Games like NightSpawn

If NightSpawn left you wanting something replayable and tense, you have options. These games line up well for what comes next. Plenty here let you team up if you like.

Horror Night
A new multiplayer, third-person, horror experience: Escape from an appaling environment by solving different puzzles with the help of your friends, and hiding from a hideous monster... or maybe becoming one ;) Unlock new maps, cosmetics and skins with the new Horror Night DLCs
Also in Co-op · Replayable, Tense, Atmospheric
53% of 286 Steam reviews are positiveFree
Dark Hours
A heist gone horribly wrong: your crew breaks in, the power dies, and something in the dark claims the building. Dark Hours is co-op survival horror for 1-4 players where you loot, hack and sneak past eight very different monsters, then escape with the goods. Or trip your friends and let them outrun it instead.
Also in Co-op · Replayable, Tense, Dark
81% of 3,597 Steam reviews are positivePlayers online now: 87$9.99
Haunt Chaser
Haunt Chaser is a 4 Player Co-Op horror game, can be played as a Single-Player too. Chasers need to use all the hunting equipment in order to banish the evil and save the poor souls from torment while uncovering deeply disturbing secrets. Also, there is a 4v1 party game mode.
Also in Co-op · Replayable, Tense, Dark
66% of 571 Steam reviews are positive$14.99
SEVERANCE
SEVERANCE is a 1-5 player online co-op paranormal investigation game where you track 20-plus ghost types with EMF meters, cameras and thermometers, then name the entity before it hunts you. The twist is you can be the haunting yourself, stalking friends as a player-controlled ghost.
Also in Co-op · Replayable, Tense, Dark
70% of 495 Steam reviews are positivePlayers online now: 3$9.99
Chased by Darkness
Chased by Darkness is a 1-4 players co-op survival horror. Your mission is to face supernatural entities and banish them to the spiritual plane. Explore, fight enemies and don't let the darkness reach you.
Also in Co-op · Replayable, Tense, Dark
73% of 325 Steam reviews are positive$3.99
PANICORE
A survival horror for up to five players: urban explorers trapped in an abandoned place, hunted by a monster that hears your steps and your voice. Find the right items, solve puzzles, pick an escape route and get out before it gets you. Hiding in a cabinet has never been this loud.
Also in Co-op · Replayable, Tense, Dark
78% of 10,843 Steam reviews are positivePlayers online now: 65$9.99
Boo Men
Boo Men is a 1-4 player co-op horror heist where you burgle haunted houses and steal from ghosts. Light keeps you safe, but every switch drains the power, so you creep through the dark flipping lamps on and off while something hungry waits for the lights to go out.
Also in Co-op · Replayable, Tense, Dark
88% of 2,097 Steam reviews are positive$7.99
Project Unknown
An online co-op horror game featuring unique playable characters and RPG mechanics. Exorcise ghosts using your special abilities and tools while surviving the supernatural onslaught
Also in Co-op · Replayable, Tense, Dark
81% of 796 Steam reviews are positive$9.99
Occult
A co-op horror quest where you and up to three friends explore cursed places, solve puzzles, dodge monsters you cannot fight, and pick which ending to chase. Loud, tense and best shared, because someone has to hear the monster coming while you hide in a closet.
Also in Co-op · Replayable, Tense, Dark
71% of 1,511 Steam reviews are positive$4.99
The Escape: Together
You and up to two friends are siblings trapped in a house a paranormal creature has claimed. Search it for keys and tools, solve puzzles together, hide when the lights die, and get out alive. A short, tense co-op horror built for one loud evening with friends.
Also in Co-op · Replayable, Tense, Dark
79% of 2,041 Steam reviews are positivePlayers online now: 8$3.99
the cabin game
Trapped in a cabin, your only way out is a card game. Every card you play reshapes the rooms around you, stirs up supernatural trouble and brings the exit one clue closer. Play solo or with up to three friends, and decide in the final hour who escapes and who stays behind.
Also in Co-op · Replayable, Tense, Dark
86% of 712 Steam reviews are positivePlayers online now: 352$11.99
DEVOUR
DEVOUR is a 1-4 player co-op survival horror game about stopping possessed cultists before they drag you to hell. You hunt ritual items, hold a UV flashlight, and run when the screaming starts. Best with friends and a steady voice chat, it turns each map into an hour of rising panic.
Also in Co-op · Replayable, Tense, Dark
90% of 69,066 Steam reviews are positivePlayers online now: 1,009$9.99

Hidden gems like NightSpawn

Invokyr

Roll the dice, survive whatever the house sends, and play your way out of a cursed board game together.

$12.99

the cabin game

Play cards to reshape the haunted cabin, uncover clues before time runs out, and choose who walks out alive.

$11.99

The Other Side

A co-op ghost hunt for up to six players. Gather evidence with modern ghost hunting gear, work out what is haunting the place, then track down the…

$13.99

Ghost Janitors

Grab a mop, keep the lights on and survive the ghosts haunting every job.

$9.99

CRYO

Sneak through frozen research stations, fix what went wrong, and find a way out before the thing listening for you finds you first.

$14.99

Paranormal Cleanup

Clean haunted houses while something hunts you through the halls, alone or with up to three friends.

$9.99

Paranoia Place: Escape Together

Team up with up to three friends to solve puzzles, hunt down randomly hidden items and survive a demon that grows faster the longer you stall.

$7.99

Project Unknown

An online co-op horror game featuring unique playable characters and RPG mechanics.

$9.99

Whisper Mountain Outbreak

Team up, scavenge and puzzle your way off a cursed 1998 mountain, one frantic run at a time.

$7.99

Emissary Zero

Sneak through a building that does not want you there, solve what it hides, and get out with whatever the Moon turns out to be.

$8.99

Folklore Hunter

Hunt folklore monsters through dark forests, setting traps and cameras while the creature hunts you back, alone or with friends.

$17.99

Dark Hours

Loot, hack and sneak your way out of a building that hunts you, alone or with up to three friends.

$9.99

Newest games like NightSpawn

SEVERANCE

SEVERANCE is a 1-5 player online co-op paranormal investigation game where you track 20-plus ghost types with EMF meters, cameras and thermometers…

$9.99

Escape from Playtime

You are a Smiling Critter, small and plush, loose in an abandoned toy factory with up to seven friends.

$9.99

Invokyr

Roll the dice, survive whatever the house sends, and play your way out of a cursed board game together.

$12.99

the cabin game

Play cards to reshape the haunted cabin, uncover clues before time runs out, and choose who walks out alive.

$11.99

Folklore Hunter

Hunt folklore monsters through dark forests, setting traps and cameras while the creature hunts you back, alone or with friends.

$17.99

Midnight Mayhem

Work together to survive against an invisible monster with ever changing abilities. Asymmetric horror game best played with friends!

$6.99

Ghost Janitors

Grab a mop, keep the lights on and survive the ghosts haunting every job.

$9.99

CRYO

Sneak through frozen research stations, fix what went wrong, and find a way out before the thing listening for you finds you first.

$14.99

Dark Hours

Loot, hack and sneak your way out of a building that hunts you, alone or with up to three friends.

$9.99

Project Unknown

An online co-op horror game featuring unique playable characters and RPG mechanics.

$9.99

Infestation: Origins

A co-op horror in which you're an exterminator treating sinister infestations caused by twisted versions of classic characters and urban legends.

$7.99

Whisper Mountain Outbreak

Team up, scavenge and puzzle your way off a cursed 1998 mountain, one frantic run at a time.

$7.99