Games like MISTERY

Chasing that mysterious and tense feeling you got from MISTERY? These games offer a similar pull for your backlog. Most of them work well for a shared session.

BACKROOMS: APPREHENSION
Trapped in the Backrooms with up to 11 other people, and one of them is not a person. As a scientist you scavenge for weapons and supplies, expose the shapeshifting Skin Stealer and escape. As the monster you wear their faces and pick the team apart from inside. Proximity voice chat turns every conversation into a gamble.
Also in Co-op · Mysterious, Tense, Scary
83% of 1,407 Steam reviews are positivePlayers online now: 13$2.99
Mimicry
A terrifying online horror game where one player becomes an impostor monster. Disguise, hunt, and destroy your friends — or work together to survive. Mimicry is a fast-paced, multiplayer fun game full of deception, fear, and chaos.
Mysterious, Tense, Scary
78% of 256 Steam reviews are positivePlayers online now: 3$4.99
MIMESIS
A 4-player co-op horror where the monsters talk like your friends. Loot a post-apocalyptic building, dodge the contaminated rain and catch the last tram before midnight, all while wondering if the person beside you is still a person. Grab a microphone, gather your crew and trust no one.
Also in Co-op · Mysterious, Tense, Scary
84% of 8,776 Steam reviews are positivePlayers online now: 175$9.99
Sinister Night
In this multiplayer survival, horror, and deduction game, eight streamers enter a mysterious old building, planning to get famous via a livestream, but two of them become possessed by evil spirits. They will kill their companions and sacrifice them at the altar to complete a sinister ritual.
Also in Co-op · Mysterious, Tense, Scary
63% of 130 Steam reviews are positive$9.99
Eville
Betray your friends- and lie your way to victory. Inspired by popular multiplayer social-deduction party games such as Werewolves and Among Us, this is a new take on the concept with realtime gameplay and interaction.
Also in Co-op · Mysterious, Tense, Replayable
68% of 432 Steam reviews are positive$4.49
Whisper Mountain Outbreak
Escape room meets survival horror on a fog-cursed mountain in 1998. Explore abandoned buildings alone or with up to four friends, fight off waves of monsters, scavenge, craft, and solve puzzles to find a way out before the whispers get to you. A tense, retro-flavored co-op extraction game where every run is a scramble to escape.
Also in Co-op · Mysterious, Tense, Scary
84% of 2,481 Steam reviews are positivePlayers online now: 69$7.99
Shift At Midnight
Run a 1990s gas station by night and figure out which customers are only pretending to be human. Check IDs, cross-check files, sell snacks, mop the floor, then shoot the fakes and clean up after. Miss one and you will be boarding doors and setting traps before it comes back.
Also in Co-op · Mysterious, Tense, Scary
88% of 11,909 Steam reviews are positivePlayers online now: 2,201$9.99
Emissary Zero
A co-op horror for 1 to 4 players: you are sent into a mysterious building at night, your manager is the only help you get, and somewhere in there is the Moon. Explore, solve puzzles, manage what you find, and try to get back out alive.
Also in Co-op · Mysterious, Tense, Scary
83% of 2,785 Steam reviews are positivePlayers online now: 1$8.99
Project Winter
Eight survivors, one frozen wilderness, and at least one liar. Gather wood, repair the objectives, call the rescue, and try to work out which of your so-called allies is quietly sabotaging everything. A social deduction survival game where trust is the rarest resource on the map.
Also in Survival crafting and Co-op · Mysterious, Tense, Scary
84% of 13,655 Steam reviews are positivePlayers online now: 16$1.99
Dark Hours
A heist gone horribly wrong: your crew breaks in, the power dies, and something in the dark claims the building. Dark Hours is co-op survival horror for 1-4 players where you loot, hack and sneak past eight very different monsters, then escape with the goods. Or trip your friends and let them outrun it instead.
Also in Co-op · Mysterious, Tense, Scary
81% of 3,597 Steam reviews are positivePlayers online now: 103$9.99
Secret Neighbor: Hello Neighbor Multiplayer
One of them is the Neighbor in disguise. Collect keys, watch your friends closely, and try not to trust the wrong person.
Also in Co-op · Mysterious, Tense, Scary
86% of 14,939 Steam reviews are positivePlayers online now: 5
Evil Mansion
Evil Mansion is a first-person 3D Werewolf game with real-time voice chat. The game has a variety of occupations (such as security, doctors, detectives).and the vote system is not for vote out player, but for mark the position of the player with the most votes.
Mysterious, Tense, Scary
76% of 155 Steam reviews are positiveFree

Cheaper than MISTERY

BACKROOMS: APPREHENSION

Scavenge, investigate and escape with your team while one of them wears a stolen face and hunts you from within.

$2.99

Mimicry

A terrifying online horror game where one player becomes an impostor monster. Disguise, hunt, and destroy your friends — or work together to survive.

$4.99

MIMESIS

Loot a ruined building with your crew, dodge the rain, catch the last tram, and figure out which of you is still human.

$9.99

Project Winter

Gather, craft and repair your way to rescue while traitors among the eight work against you in the snow.

$1.99

Sinister Night

In this multiplayer survival, horror, and deduction game, eight streamers enter a mysterious old building, planning to get famous via a livestream…

$9.99

Eville

Betray your friends- and lie your way to victory. Inspired by popular multiplayer social-deduction party games such as Werewolves and Among Us, this…

$4.49

Whisper Mountain Outbreak

Team up, scavenge and puzzle your way off a cursed 1998 mountain, one frantic run at a time.

$7.99

Shift At Midnight

Run a 1990s gas station by night and figure out which customers are only pretending to be human.

$9.99

Emissary Zero

Sneak through a building that does not want you there, solve what it hides, and get out with whatever the Moon turns out to be.

$8.99

Dark Hours

Loot, hack and sneak your way out of a building that hunts you, alone or with up to three friends.

$9.99

Occult

A co-op horror quest where you and up to three friends explore cursed places, solve puzzles, dodge monsters you cannot fight, and pick which ending…

$4.99

PANICORE

Explore an abandoned place with up to five friends while a monster that listens for your steps and your voice hunts you down.

$9.99

Hidden gems like MISTERY

Invokyr

Roll the dice, survive whatever the house sends, and play your way out of a cursed board game together.

$12.99

BACKROOMS: APPREHENSION

Scavenge, investigate and escape with your team while one of them wears a stolen face and hunts you from within.

$2.99

Whisper Mountain Outbreak

Team up, scavenge and puzzle your way off a cursed 1998 mountain, one frantic run at a time.

$7.99

Forsaken Frontiers

Step into the frozen unknown in Forsaken Frontiers, a cooperative analog horror adventure set in the unforgiving embrace of an everlasting winter.

$14.99

Shift At Midnight

Run a 1990s gas station by night and figure out which customers are only pretending to be human.

$9.99

Emissary Zero

Sneak through a building that does not want you there, solve what it hides, and get out with whatever the Moon turns out to be.

$8.99

Folklore Hunter

Hunt folklore monsters through dark forests, setting traps and cameras while the creature hunts you back, alone or with friends.

$17.99

Dark Hours

Loot, hack and sneak your way out of a building that hunts you, alone or with up to three friends.

$9.99

The Anomaly Project

Your goal is simple, spot anomalies to escape. Play alone or together with up to 8 players in online co-op.

$7.99

MIMESIS

Loot a ruined building with your crew, dodge the rain, catch the last tram, and figure out which of you is still human.

$9.99

Project: Mist

Scavenge a monster-haunted island, build a moving base on rails, and uncover its secrets alone or with friends.

$17.99

Spectral Scream

Spectral Scream is a 1-4 player cooperative horror exploration game. Are you ready to face death in the maw of purgatory?

$9.99

Newest games like MISTERY