Games like Feed The Pit

Looking for that same mysterious and scary spark as Feed The Pit? You will find a few strong contenders among these games.

CARRION
You are the monster. CARRION puts you in the body of an amorphous horror breaking out of the facility that held it: slither through vents, tear doors off, eat the staff and grow. A reverse-horror metroidvania with fluid movement, grim pixel art and puzzles built around being a writhing mass of teeth.
Mysterious, Scary, Tense
94% of 33,944 Steam reviews are positivePlayers online now: 117$19.99
Mists of Aiden
Mists of Aiden is a first-person story driven horror game. You play as a thief trapped in an eerie mansion. Each choice can open a new mystery of the house and lead to a unique walkthrough and ending. Uncover final secret of the house. Uncover your own secrets.
Mysterious, Scary, Replayable
90% of 982 Steam reviews are positive$6.99
Midnight: Submersion - Nightmare Horror Story
Nightmare Horror Story an adventure game from the first face in a horror genre provides you to take a trip in a huge and dark city full of dummies. You would have a possibility to figure out in a weird atmosphere when alive people are missed and everything that had remained is the dummies.
Mysterious, Scary, Tense
86% of 123 Steam reviews are positive$4.99
Inscryption
A card game that traps you in a cabin with a masked dealer. You sacrifice squirrels and wolves to play stronger beasts, pick routes on a map, and get up from the table to pry at the walls around you. It keeps changing shape after that, and going in knowing little makes it land harder.
Mysterious, Scary, Replayable
96% of 136,426 Steam reviews are positivePlayers online now: 1,303$19.99
Life Eater
If you don't sacrifice your neighbors, the world ends. Life Eater is a horror fantasy kidnapping simulator where you must become intimately familiar with your targets' lives one intrusive action at a time... and hope that the dark god you serve is even real.
Mysterious, Scary, Replayable
85% of 332 Steam reviews are positivePlayers online now: 1$14.99
Venge
Get ready to explore a movie studio that vanished into thin air, only to find yourself trapped in a twisted, alternate dimension where creatures lurk in the shadows, waiting to ensure you never see the light of day again...
Mysterious, Scary, Replayable
91% of 372 Steam reviews are positive$4.99
HellSign
An investigative action RPG about hunting the things that go bump in the night, for pay. Sweep haunted houses with EMF readers and blacklights, match clues in your Cryptonomicon, then load the right ammo and put the ghost down. Dark, tense and atmospheric, with a slow-burn story about a brand you do not remember earning.
Also in Detective · Mysterious, Scary, Tense
67% of 2,151 Steam reviews are positive$19.99
Among Ashes
Among Ashes is a terrifying first-person survival horror game. Your friend has sent you a link to a game that someone posted online, but as you play you quickly realise that something is terribly wrong. Whatever you do… K̴͉͚̗̅̃̄E̷͓̤̺̊͠E̴̤̰̿̽P̴̠̳̀́ ̴̨̮̭̕̚P̷̠͇̳͐̓̀L̶̹̔Ả̷̧Y̵̘̺͆̓Ï̸̻̏͂N̷͙̯͊G̵͖̹̠̽̿
Mysterious, Scary, Tense
95% of 443 Steam reviews are positive$14.99
Saturnalia
A Single-Player Survival Horror Adventure: play as a cast of characters exploring an isolated village haunted by an ancient ritual—but beware, its labyrinthine roads will change each time you lose all your characters.
Mysterious, Scary, Replayable
88% of 124 Steam reviews are positive$29.99
Cat in the Box
A horror adventure about a girl who brings a camera to a cult's abandoned mansion and finds the exit gone. Search for keys and clues, dodge what hunts the halls, and pick your way through five endings in a tense, atmospheric pixel-art night.
Mysterious, Scary, Replayable
93% of 1,448 Steam reviews are positivePlayers online now: 2$6.99
My Beautiful Paper Smile
Welcome, child, to your new home. Here you shall learn the art of perfection. Here you shall learn to smile. Be sure that smile doesn’t fade into sadness, or you will need to run and hide…
Mysterious, Scary, Tense
82% of 353 Steam reviews are positive$14.99
Care
Care is an atmospheric first person horror game with puzzle elements, where your choices have consequences. Be observant with your surroundings and unravel the horrific secrets that hide within these walls.
Also in Detective · Mysterious, Scary, Replayable
93% of 74 Steam reviews are positive$9.99

Cheaper than Feed The Pit

Mists of Aiden

Mists of Aiden is a first-person story driven horror game. You play as a thief trapped in an eerie mansion.

$6.99

Midnight: Submersion - Nightmare Horror Story

Nightmare Horror Story an adventure game from the first face in a horror genre provides you to take a trip in a huge and dark city full of dummies.

$4.99

Venge

Get ready to explore a movie studio that vanished into thin air, only to find yourself trapped in a twisted, alternate dimension where creatures…

$4.99

Cat in the Box

Explore a cult's abandoned mansion with a camera, solve what holds it shut, and survive what walks inside.

$6.99

CARIMARA: Beneath the forlorn limbs

Investigate a haunted forest house as a small mute mystic who can only ask questions, one conjured card at a time.

$4.99

Horripilant

An old knight wakes in a dungeon with no memory and a voice telling him to hit a tree. Kill your god. Become worthy. Repeat.

$7.99

The Deadseat

A horror game where you play a hand-held console in the backseat during a long drive home.

$2.99

Metel - Horror Escape

Solve your way out of a killer's house, quietly, before he notices anything is wrong.

$2.99

Prognostic

An orphan returns to the house of the deceased fortune-teller to uncover the secret of his family's death.

$6.99

OPEN DOOR

A scientific experiment in which no one survives, in a first-person survival horror game made by one developer In the role of a random person who is…

$6.99

It Steals

Collect the orbs in a maze while things that hide, hunt and lie in wait try to catch you.

$4.99

The Method of Hiding a Body

A story-driven horror puzzle game where the player takes on the role of a resentful ghost, possessing others in order to search for her own corpse.

$3.99

Hidden gems like Feed The Pit

Dreadline Express

Dreadline Express is a 1st-person, psychological horror metroidbrainia set aboard the last human train.

$12.99

Crawling Angels

Smash and thrash the mysterious Forever Chicken, a living ragdoll at the heart of a frightful Midnight Carnival.

$7.49

The Deadseat

A horror game where you play a hand-held console in the backseat during a long drive home.

$2.99

THE WELL IS NOT EMPTY

Dig your way out of hell with a rusty spoon! Crawl through ancient abandoned tunnels. Discover remnants of a ritual never meant to be seen.

$9.99

Horripilant

An old knight wakes in a dungeon with no memory and a voice telling him to hit a tree. Kill your god. Become worthy. Repeat.

$7.99

Among Ashes

Among Ashes is a terrifying first-person survival horror game.

$14.99

The Horror at Highrook

The Horror at Highrook is an occult card crafting narrative RPG.

$19.99

Fear the Moon

A story driven cryptid horror game featuring survival horror elements where you come face to face with a Midwest cryptid dubbed "the Wolfman".

$6.99

Dead of Darkness

Dead of Darkness is a 2D survival-horror action-adventure. Investigate a mysterious island and unravel its disturbing secret.

$15.99

Tales Beyond The Tomb - Pineville Night Stalker

You play Megan, sorting out a strange inheritance in a town where something is watching.

Free

Folklore Hunter

Hunt folklore monsters through dark forests, setting traps and cameras while the creature hunts you back, alone or with friends.

$17.99

The Fabulous Fear Machine

The Fabulous Fear Machine is a narrative-driven strategy game with a pulp horror style.

$17.99

Newest games like Feed The Pit