Games like Fear Surrounds

Still thinking about Fear Surrounds and its tense and replayable tone? These games keep things close enough to feel familiar. You can bring friends along for most of these.

Evil Mansion
Evil Mansion is a first-person 3D Werewolf game with real-time voice chat. The game has a variety of occupations (such as security, doctors, detectives).and the vote system is not for vote out player, but for mark the position of the player with the most votes.
Tense, Replayable, Scary
76% of 155 Steam reviews are positiveFree
MISTERY
A multiplayer game of survival and social deduction. You work with others to collect materials, survive the dangers, and complete tasks. Beware of monsters, but more of the alternates disguising as your teammates. They can change into supernatural monsters and attack you at any time.
Also in Co-op · Tense, Replayable, Scary
64% of 290 Steam reviews are positive$11.99
BACKROOMS: APPREHENSION
Trapped in the Backrooms with up to 11 other people, and one of them is not a person. As a scientist you scavenge for weapons and supplies, expose the shapeshifting Skin Stealer and escape. As the monster you wear their faces and pick the team apart from inside. Proximity voice chat turns every conversation into a gamble.
Also in Co-op · Tense, Replayable, Scary
83% of 1,407 Steam reviews are positivePlayers online now: 13$2.99
Eville
Betray your friends- and lie your way to victory. Inspired by popular multiplayer social-deduction party games such as Werewolves and Among Us, this is a new take on the concept with realtime gameplay and interaction.
Also in Co-op · Tense, Replayable, Mysterious
68% of 432 Steam reviews are positive$4.49
Town of Salem
A party game of murder, lies and mob hysteria for 7 to 15 players. One of you is a Serial Killer, some of you are Mafia, and the rest of the town has to figure out who before everyone is dead. Talk, accuse, defend yourself at trial, and lie convincingly enough to survive the night.
Tense, Replayable, Mysterious
88% of 30,873 Steam reviews are positivePlayers online now: 131$4.99
Agrou
A multiplayer round of Werewolf for 4 to 12 players. Villagers debate and vote by day, werewolves hunt by night, and special roles like the seer tip the balance. Talk your way out of trouble, or talk your friends into the grave. Every game is a different argument.
Also in Co-op · Tense, Replayable, Competitive
86% of 2,261 Steam reviews are positive$4.99
Werewolves Revenge
A free social deduction game with proximity voice chat, character customization, and hundreds of secret roles for 8-12 players.
Tense, Replayable, Mysterious
93% of 83 Steam reviews are positiveFree
KILLER INN
KILLER INN is a fast-paced asymmetrical PvP shooter where you eliminate the killers (the wolves) in battle—no time for discussion or voting! Choose the right weapons, abilities, and build. Gather clues, identify the wolves, then take them down with force!
Also in Co-op · Tense, Replayable, Scary
43% of 670 Steam reviews are positivePlayers online now: 1$9.99
Sinister Night
In this multiplayer survival, horror, and deduction game, eight streamers enter a mysterious old building, planning to get famous via a livestream, but two of them become possessed by evil spirits. They will kill their companions and sacrifice them at the altar to complete a sinister ritual.
Also in Co-op · Tense, Replayable, Scary
63% of 130 Steam reviews are positive$9.99
Werewolf Party
A medieval mystery, 4 to 12 players, where villagers scheme and werewolves hunt. Sharpen your wits, trust no one, and see who makes it through the night.
Also in Co-op · Tense, Replayable, Scary
89% of 57 Steam reviews are positivePlayers online now: 1$3.19
Wolvesville
A game of lies for up to 16 players. One round you defend the village, the next you are a werewolf hunting your friends. Use special abilities, read the chat, and talk your way to victory. Short rounds, cute art, endless arguing.
Tense, Replayable, Mysterious
78% of 1,254 Steam reviews are positivePlayers online now: 36Free
Among Us
Four to fifteen of you board a spaceship, and one of you is lying. Fix wiring, watch cameras, then argue about who just walked out of a vent. It is teamwork until it is betrayal, and it is best with friends who will throw you out an airlock over nothing.
Also in Co-op · Tense, Replayable, Mysterious
92% of 663,490 Steam reviews are positivePlayers online now: 7,217$4.99

Hidden gems like Fear Surrounds

Deadly Trick

Deadly Trick is a social deduction game playable with up to 8 players. Survive the death game unfolding at school under the name "Special Class."

$8.99

Sinister Night 2

Livestream from a haunted mansion, gather clues and unmask the possessed friends hunting you before the ritual ends.

$9.99

BACKROOMS: APPREHENSION

Scavenge, investigate and escape with your team while one of them wears a stolen face and hunts you from within.

$2.99

WE ARE SO DEAD

Talk to your living friends through flickering lights and a Ouija board, and get everyone out of the haunted house before sunrise.

$7.99

LOCKDOWN Protocol

Run tasks against the clock while saboteurs work among you, and argue your way out of every accusation before the round ends.

$9.99

Wolvesville

Join up to 16 friends in a cute village where some of you are secretly werewolves, and every round is a new chance to lie well.

Free

Get Stuffed!

Get Stuffed! is an Asymmetrical Multiplayer Social Horror game.

Free

Among Us 3D

Run tasks through a colorful spaceship, argue your innocence in voice chat, and hope the impostor isn't standing right behind you.

$9.99

Midnight Ghost Hunt

A chaotic 4v4 hide-and-seek shooter where ghosts hide inside furniture and hunters hunt them with vacuums and salt shotguns.

$19.99

Deducto

A social deduction game where employees finish tasks, impostors finish them off, and meetings decide who gets fired.

Free

Horror Legends

Hack, slash, sneak, stalk, and scavenge through this asymmetrical player versus player nightmare as a deadly supernatural Legend or scrappy member…

$4.99

Mimicry

A terrifying online horror game where one player becomes an impostor monster. Disguise, hunt, and destroy your friends — or work together to survive.

$4.99

Newest games like Fear Surrounds

WE ARE SO DEAD

Talk to your living friends through flickering lights and a Ouija board, and get everyone out of the haunted house before sunrise.

$7.99

Deadly Trick

Deadly Trick is a social deduction game playable with up to 8 players. Survive the death game unfolding at school under the name "Special Class."

$8.99

diffiCULT

Step into a fully 3D medieval world of deception. diffiCULT is a multiplayer social deduction game where you must uncover hidden cultists.

$4.99

LOCKDOWN Protocol

Run tasks against the clock while saboteurs work among you, and argue your way out of every accusation before the round ends.

$9.99

Werewolves Revenge

A free social deduction game with proximity voice chat, character customization, and hundreds of secret roles for 8-12 players.

Free

Project Unknown

An online co-op horror game featuring unique playable characters and RPG mechanics.

$9.99

Sinister Night 2

Livestream from a haunted mansion, gather clues and unmask the possessed friends hunting you before the ritual ends.

$9.99

BACKROOMS: APPREHENSION

Scavenge, investigate and escape with your team while one of them wears a stolen face and hunts you from within.

$2.99

Midnight Murder Club

A horror party shooter in a pitch-black mansion where you get a flashlight, a revolver, and proximity chat.

Werewolf Party

A medieval mystery, 4 to 12 players, where villagers scheme and werewolves hunt.

$3.19

Among Us 3D

Run tasks through a colorful spaceship, argue your innocence in voice chat, and hope the impostor isn't standing right behind you.

$9.99

MISTERY

A multiplayer game of survival and social deduction. You work with others to collect materials, survive the dangers, and complete tasks.

$11.99