Games like Varney Lake

If the story-driven and mysterious rhythm of Varney Lake stuck with you, this helps. You will find a few strong contenders among these games.

Cheaper than Varney Lake

Mothmen 1966

Mothmen 1966

Mothmen 1966 is a 'Pixel Pulp' - a visual novel fusing exceptional writing and stunning illustration, inspired by mid-20th century pulp fiction and…

91% of 304 Steam reviews are positive$8.99
Grizzly Man

Grizzly Man

1983, Alaska... During the Salmon Run, a deadly figure known as The Grizzly Man terrorizes a group of tourists led by Bob, an amnesiac former Man in…

89% of 55 Steam reviews are positive$8.99
Moth Lake: A Horror Story

Moth Lake: A Horror Story

This is the story of Moth Lake, a small town that, behind its peaceful facade, hides a terrible secret.

82% of 101 Steam reviews are positive$7.99
Servant of the Lake

Servant of the Lake

Serve a strange family, solve the house's mysteries, and survive the weekend.

98% of 7,897 Steam reviews are positivePlayers online now: 257$7.99
Misadventures of Laura Silver

Misadventures of Laura Silver

Need more stress in your life? Meet Laura Silver, a paranoid and insomniac detective tasked with researching Slavic mythology.

85% of 203 Steam reviews are positive$7.99
The Bunny Graveyard

The Bunny Graveyard

You are a cursor, sucked into a computer where a bunny named Skye runs a garden with her Handy Pals. It looks adorable. It is not.

95% of 1,390 Steam reviews are positivePlayers online now: 2$6.99
Peculiar Tales of Mid-Lake Pavilion

Peculiar Tales of Mid-Lake Pavilion

On a sultry night in late August, I ran into a man carrying a peony lantern at the Mid-Lake Pavilion.

88% of 160 Steam reviews are positive$3.99
Dracula's Legacy

Dracula's Legacy

Haunted by frightening dreams about her forgotten past, Isabella, along with her fiancé, were able to decipher one clue from the depths of her…

78% of 642 Steam reviews are positive$2.99
Tales of the Black Forest

Tales of the Black Forest

Trapped in the town of Kuromori-chō, a schoolgirl travels into the past to find her way out, meeting humans and yōkai along the way.

97% of 14,942 Steam reviews are positivePlayers online now: 2$3.99
Vampires' Melody

Vampires' Melody

Play a chef out of his time, bond with a three-hundred-year-old vampire, and steer the story toward one of many endings.

97% of 5,576 Steam reviews are positive$3.99
Ghost in the pool

Ghost in the pool

A bizarre campus legend, take you into the traditional Japanese black-and-white comic horror story.

77% of 301 Steam reviews are positive$3.99
Banebush

Banebush

Hide in your childhood village, listen to the old tales, and find out which of six endings is yours.

94% of 2,205 Steam reviews are positivePlayers online now: 2$2.99

Hidden gems like Varney Lake

The Dark Rites of Arkham

The Dark Rites of Arkham

A macabre ritual murder puts Arkham PD detectives Jack Foster and Harvey Whitman to the test.

97% of 707 Steam reviews are positivePlayers online now: 1$14.99
Foolish Mortals

Foolish Mortals

Search a haunted island for a lost treasure, question its eccentric residents, and piece together a wedding that vanished thirty years ago.

94% of 721 Steam reviews are positivePlayers online now: 11$19.99
Servant of the Lake

Servant of the Lake

Serve a strange family, solve the house's mysteries, and survive the weekend.

98% of 7,897 Steam reviews are positivePlayers online now: 257$7.99
Banebush

Banebush

Hide in your childhood village, listen to the old tales, and find out which of six endings is yours.

94% of 2,205 Steam reviews are positivePlayers online now: 2$2.99
Slender Threads

Slender Threads

Harvey Green keeps dreaming of his own head mounted on a wall.

90% of 594 Steam reviews are positivePlayers online now: 3$19.99
The Bunny Graveyard

The Bunny Graveyard

You are a cursor, sucked into a computer where a bunny named Skye runs a garden with her Handy Pals. It looks adorable. It is not.

95% of 1,390 Steam reviews are positivePlayers online now: 2$6.99
Pink Noise

Pink Noise

Pink Noise is a nonlinear visual novel in the psychological horror genre, immersing you in the retro atmosphere of the '90s.

82% of 122 Steam reviews are positive$10.99
Nightmare Frames

Nightmare Frames

Nightmare Frames is a supernatural thriller where you'll step into the shoes of Alan Goldberg, in the search for the scariest horror film of all time.

97% of 430 Steam reviews are positivePlayers online now: 2$12.99
Beacon Pines

Beacon Pines

A cute, creepy storybook adventure. You play Luka, a young deer snooping into his small town's strange events, and also the reader of the book…

97% of 3,116 Steam reviews are positivePlayers online now: 10$19.99
Mothmen 1966

Mothmen 1966

Mothmen 1966 is a 'Pixel Pulp' - a visual novel fusing exceptional writing and stunning illustration, inspired by mid-20th century pulp fiction and…

91% of 304 Steam reviews are positive$8.99
Until Then

Until Then

Follow Mark through school days, first love and a mystery that slowly unravels everything he thought he knew.

96% of 16,275 Steam reviews are positivePlayers online now: 133$19.99

Newest games like Varney Lake

Super Chillers: The Chat Room

Super Chillers: The Chat Room

Travel back to the 90s in this campy point-and-click horror comedy adventure inspired by classic YA horror books like Fear Street and Point Horror.

71% of 59 Steam reviews are positive$7.99
Servant of the Lake

Servant of the Lake

Serve a strange family, solve the house's mysteries, and survive the weekend.

98% of 7,897 Steam reviews are positivePlayers online now: 257$7.99
Pink Noise

Pink Noise

Pink Noise is a nonlinear visual novel in the psychological horror genre, immersing you in the retro atmosphere of the '90s.

82% of 122 Steam reviews are positive$10.99
The Dark Rites of Arkham

The Dark Rites of Arkham

A macabre ritual murder puts Arkham PD detectives Jack Foster and Harvey Whitman to the test.

97% of 707 Steam reviews are positivePlayers online now: 1$14.99
Foolish Mortals

Foolish Mortals

Search a haunted island for a lost treasure, question its eccentric residents, and piece together a wedding that vanished thirty years ago.

94% of 721 Steam reviews are positivePlayers online now: 11$19.99
Carnival

Carnival

Carnival is an atmospheric folk horror point-&-click featuring low-resolution pixel art graphics, locations drawn from Venice itself, and developing…

99% of 72 Steam reviews are positive$11.99
Lake of Darkness

Lake of Darkness

Your small town is slowly becoming corrupted by a mysterious evil, In a dream you get a premonition of your own death.

96% of 28 Steam reviews are positiveFree
Slender Threads

Slender Threads

Harvey Green keeps dreaming of his own head mounted on a wall.

90% of 594 Steam reviews are positivePlayers online now: 3$19.99
Banebush

Banebush

Hide in your childhood village, listen to the old tales, and find out which of six endings is yours.

94% of 2,205 Steam reviews are positivePlayers online now: 2$2.99
Grizzly Man

Grizzly Man

1983, Alaska... During the Salmon Run, a deadly figure known as The Grizzly Man terrorizes a group of tourists led by Bob, an amnesiac former Man in…

89% of 55 Steam reviews are positive$8.99
Jill O' Lantern: Final Cut

Jill O' Lantern: Final Cut

Find the clues to make a time bending turnabout in this off the rails visual novel about murder, mayhem, and a thicc pumpkin girl with a machete.

100% of 15 Steam reviews are positive$6.99