The Witch's Isle
An adventure game that takes place in a dream-like town on a solitary island.
90% of 68 Steam reviews are positive$2.99
Games like Substitute Priest
If Substitute Priest scratched a story-driven and mysterious itch for you, keep reading. Start with these games when you are ready.
What have you done, Father?
A dark murder mistery game combined with a visual novel revolving around a disturbing plot. Embark on the frightening adventure of a young priest entangled in a forbidden affair with a beautiful lady who meets a gruesome end. Lust, wrath, murder, despair.
Story-driven, Mysterious, Atmospheric
91% of 141 Steam reviews are positive$10.99Gray Dawn
Embark on a terrifying adventure of a priest accused of murdering an altar boy. Gray Dawn is a psychological thriller infused with religious elements and combines story-driven quests with an artistic experience.
Story-driven, Mysterious, Atmospheric
83% of 848 Steam reviews are positive$19.99The Whispering Valley
Explore a remote village and solve complex puzzles in The Whispering Valley, a folk horror point & click game. Delve into guilt and depression to investigate the village's deepest secret.
Story-driven, Mysterious, Atmospheric
87% of 173 Steam reviews are positive$11.99Cursed Enigma - Priest and Prayers
Father Giovanni, a devout priest, becomes entangled in mysteries and secrets while overseeing his local church. Explore the dark truths and menacing events behind the serene facade of the parish in the first episode of CURSED ENIGMA: Priest and Prayers
Story-driven, Mysterious, Atmospheric
71% of 111 Steam reviews are positiveFreeThe Parish
A slow and atmospheric retro horror game. These hills hide more than just this congregation. Tend this remote church, give services to the needy and you never know... you might just survive the night
Story-driven, Mysterious, Atmospheric
100% of 4 Steam reviews are positive$5.99The Blind Prophet
A point'n'Click adventure game. Resolve mysteries and fight the Great Evil.
Story-driven, Mysterious, Atmospheric
86% of 435 Steam reviews are positivePlayers online now: 1$19.99The Wild Case
The Wild Case is a 2D first-person point-and-click adventure. In this story-focused adventure, players meet a cast of colorful characters, experience mysterious encounters, and solve puzzles to progress through the game.
Story-driven, Mysterious, Atmospheric
85% of 231 Steam reviews are positive$8.99Saint Kotar: The Yellow Mask
Follow the fear of Benedek Dohnany and Nikolay Kalyakin and play the onset of a dark and chilling narrative adventure. Make decisions and affect the events that precede a macabre series of murders, allegedly related to devil worship and witchcraft.
Story-driven, Mysterious, Atmospheric
72% of 356 Steam reviews are positiveFreeChildren of Silentown
Lucy lives in a village at the edge of a forest full of monsters. People vanish now and then, and the grown-ups just keep repeating the rules. This time a child is old enough to ask why. A hand-drawn point & click adventure with odd puzzles, a mean cat and a story that gets under your skin.
Story-driven, Mysterious, Atmospheric
86% of 1,031 Steam reviews are positivePlayers online now: 10$19.99Slender Threads
Harvey Green keeps dreaming of his own head mounted on a wall. In the strange seaside town of Villa Ventana, that nightmare starts coming true around him, one death at a time. A hand-drawn point-and-click thriller with absurd humor, a haunting score and a mystery that pulls you to the last thread.
Story-driven, Mysterious, Atmospheric
90% of 595 Steam reviews are positivePlayers online now: 3$19.99FAITH: The Unholy Trinity
A young priest returns to the house where an exorcism went wrong. With a crucifix, a lot of dread and almost no pixels, FAITH turns 8-bit nostalgia into one of the most unsettling horror stories around: demons, cultists, and a countryside that wants you dead.
Story-driven, Mysterious, Atmospheric
94% of 8,283 Steam reviews are positivePlayers online now: 68$14.99Unavowed
A demon wore your body for a year and left a trail of blood across New York. A supernatural detective story with companions, choices and endings that change with who you are.
Story-driven, Mysterious, Atmospheric
95% of 2,333 Steam reviews are positivePlayers online now: 7$14.99
Cheaper than Substitute Priest
GREXOVKA VILLAGE
You've come to the village to "recharge." An hour later, you're looking for something you've lost, sniffing incense in a barn, and arguing with…
80% of 15 Steam reviews are positive$0.99
Upstairs
A short classic point-and-click adventure with a verb-based interface and dialogue choices, where you explore a strange building, meet unsettling…
92% of 64 Steam reviews are positive$2.99
Slap Village: Reality Slap
Set in an anachronistic Western with multitude of characters and adventures to discover, Slap Village mixes up the past and the present time within…
80% of 102 Steam reviews are positive$2.99
Dark Lore Mysteries: The Hunt For Truth
A violent murder has awoken a small town with a troubled past, they thought that chapter was over with, but has it returned?
69% of 71 Steam reviews are positive$0.79
Daemonologie
A short folk horror story about the Scottish witch trials. You play the role of a witch finder.
92% of 592 Steam reviews are positivePlayers online now: 1$2.99
Scary Game 2: The Mad Shepherd
Your first day as the village's new shepherd, and the barn is already empty.
90% of 1,384 Steam reviews are positivePlayers online now: 8$1.99
The Samaritan Paradox
A writer has died. His daughter seeks the help of you, Ord Salamon, to find his secret last novel. During the search, questions will emerge.
71% of 167 Steam reviews are positive$1.99
The Third Day
The Third Day is a biblical science fiction adventure game in which we must guide Jesus in search of the truth through a story full of humor and…
80% of 115 Steam reviews are positive$0.49
1 Moment Of Time: Silentville
This is the story of Silentville - a town with no future, no past and no present.
78% of 606 Steam reviews are positive$0.99
Subsurface Circular
Play a robot detective riding an underground train, questioning passengers to solve a string of disappearances.
94% of 1,497 Steam reviews are positive$2.99
Greyfox RPG
You move into a foggy town, then wake up in the bodies of four of its residents and decide their fates.
76% of 1,813 Steam reviews are positive$1.99
Hidden gems like Substitute Priest
Slender Threads
Harvey Green keeps dreaming of his own head mounted on a wall.
90% of 595 Steam reviews are positivePlayers online now: 3$19.99
The Apocalypse Sacrifice
As an adventurer, you have unintentionally uncovered a horrifying secret hidden in the town for years.
94% of 222 Steam reviews are positivePlayers online now: 2$9.99
The Mildew Children
Featuring a blend of 2D adventure and visual novel, The Mildew Children is a grim tale about a village inhabited only by children who follow savage…
92% of 473 Steam reviews are positivePlayers online now: 1$9.99
Little Goody Two Shoes
Win hearts in Kieferberg by day, outlast the Woods' horrors by night, and let every choice steer one of ten endings.
95% of 2,275 Steam reviews are positivePlayers online now: 32$19.99
What have you done, Father?
A dark murder mistery game combined with a visual novel revolving around a disturbing plot.
91% of 141 Steam reviews are positive$10.99
Saturnalia
A Single-Player Survival Horror Adventure: play as a cast of characters exploring an isolated village haunted by an ancient ritual—but beware, its…
88% of 124 Steam reviews are positive$29.99
The Excavation of Hob's Barrow
Dig into a Victorian barrow dig that turns quiet village secrets and creeping dread into a point-and-click investigation you won't shake off easily.
92% of 2,537 Steam reviews are positivePlayers online now: 16$14.99
Children of Silentown
Help Lucy uncover why people vanish from her village, through a point & click adventure where cute drawings hide something dark.
86% of 1,031 Steam reviews are positivePlayers online now: 10$19.99
The Whispering Valley
Explore a remote village and solve complex puzzles in The Whispering Valley, a folk horror point & click game.
87% of 173 Steam reviews are positive$11.99
If On A Winter's Night, Four Travelers
A masked ball on a moving train, where four strangers take turns telling how they got aboard.
96% of 2,888 Steam reviews are positiveFree
Whateverland
Find your way out of a magical prison in this non-linear point'n'click adventure full of mini games and challenges.
86% of 126 Steam reviews are positive$14.99
FAITH: The Unholy Trinity
A young priest faces demons and cultists with nothing but a crucifix and a lot of dread.
94% of 8,283 Steam reviews are positivePlayers online now: 68$14.99
Newest games like Substitute Priest
GREXOVKA VILLAGE
You've come to the village to "recharge." An hour later, you're looking for something you've lost, sniffing incense in a barn, and arguing with…
80% of 15 Steam reviews are positive$0.99
Scholar Adventure: Mystery of Silence
Mystery of Silence is a point-and-click adventure where William, a young writer in search of inspiration, enters an abbey shrouded in silence.
91% of 87 Steam reviews are positive$7.99
CARIMARA: Beneath the forlorn limbs
Investigate a haunted forest house as a small mute mystic who can only ask questions, one conjured card at a time.
96% of 2,962 Steam reviews are positive$4.99
Slender Threads
Harvey Green keeps dreaming of his own head mounted on a wall.
90% of 595 Steam reviews are positivePlayers online now: 3$19.99
The Apocalypse Sacrifice
As an adventurer, you have unintentionally uncovered a horrifying secret hidden in the town for years.
94% of 222 Steam reviews are positivePlayers online now: 2$9.99
The Parish
A slow and atmospheric retro horror game. These hills hide more than just this congregation.
100% of 4 Steam reviews are positive$5.99
Whispers of Prague: The Executioner's Last Cut
Classic first-person point-and-click adventure game set in contemporary Prague.
93% of 58 Steam reviews are positive$9.99
Tales from Candleforth
Tales from Candleforth is a folk horror 2D point and click game with puzzles and escape room mechanics, that narrates the fairy tales from the…
86% of 153 Steam reviews are positivePlayers online now: 1$11.99
What have you done, Father?
A dark murder mistery game combined with a visual novel revolving around a disturbing plot.
91% of 141 Steam reviews are positive$10.99
The Mildew Children
Featuring a blend of 2D adventure and visual novel, The Mildew Children is a grim tale about a village inhabited only by children who follow savage…
92% of 473 Steam reviews are positivePlayers online now: 1$9.99
EVIL
You are a priest who has gone into the dark forest for a final battle against evil.
78% of 18 Steam reviews are positive$5.99
A Night at the Watermill
You wake up in an old watermill in the middle of the night ... and can't remember anything.
94% of 51 Steam reviews are positive$3.99