Games like Scared by Squares

Want something that feels scary and surreal the way Scared by Squares does? These games could fill that gap nicely. You can bring friends along for most of these.

Horror Squad
Horror Squad is a 1-4 player online co-op horror game. Assemble your squad to clear the areas cursed by terrifying creatures.
Also in Co-op · Scary, Atmospheric, Tense
55% of 516 Steam reviews are positivePlayers online now: 2$4.99
Backrooms: No Escape
A 1–6 player immersive psychological horror experience. Venture through multiple handcrafted liminal Backrooms levels, solve puzzles, explore and survive.
Also in Co-op · Scary, Surreal, Atmospheric
48% of 27 Steam reviews are positive$6.99
The Anomaly Project
Your goal is simple, spot anomalies to escape. Play alone or together with up to 8 players in online co-op. Make the right decisions to advance to the next level, or risk being reset to the beginning!
Also in Co-op · Scary, Surreal, Atmospheric
81% of 537 Steam reviews are positivePlayers online now: 1$7.99
Eronoctosis: Put Yourself Together
A two-player horror co-op where one of you carries the light and the other the camera that banishes what crawls out of your own mind. Explore a strange, oppressive dreamscape, learn each nightmare's habits, and piece yourself back together before it takes you apart.
Also in Co-op · Scary, Surreal, Atmospheric
90% of 1,904 Steam reviews are positivePlayers online now: 2Free
The Escape: Together
You and up to two friends are siblings trapped in a house a paranormal creature has claimed. Search it for keys and tools, solve puzzles together, hide when the lights die, and get out alive. A short, tense co-op horror built for one loud evening with friends.
Also in Co-op · Scary, Surreal, Atmospheric
79% of 2,041 Steam reviews are positivePlayers online now: 4$3.99
We Escaped a Twisted Game
A two-player co-op horror escape. Trapped in a haunted manor, you’ll need to solve puzzles, work together, and trust each other to make it out alive.
Also in Co-op · Scary, Surreal, Atmospheric
94% of 830 Steam reviews are positivePlayers online now: 2$4.99
Anomaly Company
You are a new hire at the Anomaly Company, sent with up to three coworkers to check if reality is still holding together. Learn every hallway by heart, spot what changed, then vote: safe or purge. Get it wrong and you start the shift over.
Also in Co-op · Scary, Surreal, Atmospheric
75% of 204 Steam reviews are positivePlayers online now: 4$7.99
Paranoia Place: Escape Together
A 1-4 player co-op survival horror where you solve puzzles, hunt for randomly hidden items and run from a demonic killer that gets faster and angrier the longer you take. Hide in lockers, banish it with a camera, and try not to scream into proximity chat where it can hear you.
Also in Co-op · Scary, Atmospheric, Tense
87% of 1,590 Steam reviews are positivePlayers online now: 6$7.99
Emissary Zero
A co-op horror for 1 to 4 players: you are sent into a mysterious building at night, your manager is the only help you get, and somewhere in there is the Moon. Explore, solve puzzles, manage what you find, and try to get back out alive.
Also in Co-op · Scary, Surreal, Atmospheric
83% of 2,785 Steam reviews are positivePlayers online now: 1$8.99
Backrooms Lost Unit
Find yourself lost in the Backrooms in this co-op journey for 1 to 4 players. Explore eerie levels, solve puzzles, and find your way out using scavenged items. Entities lurk everywhere, and the deeper you go, the deadlier it gets.
Also in Co-op · Scary, Surreal, Atmospheric
81% of 57 Steam reviews are positive$6.99
PANICORE
A survival horror for up to five players: urban explorers trapped in an abandoned place, hunted by a monster that hears your steps and your voice. Find the right items, solve puzzles, pick an escape route and get out before it gets you. Hiding in a cabinet has never been this loud.
Also in Co-op · Scary, Atmospheric, Tense
78% of 10,843 Steam reviews are positivePlayers online now: 65$9.99
Submerge
A deep-sea exploration company sends you and your friends to investigate a research facility that has mysteriously gone silent. Face terrifying events together, survive as a team, and uncover the truth hidden within the depths.
Also in Co-op · Scary, Surreal, Atmospheric
63% of 98 Steam reviews are positive$9.99

Cheaper than Scared by Squares

Horror Squad

Horror Squad is a 1-4 player online co-op horror game. Assemble your squad to clear the areas cursed by terrifying creatures.

$4.99

Backrooms: No Escape

A 1–6 player immersive psychological horror experience. Venture through multiple handcrafted liminal Backrooms levels, solve puzzles, explore and…

$6.99

The Anomaly Project

Your goal is simple, spot anomalies to escape. Play alone or together with up to 8 players in online co-op.

$7.99

The Escape: Together

Split up to search for keys and tools, stick together when the lights go out, and reach one of several endings before the creature finds you.

$3.99

We Escaped a Twisted Game

A two-player co-op horror escape. Trapped in a haunted manor, you’ll need to solve puzzles, work together, and trust each other to make it out alive.

$4.99

Anomaly Company

You are a new hire at the Anomaly Company, sent with up to three coworkers to check if reality is still holding together.

$7.99

Paranoia Place: Escape Together

Team up with up to three friends to solve puzzles, hunt down randomly hidden items and survive a demon that grows faster the longer you stall.

$7.99

Backrooms Lost Unit

Find yourself lost in the Backrooms in this co-op journey for 1 to 4 players.

$6.99

BACKROOMS: We Escape Forever

You enter a strangely familiar place, like a forgotten dream.

$6.99

Climb The Backrooms

Climb the Backrooms by throwing, stacking and outsmarting your way through physics puzzles, alone or with up to four players.

$4.99

Somewhere in the Shadow

Woke up in strange dark spot. Who has done it with you? And why? Try to get out from that scary place and stay alive...

$2.99

Inside the Backrooms

Solve shifting puzzles and sneak past six entities in endless backrooms, scarier with friends along.

$6.99

Hidden gems like Scared by Squares

Invokyr

Roll the dice, survive whatever the house sends, and play your way out of a cursed board game together.

$12.99

We Escaped a Twisted Game

A two-player co-op horror escape. Trapped in a haunted manor, you’ll need to solve puzzles, work together, and trust each other to make it out alive.

$4.99

Paranoia Place: Escape Together

Team up with up to three friends to solve puzzles, hunt down randomly hidden items and survive a demon that grows faster the longer you stall.

$7.99

Anomaly Exit

Walk the same platform again and again, memorise what you saw, and decide whether this time something is wrong.

$5.99

Climb The Backrooms

Climb the Backrooms by throwing, stacking and outsmarting your way through physics puzzles, alone or with up to four players.

$4.99

Devil of the Plague

A 1–4 player co-op horror game. Cleanse cursed lands, perform forbidden rituals, and survive a spreading plague. Fear is not scripted.

$9.99

Anomaly Company

You are a new hire at the Anomaly Company, sent with up to three coworkers to check if reality is still holding together.

$7.99

Emissary Zero

Sneak through a building that does not want you there, solve what it hides, and get out with whatever the Moon turns out to be.

$8.99

Backrooms Lost Runners

Trapped in endless yellow corridors with friends, where even a whisper can give you away.

$13.99

The Anomaly Project

Your goal is simple, spot anomalies to escape. Play alone or together with up to 8 players in online co-op.

$7.99

Spectral Scream

Spectral Scream is a 1-4 player cooperative horror exploration game. Are you ready to face death in the maw of purgatory?

$9.99

The Devourer: Hunted Souls

Play as a paranormal investigator in our hybrid between first person survival and psychological horror story game.

$9.99

Newest games like Scared by Squares