Games like Nightmariners

Still thinking about Nightmariners and its scary and tense tone? These games could fill that gap nicely. Many of them are fun to share with friends.

The Midnighters
A co-op horror game for 1–4 players. Hunt buried treasure with your detector, sell your loot, and explore a cursed village. As sanity falls, hallucinations blur what is real. Solve ritual puzzles and face the creatures lurking in the dark.
Also in Co-op · Scary, Tense, Atmospheric
88% of 42 Steam reviews are positivePlayers online now: 4$3.74
Last Pirates: Die Together
An online co-op horror for up to 4 players. Stretch your rubbery arms across a monster-haunted island, rip loot loose for your greedy captain, and get at least one crewmate back to the ship alive. Silly physics, real scares, and a story worth telling.
Also in Co-op · Scary, Tense, Replayable
77% of 421 Steam reviews are positivePlayers online now: 19$7.99
PILGRIM
A medieval co-op horror trek. You and your friends get a wagon, a few supplies and a very long road. Delve into crypts, dodge things that hunt in the dark, and find out what waits at the end of The Road. Scary, strange and best shared with people who scream loudly.
Also in Co-op · Scary, Tense, Atmospheric
70% of 3,337 Steam reviews are positivePlayers online now: 49$7.99
Darkwater
Darkwater is a co-op extraction horror game for 1 to 4 players. Command a custom submarine trapped beneath the ice of an alien moon, fight enemy vessels and deep-sea things with too many teeth, and scavenge abandoned outposts for the fuel that keeps you alive.
Also in Co-op · Scary, Tense, Atmospheric
77% of 1,006 Steam reviews are positivePlayers online now: 19$9.99
Murky Divers
Pilot a blind submarine to the bottom of the sea, swim into abandoned labs full of corpses, and shred every last piece of evidence for Pharma Corps. Up to 8 players, dwindling oxygen, and things in the dark that would rather you didn't finish the job.
Also in Co-op · Scary, Tense, Atmospheric
87% of 3,998 Steam reviews are positivePlayers online now: 29$8.99
Dark Hours
A heist gone horribly wrong: your crew breaks in, the power dies, and something in the dark claims the building. Dark Hours is co-op survival horror for 1-4 players where you loot, hack and sneak past eight very different monsters, then escape with the goods. Or trip your friends and let them outrun it instead.
Also in Co-op · Scary, Tense, Atmospheric
81% of 3,594 Steam reviews are positivePlayers online now: 103$9.99
Subterror
Explore abandoned biospheres at the bottom of the ocean, alone or with up to 4 friends.
Also in Co-op · Scary, Tense, Atmospheric
89% of 399 Steam reviews are positive$7.99
Treasure Hunters: Raid Together
Treasure Hunters: Raid Together is an intense CO-OP treasure-hunting game for up to 4 players, set in mysterious dungeons filled with puzzles, platforms, and deadly creatures, where your goal is to find and steal the most valuable treasures in the world.
Also in Co-op · Scary, Tense, Atmospheric
81% of 62 Steam reviews are positive$6.49
Don't Sleep With The Fishes
Your ship is going down and the lifeboat holds one seat besides yours. Grab what you can, fish, talk, survive the nights, and hope something out there lets you leave. A point-and-click survival horror where every day is a choice and most endings are not the good kind.
Scary, Tense, Atmospheric
95% of 882 Steam reviews are positivePlayers online now: 27$1.99
Unhuman Nightmare
Unhuman Nightmare is a 4 player online co-op game where a team of thieves want to steal items from haunted places. What they don't know is that the places are full of traps set by ghosts. Chances are, they'll not escape alive...
Also in Co-op · Scary, Tense, Atmospheric
67% of 6 Steam reviews are positive$19.99
Wreck Runners
Physics-based co-op extraction game for crews of 2-4 players. Venture into the twisted Bermuda Triangle aboard the ORCA, a hybrid utility craft that can fly, drive and dive. Gather loot, buy new equipment, and unlock cosmetics across chaotic runs.
Also in Co-op · Scary, Tense, Replayable
73% of 51 Steam reviews are positivePlayers online now: 1$9.99
Forgotten Seas
You are lost in the Bermuda Void, where the ocean is endless and dry land precious. Craft your Ship-in-a-Bottle, then experience survival on the high seas. Sail for new land, build camps, hunt for treasures, trade for goods - then defend your ship from dreaded pirates stalking this strange realm!
Also in Co-op · Atmospheric, Replayable, Mysterious
75% of 480 Steam reviews are positivePlayers online now: 6$24.99

Cheaper than Nightmariners

The Midnighters

A co-op horror game for 1–4 players. Hunt buried treasure with your detector, sell your loot, and explore a cursed village.

$3.74

Don't Sleep With The Fishes

A hand-drawn survival horror where you fish for answers by day and ration your hope by night, with endings that rarely turn out kind.

$1.99

Isle of the Night: Pirate Survivors

Survive the pirate island! Craft by day, battle waves of enemies by night in this roguelike survival game.

$2.99

Night City

"Night City" is a cooperative first-person horror game with survival elements, here you will play as one of the company's clones, and go down into…

$0.74

Trash Sailors: Co-Op Trash Raft Simulator

Trash Sailors is a hand-drawn co-op sailing adventure for one to four players.

$3.99

Midnight Looters

Midnight Looters is a 1-4 player co-op horror game where you and your friends explore mysterious forests to find valuable treasures.

$3.99

Hunter Nightmare

HunterNightmare "is a horror survival game suitable for 1-2 players.

$0.99

Midnight Cruise

As you progress, you'll need to find keys and open locked doors. Solve puzzles and find passages. A first-person game with elements of horror.

$0.99

The Escape: Together

Split up to search for keys and tools, stick together when the lights go out, and reach one of several endings before the creature finds you.

$3.99

Chased by Darkness

Chased by Darkness is a 1-4 players co-op survival horror. Your mission is to face supernatural entities and banish them to the spiritual plane.

$3.99

Horrors of Space

An alien creature is loose on your spaceship and it’s out for blood.

$2.99

Corsair`s Madness

As the captain of the pirate ship Sam, you'll dive into the adventure of a mystical archipelago brimming with secrets and treasures.

$3.19

Hidden gems like Nightmariners

Don't Sleep With The Fishes

A hand-drawn survival horror where you fish for answers by day and ration your hope by night, with endings that rarely turn out kind.

$1.99

Knights End

Work together to survive the night shift in this challenging co-op PvE horror game.

$7.99

Subterror

Explore abandoned biospheres at the bottom of the ocean, alone or with up to 4 friends.

$7.99

Voyagers of Nera

Gather, craft and settle island villages across a bright open ocean, alone or with friends.

$29.99

Last Pirates: Die Together

Rip loot from a haunted island with your crew and try to keep someone alive on the way back to the ship.

$7.99

Darkwater

Pilot a submarine through a frozen alien sea with your crew, fighting what swims out of the dark and scavenging for the fuel to keep going.

$9.99

Forsaken Frontiers

Step into the frozen unknown in Forsaken Frontiers, a cooperative analog horror adventure set in the unforgiving embrace of an everlasting winter.

$14.99

Species: Unknown

Take a contract on an abandoned ship, figure out which creature is stalking your crew, and survive the run.

$9.99

Emissary Zero

Sneak through a building that does not want you there, solve what it hides, and get out with whatever the Moon turns out to be.

$8.99

Murky Divers

A co-op horror job at the bottom of the sea: dive into sunken labs with up to eight friends, destroy what Pharma Corps wants gone, and hope the dark…

$8.99

Dark Hours

Loot, hack and sneak your way out of a building that hunts you, alone or with up to three friends.

$9.99

Forgotten Seas

You are lost in the Bermuda Void, where the ocean is endless and dry land precious.

$24.99

Newest games like Nightmariners