Games like Mothman

Remember how scary and tense Mothman felt at its best? These games make natural next picks for you. Most of them work well for a shared session.

Folklore Hunter
You are a hunter of supernatural beasts, tracking creatures like the Wendigo through handcrafted forests, caves and abandoned camps. Set traps, place cameras, solve puzzles and scavenge for ammo before the thing hunting you finds you first. Play solo if you dare, or bring friends and share the terror.
Also in Co-op · Scary, Tense, Dark
75% of 1,225 Steam reviews are positivePlayers online now: 7$17.99
Demonologist
Grab gear with up to four hunters, find what haunts a cursed place, then exorcise it. Every run brings random ghosts and events, talking spirits, and rooms that listen to what you say. Dark, tense, and built for co-op scares.
Also in Co-op · Scary, Tense, Dark
85% of 19,158 Steam reviews are positivePlayers online now: 607$19.99
The Goatman
The Goatman is an Online CO-OP hunting game. It all began on February 23, 2019 with a call for help from the Greenfield village. It was alleged that a mysterious creature like a half goat and half demon attacked people and animals. Upon this call, a military research team set out.
Also in Co-op · Scary, Tense, Dark
68% of 359 Steam reviews are positive$4.99
Boo Men
Boo Men is a 1-4 player co-op horror heist where you burgle haunted houses and steal from ghosts. Light keeps you safe, but every switch drains the power, so you creep through the dark flipping lamps on and off while something hungry waits for the lights to go out.
Also in Co-op · Scary, Tense, Dark
88% of 2,095 Steam reviews are positive$7.99
Spooky Men
Spooky Men is a online 1-8 player cooperative survival-horror game. Complete tasks and exorcise the malevolent demon. Use your wits to distract the ghost and survive its attacks as you explore the haunted property. Can you make it out alive?
Also in Co-op · Scary, Tense, Dark
72% of 25 Steam reviews are positive$199.99
Fantasma
Fantasma is a Co-op (1-4) Psychological Horror that pits players against the supernatural. Alone or as a team- coordinate a loadout, travel to haunted locations and survive being hunted by vengeful apparitions using a variety of specially designed and upgradeable equipment.
Also in Co-op · Scary, Tense, Dark
47% of 15 Steam reviews are positive$4.99
BE HUNTED
Be Hunted is a special co-op horror game, that combines ghost hunting, escape game, psychological horror, paranormal activity, and more. You can play alone, or up to 4 player for the basic gameplay mode. You will use your ghost hunting equipment to prepare yourself.
Also in Co-op · Scary, Tense, Dark
50% of 18 Steam reviews are positive$9.99
The Devourer: Hunted Souls
Play as a paranormal investigator in our hybrid between first person survival and psychological horror story game. Investigate a haunted forest with up to 5 players CO-OP, try to lift the curse, experience a tragic story and take decisions together. Will you survive or will you lose your soul?
Also in Co-op · Scary, Tense, Dark
78% of 510 Steam reviews are positive$9.99
Inout
INOUT is a cooperative horror game for 1-4 players. For years, the locals have been afraid of an old mansion in Madyland. A possessed maniac and an ancient evil have settled here. Become a member of a team of exorcists and expel the evil force!
Also in Co-op · Scary, Tense, Dark
67% of 185 Steam reviews are positive$9.99
The Midnighters
A co-op horror game for 1–4 players. Hunt buried treasure with your detector, sell your loot, and explore a cursed village. As sanity falls, hallucinations blur what is real. Solve ritual puzzles and face the creatures lurking in the dark.
Also in Co-op · Scary, Tense, Dark
88% of 42 Steam reviews are positivePlayers online now: 4$3.74
Emissary Zero
A co-op horror for 1 to 4 players: you are sent into a mysterious building at night, your manager is the only help you get, and somewhere in there is the Moon. Explore, solve puzzles, manage what you find, and try to get back out alive.
Also in Co-op · Scary, Tense, Dark
83% of 2,782 Steam reviews are positivePlayers online now: 1$8.99
Sign of Silence
Sign of Silence is a 4-player cooperative horror game set in dreadful outskirts of Danwille town. Whether you will escape the place or stay here forever depends on cautious and coordinated actions of the whole team!
Also in Co-op · Scary, Tense, Dark
52% of 1,790 Steam reviews are positivePlayers online now: 3$4.99

Cheaper than Mothman

Dark Haunting

A multiplayer co-op horror game.

$1.99

Psycho

”Psycho” is a 3D horror game that allows you to explore and survive with your friends in the terrible mystery bunker.

$1.99

Mantra

Mantra is a multiplayer (1-4 player) and single-player psychological-horror game with high tension.

$2.49

Hunter Nightmare

HunterNightmare "is a horror survival game suitable for 1-2 players.

$0.99

You Must

In the social network, the main character plays the quest "Hide and Seek", but this time the organizers decided to move the quest to the real world.

$1.99

Monster In The Dark

Monster In The Dark is a single player first-person game, you will plunge into a world of fear and hopelessness when there is no way out and nowhere…

ECO HOLE

ECO HOLE is a survival game for one or two players with unique gameplay.

$9.99

A Technician's Nightmare

This is a multiplayer survival game in a haunted house. For 1-4 players The player must successfully complete the mission, during which there will…

$1.99

Strike of Horror

Scary game PLAY AT YOUR OWN RISK

$0.99

Shadows in Silence

Shadows in Silence is a 4 vs 1 multiplayer horror game. One player takes on the role of the killer - the witch Elliana and her cat named Sharm.

$1.99

Hunt Asylum Together

Hunt Asylum Together is a 1-4 player co-op horror action game.

$0.99

Camp Wombo

Co-op survival horror game. Four friends must gather resources and repair their vehicle while surviving deadly creatures in a constantly changing…

$1.99

Hidden gems like Mothman

Paranoia Place: Escape Together

Team up with up to three friends to solve puzzles, hunt down randomly hidden items and survive a demon that grows faster the longer you stall.

$7.99

Project Unknown

An online co-op horror game featuring unique playable characters and RPG mechanics.

$4.99

Devil of the Plague

A 1–4 player co-op horror game. Cleanse cursed lands, perform forbidden rituals, and survive a spreading plague. Fear is not scripted.

$9.99

Emissary Zero

Sneak through a building that does not want you there, solve what it hides, and get out with whatever the Moon turns out to be.

$8.99

Folklore Hunter

Hunt folklore monsters through dark forests, setting traps and cameras while the creature hunts you back, alone or with friends.

$17.99

DeathWatchers

Use the specialized equipment at your disposal to locate & log as many paranormal events as possible.

$11.99

MetaPhysical

Supernatural phenomena are on the rise. In MetaPhysical you and up to 5 other friends can go on the hunt for eerie creatures to put an end to their…

$14.99

Boo Men

Raid haunted houses with up to three friends, grab everything on your list, and pray the power holds.

$7.99

A Day Out

Track strange creatures through the dark, gather your clues, and trap whatever has been picking people off, ideally before it gets to you first.

$9.99

Eronoctosis: Put Yourself Together

Explore the depths of your own psyche with a friend, using light and a camera to hold the nightmares back.

Free

The Devourer: Hunted Souls

Play as a paranormal investigator in our hybrid between first person survival and psychological horror story game.

$9.99

The Mound: Omen of Cthulhu

Raid a cursed jungle with three friends, hauling out treasure while the horrors inland twist what you see and hear.

$19.49

Newest games like Mothman