Games like Moonlight Mayhem

Loved how competitive and replayable Moonlight Mayhem can get? These games could fill that gap nicely. Many of them are fun to share with friends.

Cheaper than Moonlight Mayhem

Werewolf Party

Werewolf Party

A medieval mystery, 4 to 12 players, where villagers scheme and werewolves hunt.

89% of 57 Steam reviews are positivePlayers online now: 1$3.19
Lycans

Lycans

Lycans is social deduction in first person: up to 12 players on an island, werewolves hiding among the villagers.

91% of 317 Steam reviews are positivePlayers online now: 12$4.99
Agrou

Agrou

A multiplayer round of Werewolf for 4 to 12 players. Villagers debate and vote by day, werewolves hunt by night, and special roles like the seer tip…

86% of 2,261 Steam reviews are positive$4.99
Who's beast

Who's beast

A multiplayer medieval game of deception and survival, where players must unmask shapeshifting impostors.

100% of 21 Steam reviews are positive$1.99
Cabin of Shadows - Dueling Impostors-

Cabin of Shadows - Dueling Impostors-

You and one other survivor have escaped to an abandoned cabin in the woods after your village was attacked by a werewolf.

76% of 45 Steam reviews are positive$3.99
Silent Howl

Silent Howl

In Silent Howl, every night is a fight for survival. Villagers must unmask the Werewolves lurking among them, ready to strike from the shadows.

100% of 1 Steam reviews are positive$1.99
Strike of Horror

Strike of Horror

Scary game PLAY AT YOUR OWN RISK

69% of 68 Steam reviews are positive$0.99
Strange Town

Strange Town

Strange Town is a very enjoyable multiplayer survival game with a role-playing theme. The game can be played with 3-8 players.

80% of 10 Steam reviews are positive$4.99
Town of Salem

Town of Salem

A party game of murder, lies and mob hysteria for 7 to 15 players.

88% of 30,873 Steam reviews are positivePlayers online now: 131$4.99
Mimicry

Mimicry

A terrifying online horror game where one player becomes an impostor monster. Disguise, hunt, and destroy your friends — or work together to survive.

78% of 256 Steam reviews are positivePlayers online now: 3$4.99
Horror Legends

Horror Legends

Hack, slash, sneak, stalk, and scavenge through this asymmetrical player versus player nightmare as a deadly supernatural Legend or scrappy member…

88% of 115 Steam reviews are positive$4.99
Hour Night

Hour Night

An online multiplayer game with 3-10 players where you survive against a shapeshifting monster. Do you know who you can trust?

100% of 3 Steam reviews are positive$0.99

Hidden gems like Moonlight Mayhem

BACKROOMS: APPREHENSION

BACKROOMS: APPREHENSION

Scavenge, investigate and escape with your team while one of them wears a stolen face and hunts you from within.

83% of 1,407 Steam reviews are positivePlayers online now: 13$2.99
Lycans

Lycans

Lycans is social deduction in first person: up to 12 players on an island, werewolves hiding among the villagers.

91% of 317 Steam reviews are positivePlayers online now: 12$4.99
Mayhemers

Mayhemers

Mayhemers is a cartoony 3D brawl for up to 8 players where one team wrecks the town and the other tries to lock them up.

84% of 155 Steam reviews are positivePlayers online now: 7$6.99
Wolvesville

Wolvesville

Join up to 16 friends in a cute village where some of you are secretly werewolves, and every round is a new chance to lie well.

78% of 1,255 Steam reviews are positivePlayers online now: 36Free
Bail or Jail(OBAKEIDORO!)

Bail or Jail(OBAKEIDORO!)

A 3 minute tag-battle with extra twists! Play as a Monster who must lock everyone into jail before time runs out, or as a Human who must avoid…

82% of 189 Steam reviews are positive$19.99
Horror Legends

Horror Legends

Hack, slash, sneak, stalk, and scavenge through this asymmetrical player versus player nightmare as a deadly supernatural Legend or scrappy member…

88% of 115 Steam reviews are positive$4.99
Killer Klowns From Outer Space: The Game

Killer Klowns From Outer Space: The Game

Team up as klowns or humans in a horror match where hiding, scavenging and squeaky shoes decide who leaves the cove alive.

73% of 3,411 Steam reviews are positivePlayers online now: 13$39.99
Mimicry

Mimicry

A terrifying online horror game where one player becomes an impostor monster. Disguise, hunt, and destroy your friends — or work together to survive.

78% of 256 Steam reviews are positivePlayers online now: 3$4.99
Agrou

Agrou

A multiplayer round of Werewolf for 4 to 12 players. Villagers debate and vote by day, werewolves hunt by night, and special roles like the seer tip…

86% of 2,261 Steam reviews are positive$4.99
MISTERY

MISTERY

A multiplayer game of survival and social deduction. You work with others to collect materials, survive the dangers, and complete tasks.

64% of 290 Steam reviews are positive$11.99
Fear Surrounds

Fear Surrounds

Two hidden specters hunt the group while everyone else watches, argues and votes to unmask them before it is too late.

85% of 10,859 Steam reviews are positivePlayers online now: 24Free
Evil Mansion

Evil Mansion

Evil Mansion is a first-person 3D Werewolf game with real-time voice chat.

76% of 155 Steam reviews are positiveFree

Newest games like Moonlight Mayhem

Redhowl

Redhowl

Social deduction game for 4 to 15 players. 3 factions clash as you fortify the village and master unique roles.

97% of 29 Steam reviews are positive$7.99
Fobia Fights

Fobia Fights

An Online Multiplayer PvP Game for 2-6 Players, Thriving on Unpredictable Fobia-Filled Encounters and Chaotic Knife Fights with your Friends!

100% of 6 Steam reviews are positive$3
Who's beast

Who's beast

A multiplayer medieval game of deception and survival, where players must unmask shapeshifting impostors.

100% of 21 Steam reviews are positive$1.99
Midnight Mayhem

Midnight Mayhem

Work together to survive against an invisible monster with ever changing abilities. Asymmetric horror game best played with friends!

78% of 46 Steam reviews are positive$6.99
Wolftown

Wolftown

The classic social deduction game of murder and intrigue, now built for local multiplayer.

100% of 3 Steam reviews are positive$9.99
Werewolves Revenge

Werewolves Revenge

A free social deduction game with proximity voice chat, character customization, and hundreds of secret roles for 8-12 players.

93% of 83 Steam reviews are positiveFree
BACKROOMS: APPREHENSION

BACKROOMS: APPREHENSION

Scavenge, investigate and escape with your team while one of them wears a stolen face and hunts you from within.

83% of 1,407 Steam reviews are positivePlayers online now: 13$2.99
Midnight Murder Club

Midnight Murder Club

A horror party shooter in a pitch-black mansion where you get a flashlight, a revolver, and proximity chat.

70% of 306 Steam reviews are positive$0
Werewolf Party

Werewolf Party

A medieval mystery, 4 to 12 players, where villagers scheme and werewolves hunt.

89% of 57 Steam reviews are positivePlayers online now: 1$3.19
Mayhemers

Mayhemers

Mayhemers is a cartoony 3D brawl for up to 8 players where one team wrecks the town and the other tries to lock them up.

84% of 155 Steam reviews are positivePlayers online now: 7$6.99
Shadows in Silence

Shadows in Silence

Shadows in Silence is a 4 vs 1 multiplayer horror game. One player takes on the role of the killer - the witch Elliana and her cat named Sharm.

80% of 10 Steam reviews are positive$1.99
MISTERY

MISTERY

A multiplayer game of survival and social deduction. You work with others to collect materials, survive the dangers, and complete tasks.

64% of 290 Steam reviews are positive$11.99