Games like Killer Island

If Killer Island left you wanting something tense and scary, you have options. These games could fill that gap nicely. You can bring friends along for most of these.

Cheaper than Killer Island

Killer in the cabin

Killer in the cabin

You find yourself among a group of survivors of a bus crash in the Norwegian mountains.

81% of 47 Steam reviews are positive$6.99
BACKROOMS: APPREHENSION

BACKROOMS: APPREHENSION

Scavenge, investigate and escape with your team while one of them wears a stolen face and hunts you from within.

83% of 1,407 Steam reviews are positivePlayers online now: 11$2.99
Campfire: One of Us Is the Killer

Campfire: One of Us Is the Killer

Campfire is a 6 people multiplayer game where you play roles. You got to bluff, accuse and persuade others via voice chat.

61% of 104 Steam reviews are positive$1.99
Project Winter

Project Winter

Gather, craft and repair your way to rescue while traitors among the eight work against you in the snow.

84% of 13,653 Steam reviews are positivePlayers online now: 105$1.99
Cabin of Shadows - Dueling Impostors-

Cabin of Shadows - Dueling Impostors-

You and one other survivor have escaped to an abandoned cabin in the woods after your village was attacked by a werewolf.

76% of 45 Steam reviews are positive$3.99
VOICES LIE

VOICES LIE

Every voice at this table could be lying. Take a hidden role, choose what to reveal, and vote out whoever you can't trust—while secret moves play…

$2.99
Eville

Eville

Betray your friends- and lie your way to victory. Inspired by popular multiplayer social-deduction party games such as Werewolves and Among Us, this…

68% of 432 Steam reviews are positive$4.49
Devil's Bluff

Devil's Bluff

The 11 vs 1 online murder mystery that offers a ground-breaking take on the Survival Horror genre.

48% of 81 Steam reviews are positive$3.99
Sussy Cat

Sussy Cat

Can you find the cold-blooded killers who have infiltrated your adorable feline friends?

100% of 3 Steam reviews are positive$0.99
Grim Pastures

Grim Pastures

Grim Pastures is a third-person social deduction party game supporting 3 to 10 players.

96% of 25 Steam reviews are positive$3.99
Killer Inside Us

Killer Inside Us

This game is available to play online with your friends (4-10 people). Inside the station there are killers and crewmates.

74% of 19 Steam reviews are positive$0.89
1, 2 BLAME!

1, 2 BLAME!

Online multiplayer game where deception and truth will suit up.

100% of 7 Steam reviews are positive$3.99

Hidden gems like Killer Island

Deadly Trick

Deadly Trick

Deadly Trick is a social deduction game playable with up to 8 players. Survive the death game unfolding at school under the name "Special Class."

94% of 155 Steam reviews are positivePlayers online now: 9$8.99
Dawson Oaks Trailer Park

Dawson Oaks Trailer Park

Commit secret crimes in a trailer park while the Supervisor hunts you and a hidden Snitch sells you out.

88% of 524 Steam reviews are positivePlayers online now: 17$9.99
Castle of Blackwater

Castle of Blackwater

Castle of Blackwater is a 2D, action-packed, social deduction game with a magical twist.

90% of 181 Steam reviews are positiveFree
BACKROOMS: APPREHENSION

BACKROOMS: APPREHENSION

Scavenge, investigate and escape with your team while one of them wears a stolen face and hunts you from within.

83% of 1,407 Steam reviews are positivePlayers online now: 11$2.99
Cut That Wire

Cut That Wire

Drive into a world where a Bluff and a Bomb are separated by only a small wire, tied up by a psychopath in chairs with bombs strapped to their…

84% of 240 Steam reviews are positive$6.99
DEATH NOTE Killer Within

DEATH NOTE Killer Within

Lie, accuse and deduce with friends in tense rounds of social deduction where one player secretly holds the Death Note.

84% of 2,349 Steam reviews are positivePlayers online now: 16$9.99
Deducto 2

Deducto 2

A fun sus-like game where you backstab your co-workers and get mad at your co-workers for backstabbing you. (up to 16 players)

91% of 451 Steam reviews are positive$4.99
LOCKDOWN Protocol

LOCKDOWN Protocol

Run tasks against the clock while saboteurs work among you, and argue your way out of every accusation before the round ends.

85% of 16,756 Steam reviews are positivePlayers online now: 115$9.99
Betrayal Beach

Betrayal Beach

Crashed on a strange island, survivors must forage, craft, and complete objectives to stay alive.

78% of 253 Steam reviews are positiveFree
Deducto

Deducto

A social deduction game where employees finish tasks, impostors finish them off, and meetings decide who gets fired.

89% of 4,382 Steam reviews are positiveFree
ESPIONAGE: Mafia Evolved

ESPIONAGE: Mafia Evolved

A free-to-play Single-and-Multiplayer social deduction game in which role-based play rewards those who rely on strategy and their creative instincts.

78% of 175 Steam reviews are positiveFree
First Class Trouble

First Class Trouble

Team up to stop a rogue AI on a luxury liner, while some of your friends secretly work against you.

79% of 3,113 Steam reviews are positivePlayers online now: 26$14.99

Newest games like Killer Island

Alterum

Alterum

A multiplayer horror of spoken magic and one possessed friend in the group.

96% of 51 Steam reviews are positivePlayers online now: 58$8.99
PHOBOS

PHOBOS

A 4-8 player social deduction horror game. Solve puzzles that need real teamwork, survive monsters that each hunt differently, and figure out who…

100% of 10 Steam reviews are positive$9.99
Dawson Oaks Trailer Park

Dawson Oaks Trailer Park

Commit secret crimes in a trailer park while the Supervisor hunts you and a hidden Snitch sells you out.

88% of 524 Steam reviews are positivePlayers online now: 17$9.99
The Hidden Camp

The Hidden Camp

The Hidden Camp is a multiplayer social deduction survival game for 9 players.

100% of 3 Steam reviews are positive$6.99
Deadly Trick

Deadly Trick

Deadly Trick is a social deduction game playable with up to 8 players. Survive the death game unfolding at school under the name "Special Class."

94% of 155 Steam reviews are positivePlayers online now: 9$8.99
diffiCULT

diffiCULT

Step into a fully 3D medieval world of deception. diffiCULT is a multiplayer social deduction game where you must uncover hidden cultists.

91% of 69 Steam reviews are positive$4.99
Forest of Deceit

Forest of Deceit

A STORM IS COMING. If you can’t build shelter in a matter of days your entire group will perish.

100% of 35 Steam reviews are positive$7.99
North Hunt

North Hunt

An online social deduction game that will ruin your friendships.

75% of 24 Steam reviews are positive$6.50
Sussy Cat

Sussy Cat

Can you find the cold-blooded killers who have infiltrated your adorable feline friends?

100% of 3 Steam reviews are positive$0.99
WISE GUYS

WISE GUYS

Wise Guys is a ruthless, high-stakes social deduction game where trust is a weapon and betrayal is just survival.

90% of 197 Steam reviews are positive$8.99
Villainy

Villainy

A game of cooperation and betrayal. Gather your party of 4-10 players, but trust no one.

94% of 89 Steam reviews are positive$7.99
LOCKDOWN Protocol

LOCKDOWN Protocol

Run tasks against the clock while saboteurs work among you, and argue your way out of every accusation before the round ends.

85% of 16,756 Steam reviews are positivePlayers online now: 115$9.99