Games like Christmas Mutilator

If Christmas Mutilator scratched a scary and dark itch for you, keep reading. You will find a few strong contenders among these games.

Cheaper than Christmas Mutilator

Cannibal Abduction

Cannibal Abduction

The family is hungry and he must provide, VHS slasher survival horror.

95% of 351 Steam reviews are positivePlayers online now: 1$4.99
Bughouse

Bughouse

Play as Christopher, a kid left home alone with a terrifying STALKER on the loose!

86% of 160 Steam reviews are positive$1.99
Uninvited Guest

Uninvited Guest

Uninvited Guest is a first-person psychological horror game set in 1930. You play as a villager who was destined to end up in an old mansion.

73% of 335 Steam reviews are positive$2.49
Psychopath Massacre

Psychopath Massacre

George Dinescu kidnapped you in his home in Romania. Get out alive while utilizing a V.H.S camera to film everything that happens inside.

68% of 73 Steam reviews are positive$3.75
House of Velez part 1

House of Velez part 1

House of Velez is a horror game based around stealth/puzzle elements.

81% of 158 Steam reviews are positive$3.99
Silent Nights

Silent Nights

Silent Nights - A short horror game with realistic graphics, touching storyline and scary moments.

70% of 210 Steam reviews are positive$3.99
Christmas Horror

Christmas Horror

Santa has living for hundred years by taking away the soul of the bad children.

47% of 34 Steam reviews are positive$1.99
Vilomah

Vilomah

Play as Jake, a teen Pizza Delivery driver on the late shift - until things get BLOODY! Try to escape this DEMENTED Farm with your life!

50% of 22 Steam reviews are positive$2.99
Metel - Horror Escape

Metel - Horror Escape

Solve your way out of a killer's house, quietly, before he notices anything is wrong.

93% of 2,326 Steam reviews are positivePlayers online now: 8$2.99
ALONE?

ALONE?

Explore and experience this horror story, as you embark on an ghostly adventure unlike anything you have played before.

41% of 132 Steam reviews are positive$2.99
The Night of the Scissors

The Night of the Scissors

Scrap hunting season has gone wrong, VHS slasher survival horror.

92% of 451 Steam reviews are positive$2.99

Hidden gems like Christmas Mutilator

House 2

House 2

A hand-drawn horror where every death teaches you something new, and each loop brings another chance to outsmart the storm, the house and what waits…

89% of 234 Steam reviews are positivePlayers online now: 7$19.99
Butcher's Creek

Butcher's Creek

Hunt for snuff tapes with hammer in hand, photograph what you leave behind, and try to stay alive in a grimy nightmare with a dark sense of humor.

94% of 1,587 Steam reviews are positivePlayers online now: 1$9.99
Skinfreak

Skinfreak

The city’s most disturbing serial killer is at large and has his sights set on Belle. Can she escape this maniac’s fleshy, rotting clutches?

86% of 394 Steam reviews are positive$12.99
Evil Nun: The Broken Mask

Evil Nun: The Broken Mask

Sneak through a cursed school, outsmart a nun who learns your habits, and piece together the mask behind it all.

95% of 1,102 Steam reviews are positive$19.99
Crimson Snow (2023)

Crimson Snow (2023)

Hide from a vengeful ex in a decorated house and choose your words carefully, because your decisions decide who lives to see morning.

94% of 1,272 Steam reviews are positive$6.99
Massacre At The Mirage

Massacre At The Mirage

For less than the price of a movie ticket, experience your very own horror-fueled slasher flick in Massacre at the Mirage.

84% of 368 Steam reviews are positive$12.49
Christmas Nightmare

Christmas Nightmare

Christmas Nightmare is an atmospheric horror game about New Year's Eve.

89% of 349 Steam reviews are positive$4.99
Cannibal Abduction

Cannibal Abduction

The family is hungry and he must provide, VHS slasher survival horror.

95% of 351 Steam reviews are positivePlayers online now: 1$4.99
Stay Out of the House

Stay Out of the House

Kidnapped by a cannibal butcher, you have three days to escape his house.

94% of 1,735 Steam reviews are positivePlayers online now: 15$14.99
The Night of the Scissors

The Night of the Scissors

Scrap hunting season has gone wrong, VHS slasher survival horror.

92% of 451 Steam reviews are positive$2.99
Butcher of the North

Butcher of the North

You never received any New Year's gifts. This year, you decided to take what is yours.

75% of 119 Steam reviews are positive$2.99

Newest games like Christmas Mutilator

ALYSSA

ALYSSA

You are Alyssa, a kidnapped girl stuck in a vast mansion run by three captors: a clumsy maid, a huge clown, and a silent leader.

73% of 41 Steam reviews are positivePlayers online now: 2$13.99
House 2

House 2

A hand-drawn horror where every death teaches you something new, and each loop brings another chance to outsmart the storm, the house and what waits…

89% of 234 Steam reviews are positivePlayers online now: 7$19.99
Butcher of the North

Butcher of the North

You never received any New Year's gifts. This year, you decided to take what is yours.

75% of 119 Steam reviews are positive$2.99
Skinfreak

Skinfreak

The city’s most disturbing serial killer is at large and has his sights set on Belle. Can she escape this maniac’s fleshy, rotting clutches?

86% of 394 Steam reviews are positive$12.99
Nightmare Shift

Nightmare Shift

Take on night shifts at a remote motel, handle unsettling guests, and navigate eerie events.

73% of 215 Steam reviews are positive$8.99
Manivore

Manivore

He doesn’t just hunt to kill. Manivore is not just a murderer, he is an artist. For him, death is not an outcome but a process.

69% of 153 Steam reviews are positive$6.99
Butcher's Creek

Butcher's Creek

Hunt for snuff tapes with hammer in hand, photograph what you leave behind, and try to stay alive in a grimy nightmare with a dark sense of humor.

94% of 1,587 Steam reviews are positivePlayers online now: 1$9.99
The Inn-Sanity

The Inn-Sanity

Survive a hotel full of people turning into monsters, where every word you say shapes who survives.

96% of 1,590 Steam reviews are positive$7.99
Massacre At The Mirage

Massacre At The Mirage

For less than the price of a movie ticket, experience your very own horror-fueled slasher flick in Massacre at the Mirage.

84% of 368 Steam reviews are positive$12.49
Tormenture

Tormenture

Tormenture is a psychological horror game where you play as a child trapped in a cursed 8-bit game with a dark secret.

87% of 210 Steam reviews are positivePlayers online now: 1$14.99