Co-op games like Shift At Midnight

If Shift At Midnight left you wanting something tense and scary, you have options. These co-op games offer a similar pull for your backlog. Sharing the fun is easy with these picks.

Cheaper than Shift At Midnight

Boo Men

Boo Men

Boo Men is a 1-4 player online co-op horror heist where you and your co-op friends break into haunted houses to steal a list of valuables.

88% of 2,099 Steam reviews are positive$7.99
Emissary Zero

Emissary Zero

Emissary Zero sends you and up to three co-op friends into a shifting building at night to find the Moon and get out alive.

83% of 2,785 Steam reviews are positivePlayers online now: 2$8.99
Occult

Occult

You and your co-op friends get hired by Redemption to clean up cursed places instead of going to jail.

71% of 1,511 Steam reviews are positive$4.99
Pacify

Pacify

Pacify is an online co-op horror game where you and co-op friends take paranormal capture jobs for PAH Inc.

86% of 33,007 Steam reviews are positivePlayers online now: 54$4.99
Paranoia Place: Escape Together

Paranoia Place: Escape Together

A 1-4 player online co-op survival horror where you and co-op friends search creepy locations for keys and items, solve puzzles, and keep moving…

87% of 1,589 Steam reviews are positivePlayers online now: 15$7.99
Knights End

Knights End

Work the deadly night shift as banished knights, completing tasks for villagers while horrors hunt you across a cursed kingdom.

89% of 314 Steam reviews are positivePlayers online now: 10$7.99
Stay Close

Stay Close

Stay Close drops you and a friend in a creepy, anomalous town as an unfortunate couple trying to get out.

62% of 1,501 Steam reviews are positive$8.99
Zort

Zort

Zort is a first-person co-op horror game for up to four co-op friends, built around searching maps together for a way out.

90% of 11,883 Steam reviews are positivePlayers online now: 27$4
The Escape: Together

The Escape: Together

You and up to two co-op friends play siblings trapped in a house stalked by a paranormal creature.

79% of 2,042 Steam reviews are positivePlayers online now: 8$3.99
BACKROOMS: APPREHENSION

BACKROOMS: APPREHENSION

Trapped in the yellow Backrooms with up to 12 co-op friends, you scavenge supplies and weapons while one of you is secretly the shapeshifting Skin…

83% of 1,409 Steam reviews are positivePlayers online now: 11$2.99
We Escaped a Twisted Game

We Escaped a Twisted Game

A two-player co-op horror escape. Trapped in a haunted manor, you’ll need to solve puzzles, work together, and trust each other to make it out alive.

94% of 830 Steam reviews are positivePlayers online now: 6$4.99
Horror Squad

Horror Squad

Horror Squad is a 1-4 player online co-op horror game. Assemble your squad to clear the areas cursed by terrifying creatures.

55% of 517 Steam reviews are positive$4.99

Hidden gems like Shift At Midnight

Invokyr

Invokyr

A cursed 1970s board game has you and up to five co-op friends rolling dice in a creaking house, then surviving whatever crawls out.

93% of 1,523 Steam reviews are positivePlayers online now: 1,143$12.99
We Escaped a Twisted Game

We Escaped a Twisted Game

A two-player co-op horror escape. Trapped in a haunted manor, you’ll need to solve puzzles, work together, and trust each other to make it out alive.

94% of 830 Steam reviews are positivePlayers online now: 6$4.99
The Last Gas Station

The Last Gas Station

You and a friend inherit a crumbling gas station in a world that moved on to electric cars.

88% of 1,550 Steam reviews are positivePlayers online now: 42$13.99
Midnight Heist

Midnight Heist

Sneak into dark office buildings with up to three co-op friends, hack computers, grab loot, and get out before the entity finds you.

92% of 391 Steam reviews are positivePlayers online now: 3$9.99
Knights End

Knights End

Work the deadly night shift as banished knights, completing tasks for villagers while horrors hunt you across a cursed kingdom.

89% of 314 Steam reviews are positivePlayers online now: 10$7.99
Happy's Humble Burger Cult

Happy's Humble Burger Cult

A fast-food shift for 1-4 co-op friends where you grill burgers, fry sides, pour drinks and work the register to hit quota, then run for it when…

85% of 581 Steam reviews are positivePlayers online now: 41$9.99
Ghost Janitors

Ghost Janitors

Ghost Janitors puts you and up to three co-op friends on cleaning duty in haunted houses.

87% of 1,081 Steam reviews are positivePlayers online now: 42$9.99
Paranormal Cleanup

Paranormal Cleanup

Clock in with up to three co-op friends to scrub ectoplasm, unclog toilets, and haul moldy pizzas out of haunted houses, schools, and camps.

87% of 1,014 Steam reviews are positivePlayers online now: 35$9.99
Paranoia Place: Escape Together

Paranoia Place: Escape Together

A 1-4 player online co-op survival horror where you and co-op friends search creepy locations for keys and items, solve puzzles, and keep moving…

87% of 1,589 Steam reviews are positivePlayers online now: 15$7.99
BACKROOMS: APPREHENSION

BACKROOMS: APPREHENSION

Trapped in the yellow Backrooms with up to 12 co-op friends, you scavenge supplies and weapons while one of you is secretly the shapeshifting Skin…

83% of 1,409 Steam reviews are positivePlayers online now: 11$2.99
Roadside Research

Roadside Research

Roadside Research puts you and up to three co-op friends in charge of a gas station, except you are aliens in paper masks studying humans for an…

85% of 4,141 Steam reviews are positivePlayers online now: 97$14.99
Whisper Mountain Outbreak

Whisper Mountain Outbreak

Trapped in fog on Mt. Bisik in 1998, you and up to three co-op friends explore abandoned buildings, fight monsters in waves, solve puzzles, and find…

84% of 2,488 Steam reviews are positivePlayers online now: 54$7.99

Newest co-op games like Shift At Midnight

Escape from Playtime

Escape from Playtime

You and up to seven co-op friends are tiny Smiling Critters lost in a toy factory that rearranges itself.

74% of 2,709 Steam reviews are positivePlayers online now: 252$9.99
Invokyr

Invokyr

A cursed 1970s board game has you and up to five co-op friends rolling dice in a creaking house, then surviving whatever crawls out.

93% of 1,523 Steam reviews are positivePlayers online now: 1,143$12.99
Happy's Humble Burger Cult

Happy's Humble Burger Cult

A fast-food shift for 1-4 co-op friends where you grill burgers, fry sides, pour drinks and work the register to hit quota, then run for it when…

85% of 581 Steam reviews are positivePlayers online now: 41$9.99
Storebound

Storebound

Storebound traps 1-3 co-op friends in a cursed megastore for a six-episode, 5-to-7-hour escape.

76% of 1,108 Steam reviews are positivePlayers online now: 16$7.99
The Last Gas Station

The Last Gas Station

You and a friend inherit a crumbling gas station in a world that moved on to electric cars.

88% of 1,550 Steam reviews are positivePlayers online now: 42$13.99
Night Shippers

Night Shippers

You signed up to deliver food in the underworld, alone or with up to 8 friends. Everynight your work condition changes.

74% of 297 Steam reviews are positive$7.99
Knights End

Knights End

Work the deadly night shift as banished knights, completing tasks for villagers while horrors hunt you across a cursed kingdom.

89% of 314 Steam reviews are positivePlayers online now: 10$7.99
Roadside Research

Roadside Research

Roadside Research puts you and up to three co-op friends in charge of a gas station, except you are aliens in paper masks studying humans for an…

85% of 4,141 Steam reviews are positivePlayers online now: 97$14.99
Folklore Hunter

Folklore Hunter

Track urban legends with co-op friends in Folklore Hunter: three handcrafted hunts for the Wendigo, the vampire and the Mothman, with clues…

75% of 1,226 Steam reviews are positivePlayers online now: 5$17.99
Ghost Janitors

Ghost Janitors

Ghost Janitors puts you and up to three co-op friends on cleaning duty in haunted houses.

87% of 1,081 Steam reviews are positivePlayers online now: 42$9.99
Im Bann Der Dunklen Jagd

Im Bann Der Dunklen Jagd

Two detectives. Five eerie levels. One fight for survival. Explore dark locations with a friend in this free two-player co-op horror game.

70% of 233 Steam reviews are positiveFree
MIMESIS

MIMESIS

MIMESIS is a 4-player online co-op survival horror game where something in the building sounds exactly like your friends.

84% of 8,807 Steam reviews are positivePlayers online now: 172$9.99