Games like Ultimate Custom Night

Still thinking about Ultimate Custom Night and its tense and scary tone? Start with these games when you are ready.

Five Nights at Freddy's: Sister Location
A night technician job at Circus Baby's Pizza World sounds easy: check the animatronics, fix what's broken, clock out. But the job is underground, the robots are smarter than they should be, and the job listing does not cover death or dismemberment. Each night brings a different task, a creeping story and robots that talk to you.
Tense, Scary, Funny
90% of 11,552 Steam reviews are positivePlayers online now: 42$7.99
myPOPGOES
"Of course you'll never get to experience Freddy Fazbear's Pizza like I did. And maybe that's a good thing. But a few months ago, I wondered... What if Popgoes could?"
Tense, Scary, Replayable
86% of 759 Steam reviews are positive$4.99
CASE 2: Animatronics Survival
A horror prequel where Jack, a man with a past, tries to survive machines built to kill. Play the story alone, creeping through dark corridors with a tablet of security cameras, or take a match online: one player becomes the animatronic, three try to stay alive. It is tense, difficult and unfair on purpose.
Tense, Scary, Funny
81% of 3,168 Steam reviews are positivePlayers online now: 7$9.99
POPGOES Arcade
A retro RPG where Popgoes the Weasel battles the corrupt animals of a forest, twice over. Two full campaigns, turn-based fights that grow into real puzzles, and layers of secrets for FNAF fans to dig through. Colourful, funny, and quietly unsettling when it wants to be.
Tense, Scary, Replayable
96% of 1,459 Steam reviews are positivePlayers online now: 12$4.99
Poppy Playtime
A first-person horror puzzle game in an abandoned toy factory where every employee vanished one day. Its toys are still around, and they are not friendly. Solve puzzles with a two-handed GrabPack, dig through VHS tapes for the truth, and don't get caught.
Tense, Scary, Funny
88% of 144,462 Steam reviews are positivePlayers online now: 653Free
The Deadseat
A horror game where you play a hand-held console in the backseat during a long drive home.
Tense, Scary, Replayable
97% of 628 Steam reviews are positivePlayers online now: 1$2.99
My Friendly Neighborhood
A dead Saturday morning puppet show starts broadcasting again, and the puppets are eating each other. The city sends repairman Gordon to fix the antenna. What he finds is a survival horror adventure with clever puzzles, letter-shooting weapons and a story that turns out to be about far more than scary puppets.
Tense, Scary, Replayable
96% of 2,539 Steam reviews are positivePlayers online now: 27$29.99
Shift At Midnight
Run a 1990s gas station by night and figure out which customers are only pretending to be human. Check IDs, cross-check files, sell snacks, mop the floor, then shoot the fakes and clean up after. Miss one and you will be boarding doors and setting traps before it comes back.
Tense, Scary, Replayable
88% of 11,909 Steam reviews are positivePlayers online now: 2,201$9.99
Spooky's Jump Scare Mansion
A cute little mansion invites you through 1000 rooms.
Tense, Scary, Replayable
92% of 15,642 Steam reviews are positivePlayers online now: 30Free
Julian & Friends
Join Julian and his friends in this psychological horror experience inspired by point-n-click computer games from the early 2000s. Witness many shenanigans with characters from the infamous 98xx.
Tense, Scary, Replayable
90% of 315 Steam reviews are positive$3.99
Finding Frankie
A parkour game show where the prize is staying alive. Find a secret invitation in a cereal box, race two other contestants through obstacle courses, and outrun Frankie and his cartoon friends who have stopped pretending to be friendly. Fast, tense and darkly funny, it mixes horror with wall jumps, rail grinds and swinging bars.
Tense, Scary, Funny
90% of 1,937 Steam reviews are positivePlayers online now: 8$14.99
Zardy's Maze
A horror game about doing yard work at midnight. Take an axe and a flashlight into a corn maze, cut down the giant weeds growing there, and stay out of reach of whatever is walking the rows with you. Every maze is new, every enemy hunts differently, and it is brutally hard in the best way.
Tense, Scary, Replayable
91% of 1,605 Steam reviews are positiveFree

Hidden gems like Ultimate Custom Night

The Deadseat

A horror game where you play a hand-held console in the backseat during a long drive home.

$2.99

the cabin game

Play cards to reshape the haunted cabin, uncover clues before time runs out, and choose who walks out alive.

$11.99

Happy's Humble Burger Cult

A fast-food shift with a body count. Grill burgers, fry sides and hit your quota with up to three friends before the mascot breaks loose and hunts…

$9.99

Julian & Friends

Join Julian and his friends in this psychological horror experience inspired by point-n-click computer games from the early 2000s.

$3.99

Finding Frankie

A parkour game show where the prize is staying alive. Find a secret invitation in a cereal box, race two other contestants through obstacle courses…

$14.99

Project Unknown

An online co-op horror game featuring unique playable characters and RPG mechanics.

$9.99

Welcome to the Game III

Simon owes dangerous people money, and tonight the only way out is The Game: dig through the dark net for hidden puzzle pieces, hack other PCs while…

$19.99

myPOPGOES

"Of course you'll never get to experience Freddy Fazbear's Pizza like I did. And maybe that's a good thing. But a few months ago, I wondered...

$4.99

Forsaken Frontiers

Step into the frozen unknown in Forsaken Frontiers, a cooperative analog horror adventure set in the unforgiving embrace of an everlasting winter.

$14.99

My Friendly Neighborhood

Repair a dead TV studio where the felt stars have turned hostile, shooting letters and piecing together what went wrong.

$29.99

Shift At Midnight

Run a 1990s gas station by night and figure out which customers are only pretending to be human.

$9.99

That's not my Neighbor

Decide which neighbors are human and which doppelgangers get turned away, one nervous shift at a time.

$2.99

Newest games like Ultimate Custom Night

Escape from Playtime

You are a Smiling Critter, small and plush, loose in an abandoned toy factory with up to seven friends.

$9.99

the cabin game

Play cards to reshape the haunted cabin, uncover clues before time runs out, and choose who walks out alive.

$11.99

Shift At Midnight

Run a 1990s gas station by night and figure out which customers are only pretending to be human.

$9.99

Happy's Humble Burger Cult

A fast-food shift with a body count. Grill burgers, fry sides and hit your quota with up to three friends before the mascot breaks loose and hunts…

$9.99

Welcome to the Game III

Simon owes dangerous people money, and tonight the only way out is The Game: dig through the dark net for hidden puzzle pieces, hack other PCs while…

$19.99

Dark Hours

Loot, hack and sneak your way out of a building that hunts you, alone or with up to three friends.

$9.99

Project Unknown

An online co-op horror game featuring unique playable characters and RPG mechanics.

$9.99

Midnight Murder Club

A horror party shooter in a pitch-black mansion where you get a flashlight, a revolver, and proximity chat.

Five Nights at Freddy's: Secret of the Mimic

Search an abandoned workshop for clues while a prototype that can become anything hunts you through the shadows.

$39.99

Forsaken Frontiers

Step into the frozen unknown in Forsaken Frontiers, a cooperative analog horror adventure set in the unforgiving embrace of an everlasting winter.

$14.99

The Deadseat

A horror game where you play a hand-held console in the backseat during a long drive home.

$2.99

That's not my Neighbor

Decide which neighbors are human and which doppelgangers get turned away, one nervous shift at a time.

$2.99