Greyfox RPG
You move into a foggy town, then wake up in the bodies of four of its residents and decide their fates.
76% of 1,810 Steam reviews are positive$1.99
Games like Toymaker
If Toymaker left you wanting something dark and story-driven, you have options. These games line up well for what comes next.
The Pale City
The Pale City is a story-driven, dark fantasy RPG with an emphasis on characterization and atmosphere. Explore a dangerous, morally complex world where every detail is personal.
Dark, Story-driven, Retro
97% of 35 Steam reviews are positive$7.99Grimm's Hollow
A short, sweet RPG about death that somehow keeps smiling. A story that sticks with you long after the credits, in one cozy evening.
Dark, Story-driven, Retro
98% of 14,678 Steam reviews are positivePlayers online now: 6FreeMothlight
In a world corrupted by Eldritch abominations, Enzo must climb out of the hellish depths of the universe. From the Black Sea to the Planes of Neethan, it is your job to make your pilgrimage back to the Worlds above. In the black hell of this world, only Moths and demons await you.
Dark, Story-driven, Scary
93% of 417 Steam reviews are positiveFreeFAREWELL SEN
MAKE FRIENDS WITH GHOSTS
Dark, Story-driven, Retro
94% of 174 Steam reviews are positiveFreeGreyfox RPG
A short, quiet RPG about waking up in other people's bodies. You arrive in the foggy town of Greyfox, spend a day inside four of its elderly residents, and decide whether each of them lives or dies. No combat, just conversations, small puzzles and choices that weigh on you.
Dark, Story-driven, Retro
76% of 1,810 Steam reviews are positive$1.99Road Not Taken
Road Not Taken is a roguelike puzzle game about surviving life’s surprises. You play as a ranger adventuring through a vast, unforgiving forest in the aftermath of a brutal winter storm, rescuing children who have lost their way.
Story-driven, Emotional, Atmospheric
80% of 252 Steam reviews are positive$14.99Camp Whittlewood
A short, old-school horror RPG set at a scout camp in the woods. A campfire story about a woodcarver who stalks Camp Whittlewood starts coming true, and your weekend of outdoor fun turns into something much worse. Dig into the camp's history, befriend (or avoid) your fellow scouts, and see which of several endings you earn.
Dark, Story-driven, Retro
96% of 104 Steam reviews are positivePlayers online now: 2$4.99Ember
Ember is a homage to classic role-playing games (RPG) that features a deep branching story, endless exploration across dynamic and living environments, a robust skill system, and an intricate crafting system.
Story-driven, Retro, Atmospheric
75% of 907 Steam reviews are positive$9.99Smoke and Sacrifice
Smoke and Sacrifice sees Sachi, a mother forced to give up her son, adventure into a grotesque underworld on a quest that will lead her to a darker truth.
Dark, Story-driven, Retro
79% of 268 Steam reviews are positive$2.99Everdine - A Lost Girl's Tale
Everdine finds herself lost in a forest of eternal twilight. Help her gather the needed ingredients to perform a magic ritual to escape before the dangers of these woods devour poor Everdine. ~ A short, atmospheric, fairy tale vibes RPG Maker horror adventure.
Dark, Story-driven, Retro
80% of 41 Steam reviews are positive$4.99Tide Up
Tide Up is a rather dark and gloomy adventure game. Accompany the girl in a dreamlike world of wonder. Collect the pearls scattered around the world and help the girl escape!
Dark, Story-driven, Retro
93% of 256 Steam reviews are positive$7.99Little Goody Two Shoes
Elise dreams of getting rich, and a pair of shiny red shoes buried in her backyard might be her way out. By day, charm the villagers of Kieferberg and earn your keep; by night, survive the Woods and its deadly secrets. A hand-painted horror fairytale with romance, ten endings and choices that all count.
Dark, Story-driven, Retro
95% of 2,270 Steam reviews are positivePlayers online now: 32$19.99
Cheaper than Toymaker
Camp Whittlewood
Uncover the dark history of a scout camp while a woodcarver legend turns real, and choose which ending your weekend earns.
96% of 104 Steam reviews are positivePlayers online now: 2$4.99
Smoke and Sacrifice
Smoke and Sacrifice sees Sachi, a mother forced to give up her son, adventure into a grotesque underworld on a quest that will lead her to a darker…
79% of 268 Steam reviews are positive$2.99
Everdine - A Lost Girl's Tale
Everdine finds herself lost in a forest of eternal twilight.
80% of 41 Steam reviews are positive$4.99
To Light: Ex Umbra
Plagued by tangible darkness, a princess and a young man guided by a mysterious force must travel across the world to find the secret to defeating…
88% of 17 Steam reviews are positive$4.99
Forever Home
Retro RPG that takes inspiration from SNES and PS1 classics.
92% of 163 Steam reviews are positive$1.99
Just Ignore Them
Monsters live in Mark's house, and his mother says to just ignore them. Then one night goes very wrong.
78% of 695 Steam reviews are positivePlayers online now: 9$3.99
Dark Fear
Dark Fear is a pixel horror game with RPG and adventure game elements. Explore a diverse landscape filled with forests, mountains, lakes and deserts.
92% of 139 Steam reviews are positive$3.99
There Swings a Skull: Grim Tidings
Enter the doomed town of Pareildas. Watch as the flames turn bone and stone to ash. Like joined wicks, we'll all burn together.
95% of 66 Steam reviews are positive$6.98
ToyMaker
A creepy lost-media videogame from the past will haunt your dreams.
100% of 16 Steam reviews are positive$0.99
Ouroboros
Ouroboros presents a bright, cheerful world in which something is horrifyingly wrong.
93% of 148 Steam reviews are positive$4.99
Land of Ghosts
A literary horror adventure made in RPG Maker MV, where you explore a land of endless rain and continue a lonely journey through fleeting encounters…
96% of 125 Steam reviews are positivePlayers online now: 1$4.50
Hidden gems like Toymaker
Land of Ghosts
A literary horror adventure made in RPG Maker MV, where you explore a land of endless rain and continue a lonely journey through fleeting encounters…
96% of 125 Steam reviews are positivePlayers online now: 1$4.50
Sinner Maker
Run a village of flawed little souls after the Rapture, juggling homes, food, love lives and sins to earn your way into heaven.
90% of 699 Steam reviews are positivePlayers online now: 64$9.66
Camp Whittlewood
Uncover the dark history of a scout camp while a woodcarver legend turns real, and choose which ending your weekend earns.
96% of 104 Steam reviews are positivePlayers online now: 2$4.99
The Necromancer's Tale
Decipher a forbidden spellbook, investigate your father's death and keep your necromancy secret in an 18th-century town that would hang you for it.
91% of 979 Steam reviews are positivePlayers online now: 16$24.99
The RPG
Raid a fantasy dungeon that doubles as a tourist attraction, while a glitching dragon unravels the game around you.
85% of 869 Steam reviews are positivePlayers online now: 10$14.99
The Mildew Children
Featuring a blend of 2D adventure and visual novel, The Mildew Children is a grim tale about a village inhabited only by children who follow savage…
92% of 473 Steam reviews are positive$9.99
Little Goody Two Shoes
Win hearts in Kieferberg by day, outlast the Woods' horrors by night, and let every choice steer one of ten endings.
95% of 2,270 Steam reviews are positivePlayers online now: 32$19.99
Svarog's Dream
A soul drifting from body to body through a mythic open world, where every death reshapes the story and the ending is yours to decide.
89% of 906 Steam reviews are positivePlayers online now: 11$21
Pocket Mirror ~ GoldenerTraum
Wander a twisted gothic mansion, solve its puzzles and let your choices decide which ending you earn.
92% of 1,617 Steam reviews are positivePlayers online now: 22$10.99
Blackout Hospital
When the power goes out while working night shift in the hospital, the emergency lights come on with an eerie glow...
96% of 189 Steam reviews are positiveFree
Drova - Forsaken Kin
A 2D action RPG where Celtic myth meets grim dark fantasy. You arrive in a world whose captured spirits are furious, pick a side between two…
93% of 9,658 Steam reviews are positivePlayers online now: 122$24.99
Newest games like Toymaker
Camp Whittlewood
Uncover the dark history of a scout camp while a woodcarver legend turns real, and choose which ending your weekend earns.
96% of 104 Steam reviews are positivePlayers online now: 2$4.99
Sinner Maker
Run a village of flawed little souls after the Rapture, juggling homes, food, love lives and sins to earn your way into heaven.
90% of 699 Steam reviews are positivePlayers online now: 64$9.66
Land of Ghosts
A literary horror adventure made in RPG Maker MV, where you explore a land of endless rain and continue a lonely journey through fleeting encounters…
96% of 125 Steam reviews are positivePlayers online now: 1$4.50
The RPG
Raid a fantasy dungeon that doubles as a tourist attraction, while a glitching dragon unravels the game around you.
85% of 869 Steam reviews are positivePlayers online now: 10$14.99
The Necromancer's Tale
Decipher a forbidden spellbook, investigate your father's death and keep your necromancy secret in an 18th-century town that would hang you for it.
91% of 979 Steam reviews are positivePlayers online now: 16$24.99
Drova - Forsaken Kin
A 2D action RPG where Celtic myth meets grim dark fantasy. You arrive in a world whose captured spirits are furious, pick a side between two…
93% of 9,658 Steam reviews are positivePlayers online now: 122$24.99
Traveller's Hymn
Traveller's Hymn is a top-down, grid-based, open-world adventure game.
93% of 180 Steam reviews are positiveFree
The Mildew Children
Featuring a blend of 2D adventure and visual novel, The Mildew Children is a grim tale about a village inhabited only by children who follow savage…
92% of 473 Steam reviews are positive$9.99
Death of Marionette
Strange things start to happen at a ruined factory where Sawyer and her friends arrive to prepare an event. Can they leave the place safely?
92% of 53 Steam reviews are positive$6.99
DOLL EYE: CHAPTER ONE
DOLL EYE: CHAPTER ONE is the first part of a dialogue-based, story-driven psychological horror game made in RPG Maker MZ.
75% of 173 Steam reviews are positiveFree
Svarog's Dream
A soul drifting from body to body through a mythic open world, where every death reshapes the story and the ending is yours to decide.
89% of 906 Steam reviews are positivePlayers online now: 11$21
Little Goody Two Shoes
Win hearts in Kieferberg by day, outlast the Woods' horrors by night, and let every choice steer one of ten endings.
95% of 2,270 Steam reviews are positivePlayers online now: 32$19.99