Games like The Consuming Shadow

If the replayable and tense rhythm of The Consuming Shadow stuck with you, this helps. You might settle into these games easily.

Lovecraft's Untold Stories
Lovecraft’s Untold Stories is an action roguelite with RPG elements. Explore randomly generated levels based in Lovecraft's stories, fight cultists and all kinds of monsters from the Mythos, improve your gear, solve puzzles, and find clues and knowledge to defeat the Great Old Ones.
Replayable, Tense, Dark
78% of 681 Steam reviews are positive$14.99
Eldritch
A first-person roguelike with a Lovecraftian streak: sneak, fight and cast your way through randomly generated dungeons, where every death sends you back to the start and every run plays out differently. Short, tense sessions that make one more go hard to resist.
Replayable, Tense, Dark
88% of 1,699 Steam reviews are positive$14.99
WORLD OF HORROR
A 1-bit horror RPG drawn entirely in MS Paint, set in a Japan where the Old Gods are waking up. Investigate randomized mysteries, fight through turn-based combat and make choices that all seem to end badly. Short, cruel runs, a haunting chiptune soundtrack, and cosmic dread in every pixel.
Replayable, Tense, Dark
89% of 9,100 Steam reviews are positivePlayers online now: 319$19.99
Source of Madness
A side-scrolling action roguelite in the Loam Lands, a grim Lovecraftian world where every monster is generated fresh and animated by a neural network. Blast abominations apart with close-combat magic, loot rings and spells, and push a new Acolyte through a nightmarish odyssey where no two runs look alike.
Replayable, Tense, Dark
69% of 1,422 Steam reviews are positivePlayers online now: 6$19.99
Gloom
Afflicted by severe amnesia, you drift deep into the Common Dream. You scour for the lost pages of the Necronomicon, while clinging on to any little purpose you have left. Faced with mad dreamers, horrible abominations and eldritch deities, you feel drawn to the dark Abyss deep within.
Replayable, Tense, Dark
83% of 520 Steam reviews are positive$9.99
Dungeon Nightmares II : The Memory
Dungeon Nightmares II is a first-person psychological horror that takes you through a journey of discovering what nightmares are.The game is inspired by classic roguelike games which include 100% procedural-generated maps and permadeath.
Replayable, Tense, Dark
77% of 248 Steam reviews are positive$2.99
Dead of Darkness
Dead of Darkness is a 2D survival-horror action-adventure. Investigate a mysterious island and unravel its disturbing secret. You’ll have to face grotesque creatures, hurdle deadly traps, solve puzzles, and most importantly, survive.
Tense, Dark, Scary
86% of 211 Steam reviews are positivePlayers online now: 1$15.99
Stygian: Outer Gods
A first-person survival horror RPG where a thousand-year-old mystery unravels around you. Scavenge every rag and scrap, craft what keeps you alive, and watch your sanity bend as the Outer Gods close in. Every bullet and every choice counts, and the story remembers both.
Tense, Dark, Scary
76% of 603 Steam reviews are positivePlayers online now: 53$24.99
Eldritchvania
Explore unearthly ruins, solve arcane riddles and pick up your sword against the indescribable horrors that lurk amidst the forgotten depths of our world. Beware the creeping grip of madness as you uncover secrets not meant for the eyes of men!
Tense, Dark, Scary
86% of 143 Steam reviews are positiveFree
Door in the Woods
This game is a venture into an alternative timeline in which graphics and sensible game design were never invented.
Replayable, Tense, Dark
77% of 242 Steam reviews are positive$9.99
The Shore
A first-person Lovecraftian horror story on a forbidden island. You play Andrew, a father searching for his lost daughter, walking a foggy shore where old gods leave their mark, solving strange puzzles and meeting creatures that should not exist. Atmospheric, surreal and unsettling, with more than one ending to find.
Tense, Dark, Scary
70% of 1,783 Steam reviews are positive$11.99
Withering Rooms
A challenging 2.5D horror RPG in a Victorian mansion that rearranges itself every night. Sneak past overgrown undead, trap ghosts with hex spells, and build a character from what you scavenge. Death stings less than it should, because rituals let you keep what matters.
Replayable, Tense, Dark
96% of 1,266 Steam reviews are positivePlayers online now: 16$24.99

Cheaper than The Consuming Shadow

The Excrawlers

Action-RPG slasher in which you have to get into the dark atmosphere of dungeons full of monsters and madness.

$0.90

Razenroth 2

Razenroth 2 is a dark action game with RPG and roguelike elements.

$0.79

White Night Dream

White Night Dream is a card-based strategy rogue-lite game where a girl chases after a runaway cat on the streets at midnight.

$0.49

The Seeker

Welcome to the Seeker! Run, hide and hack in this indie top-down game that gives a whole new meaning to the word "random!"

$0.74

Dark Shadows - Army of Evil

Dark Shadows - Army of Evil takes you back to September 1362.

$0.74

Dark Lore Mysteries: The Hunt For Truth

A violent murder has awoken a small town with a troubled past, they thought that chapter was over with, but has it returned?

$0.79

Obsurity

Discover all the secrets of two completely different worlds.

$0.90

Rogue Port - Red Nightmare

Help reunite your missing friends and save your family from wild animals, mutants, inanimate objects, aliens and the undead!

$0.49

Broken Armor

A knight exiled from his kingdom must find the holy grail if he is to return.

$0.49

Spell Cast

CO-OP Time survival game with roguelite elements, up to 10 players online

$0.49

It follows you

You are all alone in this dark and frightening place. Run and hide, hurry to find a way out, because it follows you...

$0.69

Overbowed

Explore a kingdom overrun by evil magic as you fight foes with your own magical bow in this retro inspired action-adventure platformer.

$0.80

Hidden gems like The Consuming Shadow

THE WELL IS NOT EMPTY

Dig your way out of hell with a rusty spoon! Crawl through ancient abandoned tunnels. Discover remnants of a ritual never meant to be seen.

$9.99

DEMON DUST

DEMON DUST is a Survival Horror Dungeon Crawler with a unique, mouse driven interface. Gain knowledge to survive and reach deeper and deeper floors.

$9.99

Spark in the Dark

Descend with a lantern, fight for every step and hoard your light before the endless dungeon snuffs it out.

$16.99

NO-SKIN

Survive the house turn by turn, ration what little you have, and follow the photos toward what the No-Skin Man really is.

$6.99

Horripilant

An old knight wakes in a dungeon with no memory and a voice telling him to hit a tree. Kill your god. Become worthy. Repeat.

$7.99

Dungeons of Blood and Dream

A first-person dungeon crawler about a Blood Wizard trapped in a Mind Prison, hacking through psychedelic dungeons with blades, cursed rings and…

$9.49

Withering Rooms

Sneak through a shifting Victorian manor, trap its ghosts with hex spells and rebuild your character from whatever each run leaves behind.

$24.99

The Horror at Highrook

The Horror at Highrook is an occult card crafting narrative RPG.

$19.99

DEATH PENALTY

A grim hand-drawn dungeon crawl where one wrong step in the dark costs your life, and careful play carves devils apart piece by piece.

$11.99

Dead of Darkness

Dead of Darkness is a 2D survival-horror action-adventure. Investigate a mysterious island and unravel its disturbing secret.

$15.99

EMPTY SHELL

You sign up for a recovery operation in an abandoned facility on a Japanese island, then die and get replaced by the next volunteer.

$11.99

Stygian: Outer Gods

Fight, sneak and craft your way through a Lovecraftian island while an old mystery and worse things close in.

$24.99

Games like The Consuming Shadow

Cheaper than The Consuming Shadow

Hidden gems like The Consuming Shadow

Newest games like The Consuming Shadow