Games like Sinner Maker

Remember how replayable and dark Sinner Maker felt at its best? These games make natural next picks for you.

Ruinarch
An evil god sandbox where you torment procedurally generated villages for fun. Turn a hero into a werewolf, whisper gossip, breed monsters and brew custom plagues, then watch the drama unfold. Dark comedy meets colony sim, with you as the disaster.
Also in Colony sim · Replayable, Dark, Funny
62% of 1,337 Steam reviews are positive$24.99
New Day
A life sim where you build the islanders, their apartments and their whole tiny society. Design characters with a deep creator, decorate up to four rooms each, then watch friendships, romances and unexpected problems unfold. Cute, colorful and low pressure, with a strange streak underneath.
Replayable, Story-driven
87% of 1,078 Steam reviews are positivePlayers online now: 6Free
Honey, I Joined a Cult
Build and run your own cult in this funny management sim. Design the compound, dress your followers in matching robes, keep the leader happy and milk the therapy rooms for cash. Dark humor, funky tunes and a lot of questionable interior design decisions.
Also in Colony sim · Replayable, Dark, Funny
73% of 1,398 Steam reviews are positivePlayers online now: 17$5.49
Sintopia
Run Hell Incorporated: process sinful souls through automated punishment facilities, keep your imployees paid, and poke at the Overworld with divine powers. A darkly funny management sim where the paperwork is eternal and the profit margins are yours. Build, automate, and decide what kind of deity you want to be.
Replayable, Dark, Funny
80% of 985 Steam reviews are positivePlayers online now: 54$24.49
Genesis of a Small God
You have awoken as a small god. As you accumulate the faith and souls of your followers, you will learn incredible new abilities. Protect, guide your people and smite any threats that may arise. The fate of your world is in your hands.
Also in Colony sim · Replayable
78% of 63 Steam reviews are positive$17.99
A Game of Humans
A sandbox village simulation fundamentally about people, their thoughts and their needs. Luckily they are not alone in their burden, for you possess divine powers. And you would surely never add to the plight of the common man... Right?
Also in Colony sim · Replayable
63% of 67 Steam reviews are positive$11.99
Cult of the Lamb
A possessed lamb owes a debt to a strange god, payable in followers. You crawl through shifting dungeons for loot and converts, then return home to build, preach, feed, and ritually sacrifice your adorable woodland flock on the way to becoming a lamb god.
Also in Colony sim · Replayable, Funny, Surreal
95% of 113,448 Steam reviews are positivePlayers online now: 2,220$24.99
One Hour One Life
You live an entire life in one hour, born as a baby to another player. Grow up, learn a craft, raise children who are players too, and help rebuild civilization from scratch. Every life is different, every death is final, and somehow it all matters.
Also in Colony sim · Replayable, Dark, Surreal
76% of 4,155 Steam reviews are positivePlayers online now: 12$14.99
The Shrouded Isle
You are the high priest of an island cult, and your god wakes in three years. Keep five noble families happy, uncover hidden sins, and send the right heretics to the altar each season. A short, sharp management game with a wicked sense of humor and seven endings to earn.
Replayable, Dark, Story-driven
71% of 1,170 Steam reviews are positivePlayers online now: 1$12.99
Little Sim World
Little Sim World hands you the keys to a fixer-upper in Little London, a cute 2D city where you can romance the locals, learn to cook, fish, paint or write, and rebuild a house corner by corner. Play alone at your own pace or share the neighborhood with up to 4 friends in online co-op.
79% of 680 Steam reviews are positivePlayers online now: 21$12.59
Fata Deum - The God Sim
Inspired by the god games of old, Fata Deum lets you mold settlements and townsfolk in your image. Will you raise the settlements to splendor, or spur them on to violent debauchery and demons? Watch as a living world grows under your whims.
Also in Colony sim · Replayable, Dark
59% of 415 Steam reviews are positive$29.99
Circadian City
A life sim game where you play both in the Realworld and the Dreamworld. Your personality is your skill tree.
Replayable, Surreal
56% of 150 Steam reviews are positive$11.99

Cheaper than Sinner Maker

Honey, I Joined a Cult

Design a compound, dress the flock and keep the leader smiling while the money rolls in.

$5.49

The Happy Hereafter

Welcome to The Happy Hereafter, a casual sim in which you guide the newly dead as they build an afterlife for themselves and their fellow lost souls.

$3.99

Pixel Survivors

Pixel Survivors is a god management game. Create some land and build structures to keep your small society settled.

$3.99

pyramida

A village builder / survival game. Expand your village by day and fight monsters at night.

$2.99

Rogue AI Simulator

Play as a Rogue Artificial Intelligence, in the sequel to the hit Flash game "I'm an Insane Rogue AI", played more than 4 million times!

$2.39

Simmiland

A god game played with cards. Drop plants, minerals and disasters onto a tiny pixel world and watch your little humans figure out the rest.

$4.99

Religion inc. God Simulator

Create your own unique religion in god simulator strategy sandbox games

$1.49

Waste Walkers

Waste Walkers is a gritty post-apocalyptic role playing game that allows players to discover the horrors of the apocalypse through a harsh struggle…

$8.99

Ultimate Arena

Pick and create characters to fight to the death in this action-packed nonsensical arena simulation.

$7.99

OurLife

OurLife is a text-forward life simulator game filled with immersive, choice-driven systems that impact more than just the character you're playing.

$4.99

Frostpunk

Frostpunk is a society survival game about keeping the last city on Earth alive in an endless freeze.

$2.99

My Little Life

Guide a little person from an empty room to a cozy home and a career, checking in now and then while the rest plays out on its own.

$5.99

Hidden gems like Sinner Maker

Little Sim World

Renovate your corner of a cute 2D Little London, pick up hobbies and friendships, and play at your own pace with friends.

$12.59

Sintopia

Process sinful souls through automated punishment facilities while meddling in the Overworld with divine powers.

$24.49

New Day

A life sim where you build the islanders, their apartments and their whole tiny society.

Free

dotAGE

You are the Elder, and you have seen the end of the world. Lead your Pips to an empty valley, assign them their daily work and build a village that…

$17.59

CraftCraft: Fantasy Merchant Simulator

CraftCraft is a narrative-heavy RPG sim with hands on forging and jewelry making! Create a pretty tiara for a mermaid or a sword made of dragon blood!

$15.99