Games like Second Thoughts

Still thinking about Second Thoughts and its dark and story-driven tone? These games make natural next picks for you.

The Testing Chamber
For every action, there is a reaction... For every choice, a result... Dive deep into your subconscious as you wander the halls of The Testing Chamber & join hundreds of thousands of other players in one of the biggest & most successful social experiments ever performed.
Dark, Story-driven, Mysterious
96% of 696 Steam reviews are positive$4.99
NO WAY OUT:Prison
10 days until execution. Every choice could save you — or prove you deserve it. Escape or die.
Dark, Story-driven, Mysterious
100% of 8 Steam reviews are positive$4.79
Paper Pusher
A short atmospheric psychological horror game. Locked in a corporate contract, you must decide who lives and who dies based only on details that can be written down about them. How will you justify your choices?
Dark, Story-driven, Mysterious
90% of 39 Steam reviews are positiveFree
7 Days To Think About It
A short psychological horror game where your friends invite you to hang out tonight — you have 7 days to think about it.
Dark, Story-driven, Mysterious
93% of 76 Steam reviews are positive$4.99
The Test
A short psychological experiment where a calm stranger asks you yes or no questions that start harmless and end somewhere you did not expect. It reads you, hands you a word about yourself, and leaves you thinking. Short, unsettling, and best taken alone.
Dark, Story-driven, Mysterious
96% of 19,593 Steam reviews are positive$1.99
Kindred [Subject 6244]
In this eerie, horror visual novel, you are confined in a room with a monster. How will you fare against petrifying odds? Will you be able to work your way into the mind of an indecipherable beast, or will you be added to the casualty count? A word of advice: Choose a side; don't look back.
Dark, Story-driven, Mysterious
94% of 36 Steam reviews are positive$0.99
The Executioner
The Executioner puts you in the shoes of a man who tortures people for a living while trying to retain his own sanity. In this game the monster isn’t lurking behind you. You are the monster, if you choose to become one.
Dark, Story-driven, Mysterious
64% of 315 Steam reviews are positive$9.99
7Days Origins
7Days Origins is a single-player story game where the storyline changes based on the player's choices. For 7 days, you will meet various characters in the world of the dead. You may become allies and embark on adventures together or become enemies and fight.
Dark, Story-driven, Mysterious
86% of 316 Steam reviews are positive$8.99
Trolley Problem, Inc.
A darkly funny narrative game built on real philosophical papers. Every question hands you two awful answers, a narrator who mocks whatever you pick, and a look at how the rest of the world chose. Two hours of impossible decisions you will argue about afterwards.
Dark, Story-driven, Minimalist
67% of 1,283 Steam reviews are positivePlayers online now: 1$1.09
This is Interesting
This is Interesting is a psychological horror mystery based game with roguelite elements. You are being watched, and you aren't really sure why. Delve through the depths of memory to uncover the mystery behind the gray purgatory you find yourself in.
Dark, Story-driven, Mysterious
97% of 76 Steam reviews are positive$6.99
Your Turn To Die -Death Game By Majority-
Eleven strangers wake up trapped. Sara Chidouin is one of them, and the only way out runs through a vote: discuss, weigh who is useful and who is not, and decide who dies. A multi-ending horror adventure where your choices steer the story, full of twists, characters worth caring about, and decisions you will not enjoy making.
Dark, Story-driven, Mysterious
97% of 4,222 Steam reviews are positivePlayers online now: 19$16.99
The Works of Mercy
The Works of Mercy is a psychological thriller inspired by the classics of the genre. The game’s plot revolves around mysterious killings committed on seemingly random victims. Only this time it’s the player who becomes the murderer.
Dark, Story-driven, Mysterious
41% of 196 Steam reviews are positive$6.99

Cheaper than Second Thoughts

Kindred [Subject 6244]

In this eerie, horror visual novel, you are confined in a room with a monster. How will you fare against petrifying odds?

$0.99

Trolley Problem, Inc.

You pull levers, weigh lives against lives, and defend every decision to a narrator who thinks you are wrong.

$1.09

Condition Unknown

A text-based psychological horror experience set inside a hospital where something is deeply broken and death may not be the end.

$1.50

This Is Not Your House

Crush someone's skull, Suffer from Hypothermia, Transcend your Mortal Frame, Find all 10 Endings. GET YOUR HOUSE BACK.

$0.99

The importance of choosing: second chance

This story tells us about a girl who went through a lot in her life, and each of her decisions led to certain consequences.

$0.99

Vessels

Quarantined inside an airlock. No memories. No way out. The remaining crew thinks there’s something wrong with you, but the Voice says it’ll help…

$0.99

Close Me

You start the game, you wake up, and eventually you will close the game. One day, you may even start the game again. That's the game.

$0.99

Choo-Choose

So, have you ever heard of the Trolley Problem? Do you know the price of the choices you make?

$0.99

The Ultimate Death Clock

You find yourself in a singularity with Death itself. With few chances to speak with the living, Death proposes a little game.

$0.99

The Deed

Plan a perfect crime at the family estate, then talk your way past the Inspector before your choices catch up with you.

$0.99

Invisible Wall

An interactive horror story based on a reality everyone eventually faces.

$1.49

Surrogate

Visit a surreal world and help a blue girl navigate the perils of paranoia and the intrusion of mysterious beings in her life...

$0.99

Hidden gems like Second Thoughts

Prison of Lies

In this short visual novel, four prisoners on death row are cleared of all charges. But the prison has a quota to meet.

Free

The Test: Reality Check

The Test: Reality Check is one of multiple installments in an ongoing social experiment that can be classified as an atmospheric…

$4.99

Yet Another Killing Game

You wake up in a house, alone with two beautiful girls... But no one is allowed to leave until one of you DIES. Why is this happening?

$16.99

qualia

Intellica thanks you for volunteering in this short text-based Research Study.

Free

outside the door

Outside the door is a mystic visual novel set within one office.

$1.99

The Test: Secrets of the Soul 2

You will answer questions that will reveal things deep within. Some will be uncomfortable, but with great knowledge comes great sacrifice.

Free

The Test: Secrets of the Soul

You answer a series of deep questions, and the game turns your answers into a personal psychological result.

Free

The Testing Chamber

For every action, there is a reaction... For every choice, a result...

$4.99

Your Turn To Die -Death Game By Majority-

Trapped with eleven strangers, Sara must talk, deduce and vote her way out of a death game where every choice can cost a life.

$16.99

No, I'm not a Human

Check every guest for signs, and decide which desperate strangers deserve a place inside your burning world.

$14.99

The NOexistenceN of you AND me

A short visual novel about affection and reality, where hundreds of choices twist the story toward very different endings.

$1.99

7Days Origins

7Days Origins is a single-player story game where the storyline changes based on the player's choices.

$8.99

Newest games like Second Thoughts