Games like PUMPKIN PANIC

If PUMPKIN PANIC scratched a scary and tense itch for you, keep reading. These games make natural next picks for you.

Dread Fields
A slow-burn folk farming horror. You bought an isolated farm to start a new life. Your peaceful routine is shattered when the former owner's terrible secrets rise from beneath the ground.
Also in Farming · Scary, Tense, Replayable
98% of 591 Steam reviews are positive$6.99
Harvest Island
Discover your sinister purpose in this horror farming game. Your idyllic farm life can't be trusted. Keep up with the façade as you give your crops to the gods. Explore the ominous island and question everything. You must fake your blissful farming days. Your life depends on it.
Also in Farming · Scary, Tense, Cute
83% of 233 Steam reviews are positivePlayers online now: 7$24.99
Cryptid Farm
Cultivate a thriving farm to survive in this peaceful horror farming game! Play online with up to 16 players in the same lobby. Work together with your fellow farmers to repair your tractor and escape the farm, try not to fall victim to the eerie and mysterious creatures that lurk nearby.
Also in Farming · Scary, Tense, Replayable
96% of 153 Steam reviews are positivePlayers online now: 2$4.99
Andy's Apple Farm
Play minigames and discover the hidden truth in this retro-style horror game
Scary, Tense, Cute
89% of 650 Steam reviews are positive$2.99
Descending The Woods
By day, tend to your farm, care for your pets, and explore the mysteries of the haunted woods. By nightfall, They will come from the woods, Beware of ghosts and demons of the haunted woods. Hide, Survive, Build, Fight and Explore in this eerie Survival Horror alone or with friends.
Scary, Tense, Replayable
47% of 113 Steam reviews are positive$18.99
Welcome to Elderfield
A cozy horror RPG where the crops include teeth and eyeballs, the livestock is otherworldly, and the local news gets stranger by the day. Farm, fish, mine, befriend the odd townsfolk and fight Lovecraftian horrors in turn-based combat, all wrapped in hand-drawn horror manga art and dark lofi music.
Also in Farming · Scary, Replayable, Surreal
83% of 2,613 Steam reviews are positivePlayers online now: 534$17.99
Grunn
A weekend gardening job in the Dutch countryside. Trim the grass, water the flowers, ignore the feeling of being watched. Your tools are missing, the house is off-limits, and going out after dark is forbidden. A short, strange mystery where what you learn matters more than what you carry.
Scary, Tense, Replayable
95% of 1,380 Steam reviews are positivePlayers online now: 8$12.99
A Wholesome Game About Farming
This game is about farming! Just good ol' planting crops in the daytime, and harvesting them in the daytime with no sinister nighttime gameplay or anything nefarious like that at all.
Also in Farming · Cute, Surreal
95% of 98 Steam reviews are positiveFree
Village in the Shade
A hand-painted farming sim in Kagatsu, a Japanese mountain village where days are crops, festivals, and neighbors, and nights follow three rules: don't talk to strangers, don't leave, don't go out. Plant, decorate, and make friends, then decide how much truth you want to know.
Also in Farming · Scary, Tense, Cute
92% of 716 Steam reviews are positivePlayers online now: 889$49.99
Spooky's Jump Scare Mansion
A cute little mansion invites you through 1000 rooms.
Scary, Tense, Replayable
92% of 15,634 Steam reviews are positivePlayers online now: 30Free
Farm for your Life
Your community was taken down by a heavy storm which caused an apocalypse and unleashed the living dead. Together with the other survivors, it is your task to rebuild and to allow that sustainable life can still be assured. Cultivate your farm and manage your restaurant to provide food and deal with all the zombies.
Also in Farming · Cute
81% of 502 Steam reviews are positive$3.49
Happy's Humble Burger Farm
Work the night shift alone at Happy's Humble Burger Farm: grill patties, fill drinks, keep the customers smiling, and never, ever upset Happy the Heifer. Then go home, wander a dystopian city, and dig into why none of this feels quite real. Cooking sim meets slow-burn horror, with a retro 90s edge.
Scary, Tense, Replayable
93% of 1,710 Steam reviews are positivePlayers online now: 21$19.99

Hidden gems like PUMPKIN PANIC

Dread Fields

A slow-burn folk farming horror. You bought an isolated farm to start a new life.

$6.99

Don't Sleep With The Fishes

A hand-drawn survival horror where you fish for answers by day and ration your hope by night, with endings that rarely turn out kind.

$1.99

Village in the Shade

Tend crops and befriend neighbors by day, then weigh how much of the village's truth you can handle once night falls.

$49.99

Wasteland Bites

Wasteland Bites is a horror-based food truck sim. Cooking up questionable cuisine in your post-apocalyptic food truck is tough.

$9.99

Moonlight Peaks

Trade the castle for a cozy homestead, grow enchanted crops, learn spells and fall for the town's supernatural neighbours at your own pace.

$34.99

Grunn

Tend the garden by day, break the rules after dark, and piece together what is really going on in this short, unsettling mystery.

$12.99

Cryptid Farm

Cultivate a thriving farm to survive in this peaceful horror farming game! Play online with up to 16 players in the same lobby.

$4.99

Welcome to Elderfield

A cozy horror RPG where the crops include teeth and eyeballs, the livestock is otherworldly, and the local news gets stranger by the day.

$17.99

Berry Bury Berry

A first-person incremental game about growing berries and feeding them to an ominous hole.

$7.99

Peaceful Days

Take over a cozy local farm in the charming seaside town of Aurora, meet friendly locals, reveal the secrets and enjoy your new peaceful life!

$11.99

Cute Farmer Life

Cute Farmer Life is a small indie farm game. Grow, craft and collect resources in a game designed to relax and enjoy the moment.

$3.99

Kiosk

A night shift at a rain-soaked fast food kiosk. The last worker vanished, and the customers who shuffle up to your window know something about it.

$3.99

Newest games like PUMPKIN PANIC

The Plant Shop

Tend a tiny night-shift shop, chat with strange customers and watch a creeping curse change everything around you.

$4.49

Welcome to Elderfield

A cozy horror RPG where the crops include teeth and eyeballs, the livestock is otherworldly, and the local news gets stranger by the day.

$17.99

Pumpkin Woods

Collect magical ingredients and build your cozy witch home while exploring the wonderful sights and secrets of this mysterious land.

$14.99

Village in the Shade

Tend crops and befriend neighbors by day, then weigh how much of the village's truth you can handle once night falls.

$49.99

Petunia's Purgatory

Petunia's Purgatory is a creepy-cute idle farming game that lives at the bottom of your screen.

$6.99

Moonlight Peaks

Trade the castle for a cozy homestead, grow enchanted crops, learn spells and fall for the town's supernatural neighbours at your own pace.

$34.99

Don't Sleep With The Fishes

A hand-drawn survival horror where you fish for answers by day and ration your hope by night, with endings that rarely turn out kind.

$1.99

Dread Fields

A slow-burn folk farming horror. You bought an isolated farm to start a new life.

$6.99

MAZEBOUND: Hunt, Gather, Run!

A survival horror with a simple setup: sea behind you, a towering gate ahead, and a maze in between.

$9.99

Besmirch

The town of Besmirch starves. Stave off the hunger as the latest farmhand in this survival horror farming sim, earning the trust of paranoid…

$9.99

Wasteland Bites

Wasteland Bites is a horror-based food truck sim. Cooking up questionable cuisine in your post-apocalyptic food truck is tough.

$9.99

Berry Bury Berry

A first-person incremental game about growing berries and feeding them to an ominous hole.

$7.99