Games like Crying Pony

If Crying Pony left you wanting something hand-drawn and dark, you have options. You will find a few strong contenders among these games.

In Nightmare
In Nightmare is a narrative-driven horror adventure game combining sneak action with diverse puzzles. It follows a young boy in search for the last hope of love who is working out his own salvation by navigating through his fear.
Dark, Scary, Atmospheric
81% of 58 Steam reviews are positive$19.99
Afterdream
Get lost in a lucid dream, bending the lines between reality and fiction. Utilize the strange camera to navigate through the ghosts' mysterious residence. Find the purpose of your nocturnal visit in a vivid and dreamlike setting.
Hand-drawn, Dark, Scary
91% of 308 Steam reviews are positive$10.99
Nightmare (Incubo)
INCUBO is a side scrolling platform game with a semi-horror theme. We present many ghost from around the world in our game as enemy and bosses. You played as a child in his nightmare and discover the truth about his story.
Hand-drawn, Dark, Scary
77% of 174 Steam reviews are positive$6.99
Happy Game
A little boy falls asleep into a horrible nightmare. Happy Game sends you in after him, through three of them, dragging and poking your way past suspicious smiley faces and pink bunnies. It is a psychedelic horror adventure from Amanita Design, cute on the surface and deeply unsettling underneath, with creepy songs from the Czech freakfolk band DVA.
Hand-drawn, Dark, Scary
89% of 3,353 Steam reviews are positivePlayers online now: 7$14.99
Neverending Nightmares
Thomas wakes from a nightmare into another nightmare, and another, each one darker and stranger than the last. A hand-drawn psychological horror where you are defenseless: hide from what haunts the halls, follow the story down through layers of a troubled mind, and find one of three endings. Short, bleak and hard to shake off.
Hand-drawn, Dark, Scary
77% of 2,129 Steam reviews are positivePlayers online now: 2$14.99
Yomawari: Night Alone
A little girl walks her dog at dusk and comes home holding only the leash. That night her sister vanishes too, so she goes out into a town where spirits stalk the dark. Yomawari pairs the cutest pixel art with genuine dread: you hide, run and listen to your own heartbeat as it speeds up when something gets close.
Hand-drawn, Dark, Scary
74% of 1,979 Steam reviews are positivePlayers online now: 3$19.99
Cat in the Box
A horror adventure about a girl who brings a camera to a cult's abandoned mansion and finds the exit gone. Search for keys and clues, dodge what hunts the halls, and pick your way through five endings in a tense, atmospheric pixel-art night.
Dark, Scary, Atmospheric
93% of 1,447 Steam reviews are positivePlayers online now: 2$6.99
My Beautiful Paper Smile
Welcome, child, to your new home. Here you shall learn the art of perfection. Here you shall learn to smile. Be sure that smile doesn’t fade into sadness, or you will need to run and hide…
Hand-drawn, Dark, Scary
82% of 353 Steam reviews are positive$14.99
Among the Sleep - Enhanced Edition
A first-person horror adventure where you play a two-year-old. Wake in the night, mom is gone, and the house has turned strange. Crawl through a child's nightmare with a talking teddy bear as your only light, hide from what stalks the dark, and uncover a story far sadder than the monsters suggest.
Dark, Scary, Atmospheric
89% of 6,420 Steam reviews are positivePlayers online now: 23$16.99
Have a Nice Dream
A short pixel game about a girl who wakes up in a pink room she does not recognize. A strange man says he is going out to buy her favorite bear biscuits. Explore the weird house, solve mild puzzles, and find out what this place really is. It starts unsettling and ends somewhere warmer.
Dark, Scary, Atmospheric
92% of 4,933 Steam reviews are positiveFree
LUNA
Play as a little girl named 'Luna', and survive from the dark being while discovering the secrets behind her. The more you traverse on her memory, the more you will discover dark truths that lie deep inside.
Dark, Scary, Atmospheric
83% of 298 Steam reviews are positive$0.99
CINERIS SOMNIA
A girl wakes on the seashore. Her mother is gone; all that remains is her sister's yellow bucket and the sand castle they built together. So begins CINERIS SOMNIA, a 3D adventure through a strange, mesmerizing dream world, where you explore shifting places, piece together four tragic stories and meet a tall man in black.
Dark, Scary, Atmospheric
90% of 1,316 Steam reviews are positivePlayers online now: 36$14.99

Cheaper than Crying Pony

Nightmare (Incubo)

INCUBO is a side scrolling platform game with a semi-horror theme. We present many ghost from around the world in our game as enemy and bosses.

$6.99

Cat in the Box

Explore a cult's abandoned mansion with a camera, solve what holds it shut, and survive what walks inside.

$6.99

LUNA

Play as a little girl named 'Luna', and survive from the dark being while discovering the secrets behind her.

$0.99

Eve of Souls: Static Pod

[The pod will break soon. Will she survive the nightmare or find the truth?]

$2.99

Silence of the Sleep

You play as a man called Jacob Reeves. A man who has lost his reason to live.

$4.99

Midnight Scenes: A Safe Place

Phil's life has crumbled to dust. The four walls of his room have become his safe haven. He yearns for sleep...but terrible nightmares haunt him.

$5.99

Tide Up

Tide Up is a rather dark and gloomy adventure game. Accompany the girl in a dreamlike world of wonder.

$7.99

Savior of the Abyss

Savior of the Abyss is a horror adventure game. To avoid sudden death, always pay attention and be suspicious of things around you.

$6.99

MOM

Mom says I can't get out of my room after 12:00 AM. But I always hear the door opening and closing after that hour. Why isn't mom sleeping?

$3.99

The Bunny Graveyard

You are a cursor, sucked into a computer where a bunny named Skye runs a garden with her Handy Pals. It looks adorable. It is not.

$6.99

Stray Cat Crossing

Stray Cat Crossing is an indie pixel horror game about an encounter with a mysterious little girl named Cat.

$2.99

Midnight: Submersion - Nightmare Horror Story

Nightmare Horror Story an adventure game from the first face in a horror genre provides you to take a trip in a huge and dark city full of dummies.

$4.99

Hidden gems like Crying Pony

The Deadseat

A horror game where you play a hand-held console in the backseat during a long drive home.

$2.99

DYSTHANASIA

You awaken in a cold unfamiliar building crawling with grotesque creatures.

$24.99

D'LIRIUM

An experimental 2D-shooter with the elements of a horror game. D'lirium brings together some mechanics back from 90s classics.

$4.99

Dread Flats

Search a 1990s apartment block for the missing, piecing together clues while something hunts the halls.

$5.99

The Bunny Graveyard

You are a cursor, sucked into a computer where a bunny named Skye runs a garden with her Handy Pals. It looks adorable. It is not.

$6.99

Midnight Scenes: A Safe Place

Phil's life has crumbled to dust. The four walls of his room have become his safe haven. He yearns for sleep...but terrible nightmares haunt him.

$5.99

Hollow Cocoon

"Trapped in a cocoon, the silkworm weaves her final dream." Hollow Cocoon is a first-person horror adventure game set in 1980s Japan.

$14.99

GYLT

Guide Sally through a twisted, dreamlike town, sneaking past its monsters and piecing together what happened to her cousin.

$19.99

Afterdream

Get lost in a lucid dream, bending the lines between reality and fiction.

$10.99

The Monstrous Horror Show

Four girls find their way into an abandoned hospital, each for her own reasons.

$14.99

Decarnation

Play as a cabaret dancer whose life spirals into a surreal horror of dreams, monsters and a captor's cell.

$14.99

Tide Up

Tide Up is a rather dark and gloomy adventure game. Accompany the girl in a dreamlike world of wonder.

$7.99

Games like Crying Pony

Cheaper than Crying Pony

Hidden gems like Crying Pony

Newest games like Crying Pony