Games like Amidst The Evil

If Amidst The Evil left you wanting something tense and mysterious, you have options. These games could fill that gap nicely. You can bring friends along for most of these.

Cheaper than Amidst The Evil

Somewhere in the Shadow

Somewhere in the Shadow

Woke up in strange dark spot. Who has done it with you? And why? Try to get out from that scary place and stay alive...

80% of 578 Steam reviews are positive$2.99
Rahasya: The Unsolved Mystery

Rahasya: The Unsolved Mystery

A 4 player co-op survival horror game where every step into the house uncovers a darker truth...

100% of 1 Steam reviews are positive$3.28
Red Riddles

Red Riddles

Red Riddles is a first-person co-op horror puzzle game for 1–4 players.

0% of 3 Steam reviews are positive$2.99
Evil Tag

Evil Tag

Four teenagers have to pass the rite of student initiation. To do this, they must read a spell from the ancient book in the basement of the…

67% of 640 Steam reviews are positive$1.99
Together After Dark

Together After Dark

Together After Dark is a co-op horror psychological game with a survival touch for 1-4 players.

52% of 411 Steam reviews are positivePlayers online now: 2$2.99
Nostalgia

Nostalgia

Nostalgia is a two-player cooperative indie game that escapes from enemies in a dark labyrinth.

89% of 79 Steam reviews are positivePlayers online now: 2$2.99
GIRL.EXE

GIRL.EXE

You and your friends decided to summon a girl(friend?). Unfortunately, something went wrong. Can you get out or will you stay with her forever?

100% of 12 Steam reviews are positive$2.99
The Umbridge Estate

The Umbridge Estate

The Umbridge Estate is a 1-4 Player Co-Op Survival Horror Game like no other.

55% of 11 Steam reviews are positive$0.99
Incoming Evil

Incoming Evil

A first-person horror game Incoming Evil, you will explore an unsolved event about 3 missing people.

80% of 49 Steam reviews are positive$0.89
Project Legion

Project Legion

Immerse yourself in terrifying dreams and unravel mysteries playing alone or with friends.

42% of 24 Steam reviews are positive$0.99
Last victim. House of Fear

Last victim. House of Fear

This is an indie horror game in which you have to face your fear and escape from house by solving puzzles and escaping from a ghost.

92% of 13 Steam reviews are positive$0.99
Nightmare: Les Origines

Nightmare: Les Origines

"Nightmare: Origins" is a multiplayer horror game for four players that immerses you in a nightmarish world between the realm of the dead and the…

36% of 14 Steam reviews are positive$0.99

Hidden gems like Amidst The Evil

We Escaped a Twisted Game

We Escaped a Twisted Game

A two-player co-op horror escape. Trapped in a haunted manor, you’ll need to solve puzzles, work together, and trust each other to make it out alive.

94% of 830 Steam reviews are positivePlayers online now: 6$4.99
Paranoia Place: Escape Together

Paranoia Place: Escape Together

Team up with up to three friends to solve puzzles, hunt down randomly hidden items and survive a demon that grows faster the longer you stall.

87% of 1,590 Steam reviews are positivePlayers online now: 15$7.99
Jester: A Foolish Ritual

Jester: A Foolish Ritual

A co-op survival horror game set in a dark medieval castle. Play as one of four resurrected knights and work together to find hidden runes, unlock…

88% of 103 Steam reviews are positive$4.99
Devil of the Plague

Devil of the Plague

A 1–4 player co-op horror game. Cleanse cursed lands, perform forbidden rituals, and survive a spreading plague. Fear is not scripted.

79% of 211 Steam reviews are positive$9.99
Emissary Zero

Emissary Zero

Sneak through a building that does not want you there, solve what it hides, and get out with whatever the Moon turns out to be.

83% of 2,785 Steam reviews are positivePlayers online now: 2$8.99
Unboxing the Cryptic Killer

Unboxing the Cryptic Killer

Team up online to solve a hand-drawn co-op mystery where each of you sees only half the clues.

89% of 2,408 Steam reviews are positivePlayers online now: 21$5.99
Spectral Scream

Spectral Scream

Spectral Scream is a 1-4 player cooperative horror exploration game. Are you ready to face death in the maw of purgatory?

78% of 659 Steam reviews are positive$9.99
Escape From Crimson Manor: Trapped Together

Escape From Crimson Manor: Trapped Together

Work together to escape the manor in "Trapped Together", a narrative co-op puzzle campaign where logic reigns and death is not an option.

73% of 100 Steam reviews are positivePlayers online now: 2$12.99
Im Bann Der Dunklen Jagd

Im Bann Der Dunklen Jagd

Two detectives. Five eerie levels. One fight for survival. Explore dark locations with a friend in this free two-player co-op horror game.

71% of 232 Steam reviews are positiveFree
Eronoctosis: Put Yourself Together

Eronoctosis: Put Yourself Together

Explore the depths of your own psyche with a friend, using light and a camera to hold the nightmares back.

90% of 1,904 Steam reviews are positivePlayers online now: 6Free
Mirror Layers

Mirror Layers

Mirror Layers is a first person social horror game. Cooperate with other players through an in-game social network to solve challenging…

93% of 124 Steam reviews are positive$9.99
The Escape: Together

The Escape: Together

Split up to search for keys and tools, stick together when the lights go out, and reach one of several endings before the creature finds you.

79% of 2,041 Steam reviews are positivePlayers online now: 8$3.99

Newest games like Amidst The Evil

The Midnighters

The Midnighters

Dig up cursed loot with friends, sell it for better gear, and try to stay sane while the village plays tricks on your eyes.

88% of 42 Steam reviews are positivePlayers online now: 25$4.99
The Reflection

The Reflection

The Reflection is a ritual-based co-op horror game focused on tension, teamwork, and survival.

90% of 10 Steam reviews are positive$9.99
Out of the Shadows

Out of the Shadows

Out of the Shadows is a 2–4 player online co-op horror escape game.

75% of 8 Steam reviews are positive$7.99
Separated

Separated

Trapped and separated across two connected houses, you and your friend must use voice chat to solve puzzles from different perspectives.

70% of 79 Steam reviews are positive$9.99
Escape From Crimson Manor: Trapped Together

Escape From Crimson Manor: Trapped Together

Work together to escape the manor in "Trapped Together", a narrative co-op puzzle campaign where logic reigns and death is not an option.

73% of 100 Steam reviews are positivePlayers online now: 2$12.99
Inkwellers

Inkwellers

In this online 2-player co-op puzzle adventure, you and a friend become Inkwellers and dive into Celiphia’s magical journal.

88% of 150 Steam reviews are positivePlayers online now: 2$9.99
Violet Mansion

Violet Mansion

Violet Mansion is a horror puzzle game where you and your friends must survive against various enemies by using absurd items, finding creative…

89% of 9 Steam reviews are positiveFree
Devil of the Plague

Devil of the Plague

A 1–4 player co-op horror game. Cleanse cursed lands, perform forbidden rituals, and survive a spreading plague. Fear is not scripted.

79% of 211 Steam reviews are positive$9.99
Cult of the Child Eater

Cult of the Child Eater

A heart-pounding 1-4 player co-op horror experience. Step into a forsaken orphanage to banish the legendary Child Eater.

66% of 32 Steam reviews are positive$5.99
Jester: A Foolish Ritual

Jester: A Foolish Ritual

A co-op survival horror game set in a dark medieval castle. Play as one of four resurrected knights and work together to find hidden runes, unlock…

88% of 103 Steam reviews are positive$4.99
Im Bann Der Dunklen Jagd

Im Bann Der Dunklen Jagd

Two detectives. Five eerie levels. One fight for survival. Explore dark locations with a friend in this free two-player co-op horror game.

71% of 232 Steam reviews are positiveFree
We Escaped a Twisted Game

We Escaped a Twisted Game

A two-player co-op horror escape. Trapped in a haunted manor, you’ll need to solve puzzles, work together, and trust each other to make it out alive.

94% of 830 Steam reviews are positivePlayers online now: 6$4.99