Games like Aimi

If Aimi scratched a story-driven and mysterious itch for you, keep reading. These games are worth a look next.

1. Ami's Room

   

   An exploration game set in a surreal dreamscape full of projections. Piece together past recollections and elusive memories. Make a choice as the reality and dreamed world begins to blur...

   Story-driven, Mysterious, Scary

   89%89% of 28 Steam reviews are positiveFree

2. IMSCARED

   

   A pixel horror that refuses to stay in its window. IMSCARED hunts you through a surreal first-person nightmare, then slips out onto your desktop: files appear, the game closes itself, and the puzzles only make sense outside it. Something called White Face wants a Heart. It will lie to get one.

   Story-driven, Mysterious, Scary

   95%95% of 3,532 Steam reviews are positive9Players online now: 9$3.99

3. YAMIKKO TROUBLEMAKER

   

   A long-form, choice-driven psychological horror and depression game in which the protagonist’s ending changes based on the choices made by “you,” the voice he hears in his head.

   Also in Visual novel · Story-driven, Mysterious, Scary

   96%96% of 126 Steam reviews are positiveFree

4. Hazy Mind

   

   You can't remember anything, and all you can see is HER. Delve into your story and uncover the truth behind what happened to you and your parents.

   Also in Visual novel · Story-driven, Mysterious, Scary

   85%85% of 327 Steam reviews are positive2Players online now: 2$9.99

5. Ann

   

   An art student breaks one rule after 9 PM and her school turns into a maze of corridors, traps and things that chase her.

   Story-driven, Mysterious, Scary

   93%93% of 2,803 Steam reviews are positiveFree

6. At Home Alone Final

   

   A little girl is home alone while her mom works, and a day of hide-and-seek, kittens and snacks slowly turns into something else. This pixel adventure hides a looping, twisting mystery behind its cute face, with multiple endings and a story that rewards a second look. Sweet on the surface, quietly unsettling underneath.

   Story-driven, Mysterious, Scary

   96%96% of 8,261 Steam reviews are positive2Players online now: 2Free

7. Close Your Eyes [Old Version]

   

   A redux version of a 2014 Ludum Dare RPG Maker Horror Game. A poor little marshmallow escapes death row into an underground subway system, where they're asked questions by a mysterious game show host. Updated in 2025 with new content.

   Story-driven, Mysterious, Scary

   86%86% of 783 Steam reviews are positiveFree

8. Traum

   

   Traum is a short, story-driven adventure about a man with a dream. Can even the best of plans be shattered by unexpected news?

   Story-driven, Mysterious, Scary

   92%92% of 386 Steam reviews are positiveFree

9. Mists of Aiden

   

   Mists of Aiden is a first-person story driven horror game. You play as a thief trapped in an eerie mansion. Each choice can open a new mystery of the house and lead to a unique walkthrough and ending. Uncover final secret of the house. Uncover your own secrets.

   Story-driven, Mysterious, Scary

   90%90% of 982 Steam reviews are positive$6.99

10. OMORI

    

    A story-rich RPG about a boy, a dream world full of colorful friends, and a forgotten past that will not stay forgotten. It looks like a cheerful pixel adventure, then quietly becomes one of the most affecting stories about grief and guilt you can play. Multiple endings, a great soundtrack, and real horror hiding under the pastel.

    Story-driven, Mysterious, Scary

    97%97% of 80,496 Steam reviews are positive472Players online now: 472$19.99

11. Locked Up

    

    A short first-person psychological thriller set in a house where something terrible happened. The rooms change when you are not looking, VHS tapes pull you into the past, and a Polaroid camera catches things that should not be there. About two hours long, no combat, all dread.

    Story-driven, Mysterious, Scary

    76%76% of 1,332 Steam reviews are positive1Players online now: 1$12.99

12. Paper Lily - Chapter 1

    

    Paper Lily is a pixel horror adventure about Lacie, a shut-in who follows a strange golden letter into a hidden world. Every puzzle has more than one solution, your choices shape which ending you get, and something is always watching. About four hours long, strange, sad and quietly terrifying.

    Story-driven, Mysterious, Scary

    99%99% of 9,070 Steam reviews are positive16Players online now: 16Free

Hidden gems like Aimi

lily's world XD

Lily was a normal teenager in 2004, and you just found her laptop.

96%96% of 1,808 Steam reviews are positive10Players online now: 10$11.99

AI2U: With You 'Til The End

An escape room where the thing standing between you and the door is a yandere AI who loves you very much and would rather you not leave.

87%87% of 2,508 Steam reviews are positive74Players online now: 74

Among Ashes

Among Ashes is a terrifying first-person survival horror game.

95%95% of 443 Steam reviews are positive$14.99

YAMIKKO TROUBLEMAKER

A long-form, choice-driven psychological horror and depression game in which the protagonist’s ending changes based on the choices made by “you,”…

96%96% of 126 Steam reviews are positiveFree

Ethel

Welcome to my first game! Where you'll Immerse yourself in a unbelievable, story-rich mystery, packed with jaw-dropping plot twist, horror, and…

93%93% of 239 Steam reviews are positive$6.99

Pocket Mirror ~ GoldenerTraum

Wander a twisted gothic mansion, solve its puzzles and let your choices decide which ending you earn.

92%92% of 1,625 Steam reviews are positive22Players online now: 22$19.99

Hazy Mind

You can't remember anything, and all you can see is HER. Delve into your story and uncover the truth behind what happened to you and your parents.

85%85% of 327 Steam reviews are positive2Players online now: 2$9.99

Paper Lily - Chapter 1

Help Lacie solve puzzles with many answers, follow the golden letter deeper, and see which of several endings your choices earn.

99%99% of 9,070 Steam reviews are positive16Players online now: 16Free

MOTHERED - A ROLE-PLAYING HORROR GAME

An immersive first-person horror adventure where you play the role of LIANA - a young girl who arrives home after major surgery and is met with a…

92%92% of 395 Steam reviews are positive$9.99

Looking Up I See Only A Ceiling

Explore a student's shrunken world, follow her thoughts as they turn strange, and choose between three endings.

87%87% of 3,444 Steam reviews are positive1Players online now: 1$1.99

Ann

Break the school's one rule, explore its twisted halls and find a way out before you live there forever.

93%93% of 2,803 Steam reviews are positiveFree

Mists of Aiden

Mists of Aiden is a first-person story driven horror game. You play as a thief trapped in an eerie mansion.

90%90% of 982 Steam reviews are positive$6.99

Newest games like Aimi

lily's world XD

Lily was a normal teenager in 2004, and you just found her laptop.

96%96% of 1,808 Steam reviews are positive10Players online now: 10$11.99

AI2U: With You 'Til The End

An escape room where the thing standing between you and the door is a yandere AI who loves you very much and would rather you not leave.

87%87% of 2,508 Steam reviews are positive74Players online now: 74

Who am I: Remedy

A found footage horror game where you'll try to remember who you are and escape the time loop while documenting everything on a typewriter.

85%85% of 33 Steam reviews are positive$3.14

HOMESICKNESS

HOMESICKNESS is a point-&-click psychological horror indie game exploring the nuances of nostalgia.

91%91% of 67 Steam reviews are positive$5.99

YAMIKKO TROUBLEMAKER

A long-form, choice-driven psychological horror and depression game in which the protagonist’s ending changes based on the choices made by “you,”…

96%96% of 126 Steam reviews are positiveFree

Among Ashes

Among Ashes is a terrifying first-person survival horror game.

95%95% of 443 Steam reviews are positive$14.99

Imaginary Friend Asylum

A psychological horror game about being a child in an insane asylum. You're in a cruel world but your imaginary friends have your back.

100%100% of 63 Steam reviews are positive$4.99

Himantolo

The girl with a head injury has to find her friend who vanished from the hospital.

79%79% of 34 Steam reviews are positive$2.99

Ethel

Welcome to my first game! Where you'll Immerse yourself in a unbelievable, story-rich mystery, packed with jaw-dropping plot twist, horror, and…

93%93% of 239 Steam reviews are positive$6.99

Hazy Mind

You can't remember anything, and all you can see is HER. Delve into your story and uncover the truth behind what happened to you and your parents.

85%85% of 327 Steam reviews are positive2Players online now: 2$9.99

Paper Lily - Chapter 1

Help Lacie solve puzzles with many answers, follow the golden letter deeper, and see which of several endings your choices earn.

99%99% of 9,070 Steam reviews are positive16Players online now: 16Free

Pocket Mirror ~ GoldenerTraum

Wander a twisted gothic mansion, solve its puzzles and let your choices decide which ending you earn.

92%92% of 1,625 Steam reviews are positive22Players online now: 22$19.99