Games like 2x4 Nails

If 2x4 Nails left you wanting something dark and tense, you have options. These games keep things close enough to feel familiar.

Butcher's Creek
A first-person melee horror game about a gore-hound who goes looking for snuff tapes in the Appalachian woods and ends up on the run from the people who make them. Fight back with hammers, pipes and box cutters, photograph the carnage to stay alive, and dig through a grimy, darkly funny nightmare world.
Dark, Tense, Brutal
94% of 1,587 Steam reviews are positivePlayers online now: 1$9.99
The Happyhills Homicide 2: Out For Blood
He is back. Once again take control of mass serial killer John Wade. Six years later, the infamous Pale Grin resurrects from the grave to terrorize the broken town of Happyhills. This time he has more on his mind than simple killing.
Also in Detective · Dark, Tense, Brutal
95% of 763 Steam reviews are positivePlayers online now: 1$2.99
Mask of Sanity
My name is Tom Bailey. It all began with an investigation into the murder of a physician in a local asylum St. Verginy, which was coated with strange rumors.
Dark, Tense, Brutal
41% of 44 Steam reviews are positive$6.99
Sniper Killer
Eliminate your victims as a serial killer dubbed ‘The Sniper Killer’. Terrorize the city with your keen eye and thirst for blood while staying one step ahead of a detective hell bent on bringing you to justice.
Also in Detective · Dark, Tense, Brutal
86% of 638 Steam reviews are positive$11.99
PIGFACE
You are Exit, a terrible woman with a bomb drilled into her skull and a phone full of contracts. Clear sandbox missions your way: quiet knife work or a shotgun and a prayer. Retro grit, dismemberment, masks that change how you kill. Just get the job done.
Dark, Tense, Brutal
96% of 2,688 Steam reviews are positivePlayers online now: 77$13.99
Kingpin — Life of Crime
Kingpin is a tale of revenge. Take control of a street gang and order your recruits to attack, defend or even do a little safe-cracking to pick up some needed cash. Use that cash to buy nastier weapons and take down your punk enemies in this intense first-person shooter. Being the Kingpin is half attitude and all action.
Dark, Tense, Brutal
81% of 463 Steam reviews are positive$19.99
Crime Scene Cleaner
You play a single father hired by the mob to scrub crime scenes and pay for his sick daughter's care. Mop blood, bag bodies, pocket loose cash, and piece together what happened. Grim work, strange and funny, and hard to put down once the floor starts coming clean.
Dark, Tense, Brutal
98% of 33,096 Steam reviews are positivePlayers online now: 630$29.99
Manivore
He doesn’t just hunt to kill. Manivore is not just a murderer, he is an artist. For him, death is not an outcome but a process. Can you uncover the truth within this twisted game, or will you be the next prey?
Dark, Tense, Brutal
69% of 153 Steam reviews are positive$6.99
Scrutinized
You are Luna Youngman, a criminal analyst filing reports on the suspicious people of a quiet town, digging through their texts, purchases and search history to decide who is dangerous. The catch: two killers are working their way toward your house while you work. A tense mix of detective work and home defense, with permadeath on the line.
Also in Detective · Dark, Tense, Mysterious
89% of 1,326 Steam reviews are positivePlayers online now: 5$9.99
Fallen Aces
Switchblade City's protectors are being picked off one by one, and it falls to one man with two fists to find out why. A crime noir FPS that plays like the '90s and looks hand-drawn straight out of a comic: sneak, brawl or shoot your way through a real mystery.
Dark, Tense, Brutal
96% of 6,670 Steam reviews are positivePlayers online now: 33$14.99
Dread: The Cold Case
Dread: The Cold Case: First-person psychological horror blending investigation and intense melee combat. Scavenge, improvise, and survive using everything at your disposal against unimaginable horrors.
Also in Detective · Dark, Tense, Brutal
44% of 9 Steam reviews are positive$2.99
CONCRETE VISIONS
Concrete Visions is a first-person psychological thriller video game with survival horror, FPS and beat’em up elements. There are two main components to the gameplay - melee / lite arms combat and environmental exploration as you strive to survive the night.
Dark, Tense, Brutal
70% of 56 Steam reviews are positive$0.99

Cheaper than 2x4 Nails

The Happyhills Homicide 2: Out For Blood

He is back. Once again take control of mass serial killer John Wade.

$2.99

Dread: The Cold Case

Dread: The Cold Case: First-person psychological horror blending investigation and intense melee combat.

$2.99

CONCRETE VISIONS

Concrete Visions is a first-person psychological thriller video game with survival horror, FPS and beat’em up elements.

$0.99

DEAD TRASH

Years into a brutal lockdown, a once-thriving city lies in ruins, abandoned by its government and overrun by vicious, mindless infected.

$2.99

Psychopath Massacre

George Dinescu kidnapped you in his home in Romania. Get out alive while utilizing a V.H.S camera to film everything that happens inside.

$3.75

Grinded Meat

Sheriff Walter is investigating on a series of missing person cases in the small town of Quiete hill.

$1.99

A Killer's Sorrow

What if you were the killer? Wouldn't that be a thrill? But what if you're being hunted by an evil greater than yourself?

$1.99

Five Mysterious Murders

The serial killer simulator. Five teenagers arrive in a small town to make a horror show for their YouTube channel.

$3.99

SHLEMO

Action-packed stories of 3 different guys who kill people to get to a briefcase with supposed wealth.

$2.99

Fingered

GUILTY! THEY ARE ALL GUILTY! FINGERED is a "whodunit" hyperrealisic police sim where you must finger the guilty and clean up this darn city using…

$1.87

Tomato Way

FPS/Slasher/Horror for people with strong nerves. Tomato Way it`s like your favorite video game, but better.

$3.99

2Dark

2Dark is a stealth adventure game developed by Frédérick Raynal, the pioneer of survival horror games and creator of Alone in the Dark®.

$2.49

Hidden gems like 2x4 Nails

The Skin Stapler

Track a skin-stapling serial killer through a grimy neon city, while also stepping into the shoes of the people he stalks.

$8.99

PIGFACE

A fast, brutal first-person sandbox where every contract can go quiet or loud, and no two playthroughs unfold the same way.

$13.99

The Happyhills Homicide 2: Out For Blood

He is back. Once again take control of mass serial killer John Wade.

$2.99

Jackal

Execute ultra-violent raids in 1970s casino hotels. Take down the Las Vegas mob as a drug super-powered hitman in physics-fueled top-down close combat

$14.99

Butcher's Creek

Hunt for snuff tapes with hammer in hand, photograph what you leave behind, and try to stay alive in a grimy nightmare with a dark sense of humor.

$9.99

The Happyhills Homicide

Sneak through a sunny small town as the killer, solving each level like a puzzle and staying one step ahead of the detective hunting you.

Free

DEAD TRASH

Years into a brutal lockdown, a once-thriving city lies in ruins, abandoned by its government and overrun by vicious, mindless infected.

$2.99

Sniper Killer

Eliminate your victims as a serial killer dubbed ‘The Sniper Killer’.

$11.99

Twilight Town: A Cyberpunk FPS

Twilight Town: A Cyberpunk FPS is a brutal, funny, bloody FPS game with an advanced gore system.

$7.99

Fallen Aces

Switchblade City's protectors are being picked off one by one, and it falls to one man with two fists to find out why.

$14.99

Crime Scene Cleaner

Scrub away the evidence of other people's crimes, one mop stroke at a time, and pocket a little extra along the way.

$29.99

Where the forest ends

Shred zombies and bandits, collect and upgrade weapons, and explore the beauty hidden within industrial decay in a new story-driven, top-down horror…

$9.99

Newest games like 2x4 Nails