Co-op games like PotionPanic

If the replayable and fast-paced rhythm of PotionPanic stuck with you, this helps. These co-op games are a good place to start. You can bring friends along for most of these.

Potion Party
Potion Party is a funny couch co-op alchemy game for one to four players. Working as a team, you and your friends must manage your own alchemy shop. Earn money, upgrade your tools, decorate the shop and become a master alchemist!
Also in Party · Replayable, Fast-paced, Colorful
90% of 90 Steam reviews are positive$9.99
Potion Shop Simulator
Master the art of alchemy in Potion Shop Simulator, a unique blend of simulation and strategy. Brew potions, manage your shop, and cater to a magical clientele in a single-player or co-op experience of the medieval fantasy world.
Colorful, Cute
79% of 62 Steam reviews are positive$12.99
Cauldron Chaos: Brew Potions & Tidy Up
Cauldron Chaos: Brew Potions & Tidy Up is an alchemy organization game enjoyable solo or co-op. Clean up 1000+ ingredients, refine them in multiple ways and brew almost 200 unique recipes to place them into correct shelves to transform the laboratory into a place filled with harmony & peace.
Replayable, Chaotic, Colorful
71% of 24 Steam reviews are positivePlayers online now: 1$7.99
Potion Brew: Co-op
You need this game to forget about your life cares and become the best alchemist of this fantasy world with your friends! An alchemy shop keeper game offers you to brew potions for your customers, loot the ingredients in the forest, trade with sellers and compete with rivals.
Colorful, Cute
76% of 50 Steam reviews are positive$4.99
Witchtastic
Witchtastic is a challenging 2-4 player coop game about brewing and delivering magic potions as fast as possible. Take on the role of aspiring witches and experience charming adventures. Need a break from all the yelling of your friends? You can practice in a single player campaign as well!
Also in Party · Replayable, Fast-paced, Chaotic
92% of 242 Steam reviews are positive$17.99
Pots and Potions
A game about crafting potions with the craziest effects against the clock (and your mates).
Also in Party · Replayable, Fast-paced, Chaotic
86% of 7 Steam reviews are positiveFree
Potion Commotion
Live the CRAZY life of a Wizard’s assistant in this hilarious Clicker game! You’ll be in charge of making wacky and wonderful Potions, using ingredients produced in your garden. With plenty of twists and turns along the way, the fun never stops! Do you have what it takes?
Colorful, Cute, Funny
82% of 142 Steam reviews are positiveFree
AMPANIC
A hyper-fast tool shop where every job is done with your aim, built for co-op friends to run together. You grab passersby, gather materials, process and craft orders, and deliver before angry customers walk out. Splitting the chaos makes it funnier and barely survivable.
Replayable, Fast-paced, Chaotic
100% of 72 Steam reviews are positivePlayers online now: 5$3.99
Innchanted
Run a Magical Inn with friends! Yarrul’s family Inn has been stolen by an evil wizard landlord! Team up with friends to reclaim your family's legacy. Manage your inn, brew potions, fish, cook, and fight in this hectic & heartfelt magical adventure. Play solo or co-op for 1-4 players.
Also in Party · Fast-paced, Chaotic, Colorful
84% of 117 Steam reviews are positive$19.99
Pizza Panic!
Pizza Panic! Is a 1-4-player co-op cooking game where you and your friends try to keep your pizza parlor running for as long as possible. Work together, bake pizzas, earn money, buy upgrades and ensure you have the greatest pizza parlor of all time!
Also in Party · Replayable, Fast-paced, Chaotic
55% of 44 Steam reviews are positiveFree
Burger Witch
Magic meets mayhem in this frantic burger-crafting adventure! Assemble enchanted burgers, manage chaotic kitchen orders, and work with friends to meet your spooky quota before time runs out. Cook, cast, and conquer the kitchen—because in this dungeon, witches don’t brew potions, they grill patties!
Replayable, Fast-paced, Chaotic
71% of 7 Steam reviews are positive$4.99
Abracadabrew
Abracadabrew is a memory-based 1-4 player local co-op game. Cooperate with friends while using your memory to brew as many potions as you can by dawn. Gather ingredients hidden around the room while communicating and staying focused to unlock new brain-racking potion combinations.
Also in Party · Replayable, Fast-paced, Chaotic
94% of 18 Steam reviews are positive$11.99

Hidden gems like PotionPanic

Boba Cafe Simulator

Run a milk tea shop with up to 8 co-op friends, hand-crafting every cup from sliced fruit to cooked pearls.

$15.99

Barfender: CO-OP Bar Simulator

Barfender is a chaotic 1-4 player co-op bar sim where you and your co-op friends pour beers, shake cocktails, mop up messes, and stop fights while…

$12.99

Wand & Order: Tidy up the magic shop!

Your cleaning spell turned into a tornado and trashed a magic shop with thousands of items.

$4.79

Pizza House Simulator🍕

Run a pizzeria on the Amalfi Coast solo or with up to 6 co-op friends.

$12.99

Breezy Bakes Simulator

Run a seaside Italian bakery with up to four co-op friends, making dough, firing the oven, and getting pizzas and breads to customers before they…

$10.99

Moonshiner Simulator

Scavenge supplies, brew your own recipes and grow a backwoods spirits operation, solo or with friends.

$10.79

Tidy Up Together

An evil wizard tornado-blasted your fantasy adventurer shop, scattering potions, greatswords, sushi and pineapples across the floor.

$5.99

Sandwich Simulator

Run a sandwich shop with co-op friends: take orders, stack bread and fillings, pour drinks, and get trays to tables before patience runs out.

$4.99

Ale & Tale Tavern: First Pints

Cook, serve, clean tables, hunt boars, fish, farm, and fight off monsters between orders.

Free

Bone's Cafe

Bone's Cafe is a fast paced, 1-4 Players couch co-op, cooking game. Customize the layout of your kitchen to guarantee your success.

$14.99

The Roast - Coffee Shop Simulator

Manage your own coffee shop and play together with your friends.

$3.99

Bronzebeard's Tavern

Run a dwarven tavern with up to seven co-op friends, splitting jobs between seating guests, taking orders, cooking without burning anything, and…

Free

Newest co-op games like PotionPanic

Moonshiner Simulator

Scavenge supplies, brew your own recipes and grow a backwoods spirits operation, solo or with friends.

$10.79

Tall Orders

Tall Orders is a co-op platforming game where you and a friend play as small gnomes tending to a wizard's potion shop for the day.

Free

AMPANIC

A hyper-fast tool shop where every job is done with your aim, built for co-op friends to run together.

$3.99

Barfender: CO-OP Bar Simulator

Barfender is a chaotic 1-4 player co-op bar sim where you and your co-op friends pour beers, shake cocktails, mop up messes, and stop fights while…

$12.99

Dinerz

Run your own first-person diner, from first sizzle to final bill.

$7.99

Cauldron Chaos: Brew Potions & Tidy Up

Cauldron Chaos: Brew Potions & Tidy Up is an alchemy organization game enjoyable solo or co-op.

$7.99

Dragon Dinner

An explosive cocktail of intense strategic action and deceivingly cute dragons!

$9.99

Coin & Cauldron

The Kingdom of Valoria is in grave danger - The King has sent his most trusted Alchemist to help fight off the monster hordes near the town of…

$14.99

Wand & Order: Tidy up the magic shop!

Your cleaning spell turned into a tornado and trashed a magic shop with thousands of items.

$4.79

Medieval Juice Crafter

Craft your special recipe juices and sell them in medieval villages. Expand your business with new recipes, machines, properties, and workers.

$5.99

Burger Shift: Team Rush

Run a fast food joint with up to 8 co-op friends, taking orders, flipping burgers, running fryers and soda fountains while the rush piles up.

$14.99

Alchemy Factory

Start with a tiny medieval shop, then team up with co-op friends to belt, pipe, and magically fling resources into potions, jewelry, and relics.

$17.99