Co-op games like Potion Problems

Hooked on the colorful and funny side of Potion Problems? These co-op games make natural next picks for you. You can bring friends along for most of these.

Which Wizard?
A multiplayer social deduction game with mystery, mischief, and magic! Use magical abilities and your powers of deduction to figure out who in your party of Wizards is a secret traitor. One (or more) in your group is truly evil... but Which Wizard is it?
Also in Party · Colorful, Funny, Replayable
86% of 21 Steam reviews are positive$4.99
Villainy
A game of cooperation and betrayal. Gather your party of 4-10 players, but trust no one. Heroes and Villains plot against each other in quick, highly intense matches. Deception is your greatest weapon, and secrecy is the ultimate defense.
Also in Party · Colorful, Funny, Replayable
94% of 89 Steam reviews are positive$7.99
Potion Party
Potion Party is a funny couch co-op alchemy game for one to four players. Working as a team, you and your friends must manage your own alchemy shop. Earn money, upgrade your tools, decorate the shop and become a master alchemist!
Also in Party · Colorful, Funny, Replayable
90% of 90 Steam reviews are positive$9.99
Hodgepodge Hunch
Hodgepodge Hunch is a who-done-it game where everyone chips in to make a hotpot dish. Collaborate with your buddies to collect ingredients in the dungeons and whip up a delicious feast. There's just one problem... A backstabber may be lurking among you who'll throw your dinner plans awry...
Also in Party · Colorful, Funny, Replayable
93% of 142 Steam reviews are positive$4.99
Paper Pirates
Grab a crew and jump aboard a haunted pirate ship for a social deduction party game, using your phones as controllers! Are you a human sailing home to shore or a ghost working against the crew? Throw your crewmates overboard, but fear not - nobody’s ever out of the game!
Also in Party · Colorful, Funny, Replayable
91% of 114 Steam reviews are positive$12.99
Pots and Potions
A game about crafting potions with the craziest effects against the clock (and your mates).
Also in Party · Colorful, Funny, Replayable
86% of 7 Steam reviews are positiveFree
First Class Trouble
A 1950s-style space cruise ship, a rogue AI named CAIN, and two killer robots hiding among your co-op friends. Work the shutdown together, then turn on each other over who is lying. Champagne bottles included.
Also in Party · Funny, Replayable, Competitive
79% of 3,113 Steam reviews are positivePlayers online now: 41$14.99
Castle of Blackwater
Castle of Blackwater is a 2D, action-packed, social deduction game with a magical twist. In this intense game of trust and betrayal, up to 10 strangers are trapped in a castle of danger and deception, with a mission to complete tasks and escape with their lives.
Colorful, Funny, Replayable
90% of 181 Steam reviews are positiveFree
Deadly Trick
Deadly Trick is a social deduction game playable with up to 8 players. Survive the death game unfolding at school under the name "Special Class." Depending on the situation or your own choices, you could become the White or the Shadow! Cooperate… or betray.
Also in Party · Colorful, Funny, Replayable
94% of 154 Steam reviews are positive$8.99
Witchtastic
Witchtastic is a challenging 2-4 player coop game about brewing and delivering magic potions as fast as possible. Take on the role of aspiring witches and experience charming adventures. Need a break from all the yelling of your friends? You can practice in a single player campaign as well!
Also in Party · Colorful, Funny, Replayable
92% of 242 Steam reviews are positive$17.99
Feign
Feign is a cartoon social-deduction party for up to 12 co-op friends, split into Innocents, Impostors, and Neutrals. Use a secret role at night, then argue and vote someone out by day. Rounds are quick, replayable, and built for lying badly and laughing about it.
Also in Party · Colorful, Funny, Replayable
91% of 5,301 Steam reviews are positivePlayers online now: 194$2.74
diffiCULT
Step into a fully 3D medieval world of deception. diffiCULT is a multiplayer social deduction game where you must uncover hidden cultists. Use proximity voice chat, investigate houses at night, survive daily votes, and reveal who is truly on your side.
Also in Party · Replayable, Competitive
91% of 68 Steam reviews are positive$4.99

Hidden gems like Potion Problems

Deadly Trick

Deadly Trick is a social deduction game playable with up to 8 players. Survive the death game unfolding at school under the name "Special Class."

$8.99

Dawson Oaks Trailer Park

A trailer park full of criminals, one Supervisor watching, and a Snitch hiding among you.

$9.99

Castle of Blackwater

Castle of Blackwater is a 2D, action-packed, social deduction game with a magical twist.

Free

Feign

Feign is a cartoon social-deduction party for up to 12 co-op friends, split into Innocents, Impostors, and Neutrals.

$2.74

Hodgepodge Hunch

Hodgepodge Hunch is a who-done-it game where everyone chips in to make a hotpot dish.

$4.99

Deducto 2

A fun sus-like game where you backstab your co-workers and get mad at your co-workers for backstabbing you. (up to 16 players)

$4.99

Betrayal Beach

Crashed on a strange island, survivors must forage, craft, and complete objectives to stay alive.

Free

Escape First Alchemist ⚗️

First-person escape game, playable solo or co-op with up to 4 people. Solve riddles of a reclusive alchemist that trapped you in his workshop.

$3.99

Witchtastic

Witchtastic is a challenging 2-4 player coop game about brewing and delivering magic potions as fast as possible.

$17.99

Deducto

Deducto is a first-person hidden-role shooter for 6-10 players set in an office.

Free

ESPIONAGE: Mafia Evolved

A free-to-play Single-and-Multiplayer social deduction game in which role-based play rewards those who rely on strategy and their creative instincts.

Free

Super Sus

Super Sus is a cartoony multiplayer social deduction game set on a spaceship, where Spacecrew finish tasks, Impostors sabotage and eliminate…

Free

Newest co-op games like Potion Problems

Alterum

A multiplayer horror of spoken magic and one possessed friend in the group.

$8.99

Scam Line

Scam Line locks 4 to 8 co-op friends in separate rooms with only old mobile phones to talk through.

$6.99

WAZATO: Sabotage or Mistake?

Sabotage or Mistake? A 4-player online party game mixing co-op action with social deduction.

$6.99

Haunted Heist

Haunted Heist is a 3-8 player round-based party game where a team of Heisters sneaks through a procedurally generated mansion to carry gems back to…

$9.99

Dawson Oaks Trailer Park

A trailer park full of criminals, one Supervisor watching, and a Snitch hiding among you.

$9.99

Masters of Mayhem

A vibrant co-op social deduction adventure with roguelike twists, wild abilities, monsters, and nonstop mayhem.

Free

Deadly Trick

Deadly Trick is a social deduction game playable with up to 8 players. Survive the death game unfolding at school under the name "Special Class."

$8.99

diffiCULT

Step into a fully 3D medieval world of deception. diffiCULT is a multiplayer social deduction game where you must uncover hidden cultists.

$4.99

North Hunt

An online social deduction game that will ruin your friendships.

$6.50

Forest of Deceit

A STORM IS COMING. If you can’t build shelter in a matter of days your entire group will perish.

$7.99

Stick Scholars

A social deduction party game where players parkour to school, answer trivia, and hunt down a hidden Class Clown who is sabotaging to try and make…

$4.99

STAB!

Betray your friends. Lie. Survive. STAB! is a chaotic social party game where trust is a mistake.

$0.99