Games like The Babysitter

If The Babysitter scratched a story-driven and mysterious itch for you, keep reading. These games offer a similar pull for your backlog.

Hidden gems like The Babysitter

Alice's World

Alice's World

Alice's World is a story-driven 2D adventure puzzle game. Amidst desolate ruins and deserted cities in a world filled with death, the young girl…

89% of 339 Steam reviews are positive$13.99
Down the Rabbit Hole Flattened

Down the Rabbit Hole Flattened

Down the Rabbit Hole is an adventure set in Wonderland prior to Alice's arrival.

90% of 354 Steam reviews are positivePlayers online now: 3Free
Lil' Guardsman

Lil' Guardsman

Interrogate over 100 visitors at the castle gate and decide who gets in, one shift at a time.

93% of 1,213 Steam reviews are positivePlayers online now: 24$3.99
Little Goody Two Shoes

Little Goody Two Shoes

Win hearts in Kieferberg by day, outlast the Woods' horrors by night, and let every choice steer one of ten endings.

95% of 2,275 Steam reviews are positivePlayers online now: 32$19.99
The Baby In Yellow

The Baby In Yellow

Care for a baby who teleports, floats and whispers orders into your head, across 11 chapters of a nightmare that starts in a cozy flat.

96% of 2,432 Steam reviews are positivePlayers online now: 23$8.99
Life Eater

Life Eater

If you don't sacrifice your neighbors, the world ends. Life Eater is a horror fantasy kidnapping simulator where you must become intimately familiar…

85% of 332 Steam reviews are positive$14.99
Children of Silentown

Children of Silentown

Help Lucy uncover why people vanish from her village, through a point & click adventure where cute drawings hide something dark.

86% of 1,031 Steam reviews are positivePlayers online now: 10$19.99
Lily's Well

Lily's Well

A rainy night in 2005. Nine-year-old Lily hears a voice crying for help from the well, and the only way down is a rope you build from whatever the…

97% of 2,712 Steam reviews are positivePlayers online now: 5Free
a pet shop after dark

a pet shop after dark

PETSITTER WANTED. A horror point-and-click adventure game. Water the plants, feed the pets, and DON'T turn off the lights.

89% of 368 Steam reviews are positive$9.99
A Juggler's Tale

A Juggler's Tale

Guide a runaway puppet through a rhyming, cinematic fairy tale where her own strings shape every puzzle.

93% of 1,331 Steam reviews are positivePlayers online now: 2$17.99
Lost in Play

Lost in Play

Guide a brother and sister through a surreal, hand-drawn world, solving gentle puzzles with nothing but gestures and gibberish.

98% of 8,541 Steam reviews are positivePlayers online now: 9$19.99
The Dream Libra had

The Dream Libra had

The two girls who had a traffic accident, Libra and her girlfriend Amili, wander the supernatural world as Near-death experience.

94% of 186 Steam reviews are positiveFree

Newest games like The Babysitter

Alice Nation

Alice Nation

Explore, talk, and solve puzzles with cards in a solo tabletop adventure! Play as Alice, a girl trapped in the Beyond.

97% of 468 Steam reviews are positivePlayers online now: 3$7.99
Alice's Night at the Mansion

Alice's Night at the Mansion

Three eccentric ghosts have kidnapped Alice's dog, Dinah! Help Alice free her dog, solve the mysteries of Monster Mansion, and make the annual…

100% of 5 Steam reviews are positive$4.99
Only Good Babysitters Go To Heaven

Only Good Babysitters Go To Heaven

Only Good Babysitters Go To Heaven is a First-Person comedy horror game about being stuck babysitting while the news is expressing that the world…

91% of 57 Steam reviews are positivePlayers online now: 3$5.99
Alice's World

Alice's World

Alice's World is a story-driven 2D adventure puzzle game. Amidst desolate ruins and deserted cities in a world filled with death, the young girl…

89% of 339 Steam reviews are positive$13.99
Down the Rabbit Hole Flattened

Down the Rabbit Hole Flattened

Down the Rabbit Hole is an adventure set in Wonderland prior to Alice's arrival.

90% of 354 Steam reviews are positivePlayers online now: 3Free
Babette

Babette

There's this old 90s virtual pet game at a yard sale. It's called 'Babette'. Now you can play with Babette the cat from the comfort of your bedroom.

92% of 36 Steam reviews are positive$3.99
Alice's Lullaby

Alice's Lullaby

Embark on a surreal, psychedelic adventure to travel back and forth through time and rescue young Alice, helping her escape the uncanny, macabre and…

84% of 37 Steam reviews are positive$14.99
Life Eater

Life Eater

If you don't sacrifice your neighbors, the world ends. Life Eater is a horror fantasy kidnapping simulator where you must become intimately familiar…

85% of 332 Steam reviews are positive$14.99
Lil' Guardsman

Lil' Guardsman

Interrogate over 100 visitors at the castle gate and decide who gets in, one shift at a time.

93% of 1,213 Steam reviews are positivePlayers online now: 24$3.99
Joker Show - Horror Escape

Joker Show - Horror Escape

Your parents left for the night, and you stayed at home alone, you were bored and you decided to call the Jester (Joker), but something went wrong...

75% of 809 Steam reviews are positivePlayers online now: 3Free
Little Goody Two Shoes

Little Goody Two Shoes

Win hearts in Kieferberg by day, outlast the Woods' horrors by night, and let every choice steer one of ten endings.

95% of 2,275 Steam reviews are positivePlayers online now: 32$19.99
The Baby In Yellow

The Baby In Yellow

Care for a baby who teleports, floats and whispers orders into your head, across 11 chapters of a nightmare that starts in a cozy flat.

96% of 2,432 Steam reviews are positivePlayers online now: 23$8.99