Games like ScreamCap

Still thinking about ScreamCap and its mysterious and story-driven tone? You will find a few strong contenders among these games.

LiveScream
Armed with nothing but your curiosity, streaming equipment, and insatiable need to impress others, you approach a long-abandoned house in your small town. What could possibly go wrong?
Also in Detective · Mysterious, Story-driven, Hand-drawn
89% of 9 Steam reviews are positive$2.99
Paranormal Teens
Based on the fictional reality TV series Paranormal Teens. Free to play.
Mysterious, Story-driven, Hand-drawn
51% of 111 Steam reviews are positiveFree
By Moonlight
~ ~ A Comedic Mystery Visual Novel with Relationship Building ~ ~ Play as a paranormal investigator hired by the paranormal to investigate! Search for a headless horseman's missing head before the night is over.
Mysterious, Story-driven, Hand-drawn
88% of 118 Steam reviews are positiveFree
The Case of the Serialized Killer
Delve into a devilishly delightful world of mysticism and mystery as Harold Ludicael, the disgraced demonologist. After the untimely demise of a famous illustrator, you’re tasked with solving their murder in this point-and-click visual novel.
Also in Detective · Mysterious, Story-driven, Hand-drawn
90% of 86 Steam reviews are positiveFree
Scarlet Hollow
Your aunt's funeral pulls you to Scarlet Hollow, a small mountain town where the mine is sealed, livestock is going missing and something is very wrong. A horror-mystery visual novel with hand-drawn art, traits that change your dialogue, and branching so dense one playthrough shows less than a fifth of it. You have a week. Good luck.
Mysterious, Story-driven, Hand-drawn
97% of 4,972 Steam reviews are positivePlayers online now: 108$23.99
Vivian Carmine
In an average town somewhere in America, a disturbance has been felt. Vivian Carmine and her badge, Nicholas, have come from the Gap Between Worlds to investigate.
Mysterious, Story-driven, Hand-drawn
86% of 22 Steam reviews are positiveFree
Hermitage: Strange Case Files
This gripping paranormal horror adventure revolves around Hermitage, the sinister bookstore that attracts most unusual customers – all of whom seem to be involved in mysterious cases bordering on the paranormal.
Also in Detective · Mysterious, Story-driven, Hand-drawn
76% of 33 Steam reviews are positive$19.99
Stillwater
A short visual novel where a private investigator gets reeled into a murky mystery, entangled in lies, secrets, and a family curse.
Also in Detective · Mysterious, Story-driven, Hand-drawn
95% of 246 Steam reviews are positiveFree
Urban Myth Dissolution Center
Join the Urban Myth Dissolution Center as Azami, a new hire who reads residual thoughts through her glasses. Cursed relics, creepy rental listings, dimensional anomalies: each case is a short occult mystery told in psychedelic pixel art, with social media digging, onsite legwork and a psychic boss who divines the truth from his desk.
Also in Detective · Mysterious, Story-driven, Hand-drawn
87% of 6,107 Steam reviews are positivePlayers online now: 49$12.59
Blood Lily: Killers Can't Sink a Yuri Ship
A B-horror mystery comedy adventure game. Having a crush on your bestie is hard enough without serial killers in the way! Lily's vacay plan to romance her crush Sally goes wrong when killers keep cropping up and ruining the mood. And that means war. "How dare you come between Sally and me!"
Also in Detective · Mysterious, Story-driven, Hand-drawn
89% of 46 Steam reviews are positive$5.99
Jill O' Lantern: Final Cut
Find the clues to make a time bending turnabout in this off the rails visual novel about murder, mayhem, and a thicc pumpkin girl with a machete.
Also in Detective · Mysterious, Story-driven, Hand-drawn
100% of 15 Steam reviews are positive$6.99
When The Night Comes
When The Night Comes is a queer, narrative-driven, supernatural visual novel.
Mysterious, Story-driven, Hand-drawn
92% of 290 Steam reviews are positivePlayers online now: 2$12.99

Cheaper than ScreamCap

LiveScream

Armed with nothing but your curiosity, streaming equipment, and insatiable need to impress others, you approach a long-abandoned house in your small…

$2.99

Blood Lily: Killers Can't Sink a Yuri Ship

A B-horror mystery comedy adventure game. Having a crush on your bestie is hard enough without serial killers in the way!

$5.99

Creepy Support

Save people from terrible paranormal dangers as a support operator of a secret SCP-like organization!

$4.99

Case 03: True Cannibal Boy

A horror mystery adventure game with ghost story elements. Anxiety plagues college student Lily, whose crush Sally has gone missing.

$5.99

Kansei

A murder mystery visual novel. Use your psychic powers to uncover secrets and hunt down a murderer.

$8.99

Sunlight Scream

The hero moves to a new city. However, along with him comes a masked killer who begins to kill his friends one by one...

$6.99

Blood Lily Ghoststories

A horror game about a needy female ghost. A trio of close-knit occult club girls gather late at night to enjoy telling ghost stories.

$2.99

Blood Lily Loop

Your bestie seems to be hiding something. There's something about your world that seems odd as well, like it has...secrets.

$2.99

Yousei

A murder mystery visual novel. Dig into your history as you chase down a murderer.

$8.99

CABALL

Veronica doesn't believe in mysticism, but the unexplained events that occur after she loses her job will make her change her mind forever.

$6.99

PARANORMAL GIRLFRIEND

A mysterious girl shows up at your house and things get wild...

$5.99

SCP: Doki Doki Anomaly

SCP-8008-1 IS A HORROR DATING SIM WHERE THE BEST YOU CAN HOPE FOR IS SURVIVAL. SMOOCH SCP-173, SCP-682 AND EVEN SCP-096.

$5.99

Hidden gems like ScreamCap

Familiar Friends: What's Your Familiar?

A cute and cozy Visual Novel experience with plenty of choices to make!

Free

Urban Myth Dissolution Center

Investigate cursed relics and impossible anomalies as a rookie psychic detective, one strange urban myth at a time.

$12.59

Stillwater

A short visual novel where a private investigator gets reeled into a murky mystery, entangled in lies, secrets, and a family curse.

Free

PARANORMASIGHT: The Seven Mysteries of Honjo

Follow several points of view through 1980s Tokyo, uncover the truth behind the Seven Mysteries of Honjo, and try to survive a story where one wrong…

$19.99

Night Cascades

The city is on fire, and the Devil is to blame - or is it? Two women must solve an occult-themed mystery set in an alternate 1980s while unraveling…

$9.99

Gore Screaming Show

A deeply unsettling visual novel following a boy who returns to his hometown expecting to find peace; however, it isn't long before his hopes are…

$29.99

When The Night Comes

When The Night Comes is a queer, narrative-driven, supernatural visual novel.

$12.99

Scarlet Hollow

Your aunt's funeral pulls you to Scarlet Hollow, a small mountain town where the mine is sealed, livestock is going missing and something is very…

$23.99

CORPSE FACTORY

Discard your sense of morality and enter the world of CORPSE FACTORY. An obscure website allows users to request a death.

$19.99

The Case Book of Arne

A vampire and a girl... who are they? The two of them have a secret and solve a strange case...

$9.99

Nanairo Reincarnation

Join spirit detective Kagami Makoto and his demon familiars as they hunt down the wandering ghosts disrupting the peace of his small town.

$14.99

Heart of the Woods

A fantasy yuri visual novel filled with magic, fairies, and a ghost girl.

$14.99

Newest games like ScreamCap