Games like My Putrid Ponies

Chasing that scary and tense feeling you got from My Putrid Ponies? These games keep things close enough to feel familiar.

Cheaper than My Putrid Ponies

Scary Game 2: The Mad Shepherd

Scary Game 2: The Mad Shepherd

Your first day as the village's new shepherd, and the barn is already empty.

90% of 1,385 Steam reviews are positivePlayers online now: 8$1.99
You Must

You Must

In the social network, the main character plays the quest "Hide and Seek", but this time the organizers decided to move the quest to the real world.

75% of 496 Steam reviews are positive$1.99
Eve of Souls: Static Pod

Eve of Souls: Static Pod

[The pod will break soon. Will she survive the nightmare or find the truth?]

95% of 468 Steam reviews are positive$2.99
Mansion of the Dead

Mansion of the Dead

Step into the shoes of Agent Kim, drawn into a chilling mystery deep in the wilderness.

94% of 78 Steam reviews are positive$2.99
Zort

Zort

Four friends, a dark map full of creatures, and one exit to find before panic wins.

90% of 11,883 Steam reviews are positivePlayers online now: 27$4
VRZ: Torment

VRZ: Torment

Be immersed into Purgatory Island of undead and dying. Solve mysteries to escape while trying to survive.

69% of 186 Steam reviews are positive$0.99
The Dead are Not Dead

The Dead are Not Dead

Five years after the world is devastated by a zombie virus, Alfred is looking for Jake, his older brother.

85% of 39 Steam reviews are positive$1.99
The Final Take

The Final Take

Relive dark footage recorded from the perspective of multiple characters in this unique first person horror.

55% of 265 Steam reviews are positive$1.99
The Method of Hiding a Body

The Method of Hiding a Body

A story-driven horror puzzle game where the player takes on the role of a resentful ghost, possessing others in order to search for her own corpse.

89% of 76 Steam reviews are positivePlayers online now: 1$3.99
Fear of Clowns

Fear of Clowns

You woke up in the middle of the night from the doorbell's sound. Someone wants to play with you...

63% of 157 Steam reviews are positive$0.99
The Deadseat

The Deadseat

A horror game where you play a hand-held console in the backseat during a long drive home.

97% of 628 Steam reviews are positivePlayers online now: 1$2.99
Eaten Alive

Eaten Alive

Eaten Alive is a Point and Click, Adventure, Horror game with Puzzle and Mystery game-play elements.

40% of 336 Steam reviews are positivePlayers online now: 2$1.99

Hidden gems like My Putrid Ponies

Scary Game 2: The Mad Shepherd

Scary Game 2: The Mad Shepherd

Your first day as the village's new shepherd, and the barn is already empty.

90% of 1,385 Steam reviews are positivePlayers online now: 8$1.99
Carnival Massacre

Carnival Massacre

Drawing heavily from classic survival horror tropes, Carnival Massacre takes players on a haunting quest in a cursed theme park.

92% of 222 Steam reviews are positivePlayers online now: 1$4.99
Among Ashes

Among Ashes

Among Ashes is a terrifying first-person survival horror game.

95% of 443 Steam reviews are positive$14.99
Silly Polly Beast

Silly Polly Beast

Shoot, skate and cast forbidden spells through a grim underworld where every bullet counts and the story keeps twisting.

90% of 2,383 Steam reviews are positivePlayers online now: 10$19.99
Echoes of the Living

Echoes of the Living

Explore a fog-choked town, ration your ammo and piece together the mystery while the dead close in.

83% of 1,048 Steam reviews are positivePlayers online now: 7$24.99
D'LIRIUM

D'LIRIUM

An experimental 2D-shooter with the elements of a horror game. D'lirium brings together some mechanics back from 90s classics.

96% of 987 Steam reviews are positivePlayers online now: 2$4.99
Deformed

Deformed

Single player horror game set in an underground lab. Kill monsters and escape.

95% of 164 Steam reviews are positive$4.99
The Bunny Graveyard

The Bunny Graveyard

You are a cursor, sucked into a computer where a bunny named Skye runs a garden with her Handy Pals. It looks adorable. It is not.

95% of 1,390 Steam reviews are positivePlayers online now: 2$6.99
PUMPKIN PANIC

PUMPKIN PANIC

Run a small forest farm while something in the dark waits for the sun to go down, and try to escape with your one life.

96% of 4,236 Steam reviews are positivePlayers online now: 20Free
Eyes: The Horror Game

Eyes: The Horror Game

You break into the mansion at night. It’s huge and built like a maze. You're trying to escape, but the monster is after you! The chase begins. RUN!!

90% of 980 Steam reviews are positivePlayers online now: 5$4.99
My Friendly Neighborhood

My Friendly Neighborhood

Repair a dead TV studio where the felt stars have turned hostile, shooting letters and piecing together what went wrong.

96% of 2,539 Steam reviews are positivePlayers online now: 21$29.99
Massacre At The Mirage

Massacre At The Mirage

For less than the price of a movie ticket, experience your very own horror-fueled slasher flick in Massacre at the Mirage.

84% of 368 Steam reviews are positive$12.49

Newest games like My Putrid Ponies

Poopy's Playland

Poopy's Playland

Play as a grieving mother whose child went missing in a playland one year ago.

73% of 89 Steam reviews are positive$11
Project: Mist

Project: Mist

Scavenge a monster-haunted island, build a moving base on rails, and uncover its secrets alone or with friends.

71% of 328 Steam reviews are positivePlayers online now: 19$17.99
Tache Noire

Tache Noire

An exploration Survival Horror game set in the idyllic town of Lucenille. Explore every single crevice and find what happened to your friends.

95% of 58 Steam reviews are positive$16.99
Rainbow Gate

Rainbow Gate

Rainbow Gate is a survival horror game set in an abandoned toy factory and amusement park that was once full of joy, but has now become a deadly trap.

68% of 125 Steam reviews are positivePlayers online now: 1$13.99
Carnival Massacre

Carnival Massacre

Drawing heavily from classic survival horror tropes, Carnival Massacre takes players on a haunting quest in a cursed theme park.

92% of 222 Steam reviews are positivePlayers online now: 1$4.99
Echoes of the Living

Echoes of the Living

Explore a fog-choked town, ration your ammo and piece together the mystery while the dead close in.

83% of 1,048 Steam reviews are positivePlayers online now: 7$24.99
Silly Polly Beast

Silly Polly Beast

Shoot, skate and cast forbidden spells through a grim underworld where every bullet counts and the story keeps twisting.

90% of 2,383 Steam reviews are positivePlayers online now: 10$19.99
PONE

PONE

A co-op survival horror game where you and your closest friends must work together to survive in an upside down world crawling with the infected.

81% of 262 Steam reviews are positivePlayers online now: 3$7.99
Mortanis Prisoners

Mortanis Prisoners

Mortanis Prisoners - A survival horror game set in a Third Reich concentration camp where the camp's leadership, upon discovering a planned…

79% of 72 Steam reviews are positive$12.99
Inside the Crow´s Nest

Inside the Crow´s Nest

Inside the Crow's Nest is a game inspired by classic survival horror.

75% of 48 Steam reviews are positiveFree
Seek

Seek

In this game, you play as Alice, an girl trapped in a twisted, ever-changing world.

81% of 114 Steam reviews are positive$4.99
Lurking Danger

Lurking Danger

Lurking Danger is a survival horror where Elena and Regina, two diner waitresses, uncover a dark secret.

68% of 50 Steam reviews are positive$11.99