Games like Magic Toenail

If Magic Toenail left you wanting something replayable and cute, you have options. These games could fill that gap nicely.

Cheaper than Magic Toenail

Machick

Machick

Defeat the heavily armed army of anti-magic toads and free the forest from destruction.

84% of 208 Steam reviews are positive$3.14
Neophyte

Neophyte

A mini topdown action roguelike with chaotic spell-slinging hack-n-slash combat.

90% of 662 Steam reviews are positive$2.99
PUTRID SHOT ULTRA

PUTRID SHOT ULTRA

A chaotic shoot-em-up roguelite with magic spell casting. Defeat enemies with your gun!

100% of 46 Steam reviews are positive$2.99
Wizard Shrimp

Wizard Shrimp

Wizard Shrimp™ is a bullet-hell roguelite game where you play as a Shrimp who is inexplicably also a Wizard?!

98% of 100 Steam reviews are positive$2.99
ByteRogue

ByteRogue

ByteRogue is a minimalist turn-based puzzle-tactics roguelike where you play as a wizard-thief.

100% of 7 Steam reviews are positive$2.55
Wizard's Guide

Wizard's Guide

"Wizard's Guide" is a strategic RPG that combines "puzzle" and "rogue-lite" elements.

100% of 2 Steam reviews are positive$2.99
Spell Defender

Spell Defender

Spell Defender is a 3D, Third-Person, wave defence, survival Roguelite. Use magical powers to defeat waves of enemies.

86% of 133 Steam reviews are positive$2.99
CharmEdge Deck

CharmEdge Deck

A laid-back casual roguelike-DBG game! As a genius mage-swordsman apprentice, build your magic deck, wield Enchantments and Skills, and teach that…

94% of 32 Steam reviews are positive$2.99
Little Witch Survivors

Little Witch Survivors

"Little Witch Survivors" is a magic pigeon barrage shooting game.

87% of 547 Steam reviews are positivePlayers online now: 7$3.84
The Wand Wizard

The Wand Wizard

Create insane combinations of power and break the game in every possible way to get your name on the leaderboards!

67% of 3 Steam reviews are positive$0.99
MAGIC & MONSTERS

MAGIC & MONSTERS

Collect weapons and magic, fight your way through hordes of enemies, and venture deeper into the dungeon. What awaits you at the very end...?

$3
Orb Tower

Orb Tower

A Roguelike Bubble Puzzler! Choose your school of magic and reach the top of the tower! Chill pick up and play feel and nostalgic pixel art and music.

95% of 203 Steam reviews are positive$1.99

Hidden gems like Magic Toenail

Neophyte

Neophyte

A mini topdown action roguelike with chaotic spell-slinging hack-n-slash combat.

90% of 662 Steam reviews are positive$2.99
Rift Wizard 3

Rift Wizard 3

A hardcore turn-based roguelike where you build a wizard from over 500 spells and artifacts, then blast, summon or enchant your way through 20…

90% of 415 Steam reviews are positivePlayers online now: 94$19.99
Magecraft: Spellbuilding

Magecraft: Spellbuilding

Craft spell cards, collect new effects, and build the perfect deck as you fight through rounds of turn-based combat.

98% of 154 Steam reviews are positivePlayers online now: 2Free
DOG WITCH

DOG WITCH

Dog Witch is a roguelike deckbuilder where your spells are fueled by enchanted dice.

89% of 329 Steam reviews are positivePlayers online now: 1$9.99
For The Cat! Sorcerer's Revenge

For The Cat! Sorcerer's Revenge

Fire endless spells at swarming hordes, fuse elements into wilder magic, and grow strong enough to settle the score.

91% of 101 Steam reviews are positivePlayers online now: 14$5.99
Machick 2

Machick 2

A magical, chaotic roguelike-survivor. Craft insane wands, evolve and fuse powerful spells, equip crazy gear, and wield the power of divine relics.

88% of 612 Steam reviews are positive$5.24
Rift Wizard 2

Rift Wizard 2

Pick your spells and passives, then survive turn-based tactical fights across randomized runs as an immortal wizard hunting your nemesis.

91% of 748 Steam reviews are positivePlayers online now: 15$19.99
Wizard Shrimp

Wizard Shrimp

Wizard Shrimp™ is a bullet-hell roguelite game where you play as a Shrimp who is inexplicably also a Wizard?!

98% of 100 Steam reviews are positive$2.99
Sol Cesto

Sol Cesto

Descend a dark dungeon, bet on dice rolls and stack cursed relics to bend the odds your way.

91% of 5,014 Steam reviews are positivePlayers online now: 32$13.99
Tomb of the Bloodletter

Tomb of the Bloodletter

Tomb of the Bloodletter is a strategic word roguelike where your keyboard becomes your arsenal.

88% of 105 Steam reviews are positive$7.99
SpellRogue

SpellRogue

Turn dice into mana, shape spells from a growing pool, and fight through a grim world where every run plays out differently.

86% of 1,592 Steam reviews are positivePlayers online now: 26$19.99
Flick Shot Rogues

Flick Shot Rogues

Plan, Aim, Shoot! FLICK SHOT ROGUES blends the tactile satisfaction of flicking stuff across a table with the strategic depth of your favourite…

86% of 304 Steam reviews are positivePlayers online now: 1$14.99

Newest games like Magic Toenail

For The Cat! Sorcerer's Revenge

For The Cat! Sorcerer's Revenge

Fire endless spells at swarming hordes, fuse elements into wilder magic, and grow strong enough to settle the score.

91% of 101 Steam reviews are positivePlayers online now: 14$5.99
Reflection Witch

Reflection Witch

Reflection Witch is a new rougelike spin on classic brick-breaking games.

100% of 4 Steam reviews are positive$7.99
Wizard's Guide

Wizard's Guide

"Wizard's Guide" is a strategic RPG that combines "puzzle" and "rogue-lite" elements.

100% of 2 Steam reviews are positive$2.99
Rift Wizard 3

Rift Wizard 3

A hardcore turn-based roguelike where you build a wizard from over 500 spells and artifacts, then blast, summon or enchant your way through 20…

90% of 415 Steam reviews are positivePlayers online now: 94$19.99
Neophyte

Neophyte

A mini topdown action roguelike with chaotic spell-slinging hack-n-slash combat.

90% of 662 Steam reviews are positive$2.99
Tomb of the Bloodletter

Tomb of the Bloodletter

Tomb of the Bloodletter is a strategic word roguelike where your keyboard becomes your arsenal.

88% of 105 Steam reviews are positive$7.99
DOG WITCH

DOG WITCH

Dog Witch is a roguelike deckbuilder where your spells are fueled by enchanted dice.

89% of 329 Steam reviews are positivePlayers online now: 1$9.99
Folly Of The Wizards

Folly Of The Wizards

Folly Of The Wizards is a comedic 2D roguelike action game that puts you in the shoes of a clumsy wizard apprentice.

82% of 22 Steam reviews are positive$29.99
Flick Shot Rogues

Flick Shot Rogues

Plan, Aim, Shoot! FLICK SHOT ROGUES blends the tactile satisfaction of flicking stuff across a table with the strategic depth of your favourite…

86% of 304 Steam reviews are positivePlayers online now: 1$14.99
Magecraft: Spellbuilding

Magecraft: Spellbuilding

Craft spell cards, collect new effects, and build the perfect deck as you fight through rounds of turn-based combat.

98% of 154 Steam reviews are positivePlayers online now: 2Free
Machick 2

Machick 2

A magical, chaotic roguelike-survivor. Craft insane wands, evolve and fuse powerful spells, equip crazy gear, and wield the power of divine relics.

88% of 612 Steam reviews are positive$5.24