Games like Innocent Critters

If Innocent Critters left you wanting something replayable and tense, you have options. You will find a few strong contenders among these games. Plenty here let you team up if you like.

The Forest
After your jet goes down, you wake up alone in a strange forest that wants you dead. Chop trees, build shelter, find food, and hold your camp through the night against cannibal mutants. It is a harsh first-person survival horror about building by day and defending by night.
Also in Co-op · Replayable, Tense, Scary
95% of 585,687 Steam reviews are positivePlayers online now: 6,230$19.99
Panic In The Woods
A horror survival and extraction game playable in single player or co-op for up to 4 players. Lost in a creepy forest, you and your friends are hunted by a monster. Stay quiet while extracting keys through nightmarish realms using items like traps, sonars, and flare guns to survive!
Also in Co-op · Replayable, Tense, Scary
68% of 116 Steam reviews are positive$5.99
I will eat you
I will eat you! Run, hide, shout and try to survive in the game, full of fun and funny moments. Play with random players or with friends. But whatever you do, DO NOT ENTER THE DEN OF THE BEAST!
Also in Co-op · Tense, Scary, Cute
79% of 226 Steam reviews are positive$4.99
30 days to survive
"30 days to survive" - the game is going day, in a world where there is a zombie Apocalypse! The protagonist has to survive 30 days on a randomly generated map full of dead.
Replayable, Tense, Scary
76% of 100 Steam reviews are positive$5.99
MAZEBOUND: Hunt, Gather, Run!
A survival horror with a simple setup: sea behind you, a towering gate ahead, and a maze in between. Hunt, gather, craft crude weapons and keep moving, because the things inside are starving too. Play solo if you like being scared, or with friends if you like being scared together.
Also in Co-op · Replayable, Tense, Scary
82% of 614 Steam reviews are positivePlayers online now: 3$9.99
The Survivalists
A colorful survival sandbox on a procedurally generated island, where the real trick is putting monkeys to work. Tame them, train them to chop, mine, craft and fight, build a base, raid temples for treasure, and do it all with up to three friends. A lighter, friendlier take on survival, set in The Escapists universe.
Also in Co-op · Replayable, Cute, Colorful
76% of 8,133 Steam reviews are positivePlayers online now: 51$24.99
Don't Starve Together
Don't Starve Together is a standalone multiplayer expansion to Don't Starve about staying alive in a strange wilderness with friends. You gather, craft, farm and build a base while hunger, darkness and monsters test the group. Playing with friends is a big part of the fun, players keep one shared world going for a long time, and total time in the game can reach hundreds of hours.
Also in Co-op · Replayable, Tense, Scary
94% of 378,717 Steam reviews are positivePlayers online now: 51,558$14.99
INCUR Survival
A survival open-world game, where you can gather resources, Hunt, Craft tools and armor, Tame Animals, Ride Animals, Build, and defend your base from creatures, and other players.
Also in Co-op · Tense, Scary
80% of 100 Steam reviews are positive$3.99
Camp Wombo
Co-op survival horror game. Four friends must gather resources and repair their vehicle while surviving deadly creatures in a constantly changing forest.
Also in Co-op · Replayable, Tense, Scary
92% of 12 Steam reviews are positive$1.99
Nobody Sleeps Tonight
a survival horror game about finding your friend who disappears at night in a strange forest hiding a sinister secret.
Replayable, Tense, Scary
64% of 25 Steam reviews are positive$5.99
Chainsaw Woods
A survival horror game where you must escape from a forest you've gotten lost in. The forest is randomly generated each time you play. Supports online co-op for up to 2 players. Work together to escape from the forest!
Also in Co-op · Replayable, Tense, Scary
50% of 2 Steam reviews are positive$3.99
Don't Starve
Don't Starve drops gentleman scientist Wilson into a strange wilderness run by a demon, where you gather, craft, farm, hunt and fight to stay alive. No guidance, no second chances: every randomly generated world wants you dead, and learning its rules is the fun.
Replayable, Tense, Scary
96% of 97,338 Steam reviews are positivePlayers online now: 934$9.99

Hidden gems like Innocent Critters

MAZEBOUND: Hunt, Gather, Run!

A survival horror with a simple setup: sea behind you, a towering gate ahead, and a maze in between.

$9.99

Inferno Protocol

Scavenge, inject and shoot your way through a shifting labyrinth, building a settlement at its heart while you hunt for the way out, alone or with…

$13.49

Wild Woods

Wild Woods is a couch co-op game about brave little cats defending their wooden wagon through a dangerous forest.

$14.99

Escape from Playtime

You are a Smiling Critter, small and plush, loose in an abandoned toy factory with up to seven friends.

$9.99

Smalland: Survive the Wilds

You are tiny, the world is not. Smalland drops you into an oversized wilderness where puddles are lakes, ants want you for dinner and a grasshopper…

$34.99

INCUR Survival

A survival open-world game, where you can gather resources, Hunt, Craft tools and armor, Tame Animals, Ride Animals, Build, and defend your base…

$3.99

Forest Doesn’t Care

A peaceful life in nature or a fight for survival? Explore a realistic forest, survive, discover abandoned places, and uncover why the forest…

$13.99

Peregrino

Peregrino is a dark isometric survival adventure where you explore a cursed forest by day and manage your caravan by night.

$16.99

Panic In The Woods

A horror survival and extraction game playable in single player or co-op for up to 4 players.

$5.99

MISTERY

A multiplayer game of survival and social deduction. You work with others to collect materials, survive the dangers, and complete tasks.

$11.99

30 days to survive

"30 days to survive" - the game is going day, in a world where there is a zombie Apocalypse!

$5.99

I will eat you

I will eat you! Run, hide, shout and try to survive in the game, full of fun and funny moments. Play with random players or with friends.

$4.99

Newest games like Innocent Critters

Hazard Levels

Enter unstable rifts, survive otherworldly creatures, and grab bizarre ingredients to fuel a secret brewery hidden beneath a British pub.

$7.49

Barely Alive

A co-op survival party game. Hunt your friends or survive until sunrise.

$3.74

Escape from Playtime

You are a Smiling Critter, small and plush, loose in an abandoned toy factory with up to seven friends.

$9.99

Invokyr

Roll the dice, survive whatever the house sends, and play your way out of a cursed board game together.

$12.99

Inferno Protocol

Scavenge, inject and shoot your way through a shifting labyrinth, building a settlement at its heart while you hunt for the way out, alone or with…

$13.49

Holey

A co-op horror game where you are part of a crew sheltering in a collapsed tunnel, scavenging loot across maps filled with deadly creatures born…

$7.99

GRAIN ROT

Ride a cursed elevator down with friends, grab what you can from the ruins, and rebuild your Outpost before the Corrupted catch you.

$9.99

Camp Wombo

Co-op survival horror game. Four friends must gather resources and repair their vehicle while surviving deadly creatures in a constantly changing…

$1.99

Hunters In The Dark

A frantic party tag game for 1–4 players. Play as a Treasure Hunter racing for loot—or a Shadow Hunter chasing them down.

$5.35

MAZEBOUND: Hunt, Gather, Run!

A survival horror with a simple setup: sea behind you, a towering gate ahead, and a maze in between.

$9.99

Peregrino

Peregrino is a dark isometric survival adventure where you explore a cursed forest by day and manage your caravan by night.

$16.99

The Woods

Survive solo or team up with friends online on a vast forest island.

$9.99