Games like Critterball Derby

Still thinking about Critterball Derby and its colorful and cute tone? These games could fill that gap nicely.

Cheaper than Critterball Derby

Desktop BaseBall 2

Desktop BaseBall 2

Get ready for an all-new and improved baseball experience! Assemble an original team like no other!

75% of 4 Steam reviews are positive$5.99
2D Baseball Duel

2D Baseball Duel

Enter the battle of Pitcher vs. Batter! Challenge the single player teams to unlock their unique pitches, then battle your friends with the fast…

82% of 17 Steam reviews are positive$2.99
Home Run High

Home Run High

Train your baseball players and create a winning team!

73% of 161 Steam reviews are positivePlayers online now: 6$8.99
The TEAM game:Corgi&me

The TEAM game:Corgi&me

From a washed-up, obscure player to the star hitter of a... Welsh Corgi baseball team?!

100% of 6 Steam reviews are positive$5.99
Bottom of the 9th

Bottom of the 9th

Play the most exciting moment of baseball in this fast-paced dice and card game!

82% of 51 Steam reviews are positive$0.99
Super Psycho Baseball

Super Psycho Baseball

Welcome to Super Psycho Baseball, a sadistic home-run hitting roguelike in which you try to conquer a gang of pitch-slinging bosses, each more…

92% of 235 Steam reviews are positive$4.99
Koro-san's Home "WAN!" Derby

Koro-san's Home "WAN!" Derby

Koro-san just keeps hitting home runs! Koro-san loves baseball, so she invited all the Hololive Gamers to play baseball.

88% of 32 Steam reviews are positive$3.90
Old School Baseball

Old School Baseball

Step up for a retro arcade baseball experience! Master the batter-vs-pitcher duel, time your swing, and adapt as the field reshuffles every…

$5.59
Digital Diamond Baseball V8

Digital Diamond Baseball V8

Digital Diamond Baseball is a computerized baseball simulator that allows gamers to play individual games, series, or entire seasons, using players…

95% of 21 Steam reviews are positive$4.99
BASEBALL STARS 2

BASEBALL STARS 2

Lace up your cleats, and step onto the diamond with the pros of “BASEBALL STARS 2” on Steam!

80% of 83 Steam reviews are positivePlayers online now: 1$1.19
Baseball Legacy Manager 24

Baseball Legacy Manager 24

Build the ultimate legacy as the general manager of a professional baseball team!

38% of 8 Steam reviews are positive$8.99

Hidden gems like Critterball Derby

Backyard Baseball '01

Backyard Baseball '01

Backyard Baseball '01 puts 30 hilarious kids and 28 MLB legends on the same sandlot diamond.

93% of 680 Steam reviews are positivePlayers online now: 24$9.99
Super Psycho Baseball

Super Psycho Baseball

Welcome to Super Psycho Baseball, a sadistic home-run hitting roguelike in which you try to conquer a gang of pitch-slinging bosses, each more…

92% of 235 Steam reviews are positive$4.99
Backyard Baseball '97

Backyard Baseball '97

Pick a team of charming youngsters, step up to the plate and play everything from a quick game to a full season of lighthearted baseball.

97% of 2,254 Steam reviews are positivePlayers online now: 11$9.99
Backyard Baseball

Backyard Baseball

Draft a team of backyard kids, swing for the fences with silly power-ups, and play ball across six game modes.

81% of 1,349 Steam reviews are positivePlayers online now: 43$39.99
Out of the Park Baseball 27

Out of the Park Baseball 27

Take charge of a baseball organization from the draft to the dugout, at whatever pace you like.

82% of 566 Steam reviews are positivePlayers online now: 928$49.99
eBaseball™: PRO SPIRIT

eBaseball™: PRO SPIRIT

Build your own team, time every swing against live pitching, and climb into online matches where skill decides the winner.

78% of 1,924 Steam reviews are positivePlayers online now: 564Free
Out of the Park Baseball 26

Out of the Park Baseball 26

Take charge of a real baseball organization, from the draft board to the pitch you call in the ninth.

82% of 825 Steam reviews are positivePlayers online now: 190$49.99
Yerr Out

Yerr Out

🦅 wacky & competitive baseball game! 🦌 Unlock over 100+ animals to assemble your team, each with different attributes 🐂

87% of 149 Steam reviews are positiveFree
MLB 9 Innings Rivals 26

MLB 9 Innings Rivals 26

Time your swing, outsmart the batter pitch by pitch, and carry a live 2026 roster through a full season or online matchups.

79% of 1,832 Steam reviews are positivePlayers online now: 896Free
Super Mega Baseball™ 4

Super Mega Baseball™ 4

Step up to the plate in a colorful arcade baseball game where Legends, tight pitching duels and cross-platform matches keep every inning worth…

80% of 1,358 Steam reviews are positivePlayers online now: 88$49.99
Super Mega Baseball 3

Super Mega Baseball 3

Pitch, hit and steal through tight at-bats, with difficulty that bends to your level and seasons to build a team around.

92% of 1,834 Steam reviews are positivePlayers online now: 15$44.99
TOTALLY BASEBALL

TOTALLY BASEBALL

Play the full sport of Baseball (every position) on your own or with your friends in VR!

86% of 153 Steam reviews are positive$14.99

Newest games like Critterball Derby

CUSTOM PENNANT BASEBALL

CUSTOM PENNANT BASEBALL

Run a fictional baseball club across many seasons as general manager.

70% of 30 Steam reviews are positivePlayers online now: 1$14.99
Cricket Management 26

Cricket Management 26

Build your cricketing dynasty in a deep and immersive cricket management simulation.

69% of 35 Steam reviews are positive$17
Hakoniwa Base Ball

Hakoniwa Base Ball

Draft, trade and manage a whole league of up to 30 teams, then watch seasons unfold at your own pace.

100% of 37 Steam reviews are positivePlayers online now: 23$9.99
Backyard Baseball

Backyard Baseball

Draft a team of backyard kids, swing for the fences with silly power-ups, and play ball across six game modes.

81% of 1,349 Steam reviews are positivePlayers online now: 43$39.99
Road to Omaha: College Baseball Dynasty

Road to Omaha: College Baseball Dynasty

A deep college baseball dynasty management sim where you build a program across endless seasons: recruit, set lineups and rotations, hire staff…

71% of 17 Steam reviews are positive$19.99
The TEAM game:Corgi&me

The TEAM game:Corgi&me

From a washed-up, obscure player to the star hitter of a... Welsh Corgi baseball team?!

100% of 6 Steam reviews are positive$5.99
Game Pulse Payoff Pitch

Game Pulse Payoff Pitch

Game Pulse is a tabletop-inspired baseball strategy sim based on Payoff Pitch—manage lineups, make critical decisions, and play or simulate full…

82% of 11 Steam reviews are positivePlayers online now: 7$49.95
Indoor Baseball

Indoor Baseball

Play a fast paced game of 1v1 baseball where your parents wouldn't let you.

78% of 18 Steam reviews are positive$14.99
holoBase

holoBase

Enjoy real baseball action with hololive talents!! Create your own team with talents, fans, and mascots, and dive into intense, exciting games!

69% of 13 Steam reviews are positive$12.99
Out of the Park Baseball 27

Out of the Park Baseball 27

Take charge of a baseball organization from the draft to the dugout, at whatever pace you like.

82% of 566 Steam reviews are positivePlayers online now: 928$49.99
eBaseball™: PRO SPIRIT

eBaseball™: PRO SPIRIT

Build your own team, time every swing against live pitching, and climb into online matches where skill decides the winner.

78% of 1,924 Steam reviews are positivePlayers online now: 564Free
Tabletop Baseball

Tabletop Baseball

A physics-powered arcade baseball blast! Time your swing, rack up runs, and climb classic high score tables.

100% of 6 Steam reviews are positive$4.99