Games like Blackbeard's Treasure

If Blackbeard's Treasure left you wanting something fast-paced and replayable, you have options. These games line up well for what comes next.

Cheaper than Blackbeard's Treasure

Treasure Drop

Treasure Drop

Dive into treasure filled depths! Merge coins and gems, keep them in the dome, and build the ultimate fortune.

$4.99
Shovel Pirate

Shovel Pirate

X marks the spot! Follow the map and find hidden treasures.

92% of 60 Steam reviews are positive$2.99
Plunder Islands

Plunder Islands

A fast paced 2D platformer, Plunder Islands has you running, jumping and climbing for treasure. Are you ready for the challenges the islands reveal?

100% of 2 Steam reviews are positive$1.19
Plunder Bay

Plunder Bay

An online pirate board game for 2–6 players. Sail scattered islands, blast rivals with cannons and rockets, and STEAL their treasure when you sink…

100% of 1 Steam reviews are positive$3.99
Captain Pegleg

Captain Pegleg

Captain Pegleg goes on a treasure hunt and tries to hijack a new ship to escape while his crew is…. doing absolutely nothing!?

75% of 4 Steam reviews are positive$1.99
Island Treasures

Island Treasures

Island Treasures: 2D pixel action-adventure.Play as Jack. Slash or throw daggers.Collect gold & Golden Skulls.Find keys & chests for map fragments.

88% of 8 Steam reviews are positive$1.99
Pirate Treasure: Tidy Up!

Pirate Treasure: Tidy Up!

Attention, greenhorn! Prove you’re worthy of joining the crew by tidying up our chaotic treasure vault.

67% of 6 Steam reviews are positivePlayers online now: 10$4.19
Pirates Pinball

Pirates Pinball

Be a Pirate and find the tresure in t he most entertaining Pinball!

75% of 4 Steam reviews are positive$2.99
Treasure's Mine!

Treasure's Mine!

Build defenses on randomly generated archipelagos and fend off waves of pirates!

100% of 21 Steam reviews are positive$4.99
Sea of Treasures

Sea of Treasures

Sea of Treasures is an exciting 2D platformer that takes you on an epic adventure through multiple islands in search of the legendary treasure map.

67% of 3 Steam reviews are positive$1.99
Cobi Treasure Deluxe

Cobi Treasure Deluxe

Help Sally the seahorse collect and match ocean treasures before they fall to the seabed.

75% of 65 Steam reviews are positive$2.99
Corsair`s Madness

Corsair`s Madness

As the captain of the pirate ship Sam, you'll dive into the adventure of a mystical archipelago brimming with secrets and treasures.

88% of 17 Steam reviews are positive$3.19

Hidden gems like Blackbeard's Treasure

Last Pirates: Die Together

Last Pirates: Die Together

Rip loot from a haunted island with your crew and try to keep someone alive on the way back to the ship.

77% of 426 Steam reviews are positivePlayers online now: 19$7.99
Rock the Islands

Rock the Islands

A colorful island adventure where you mine gems, sell loot, and rescue captives from goblins who then work for you.

89% of 345 Steam reviews are positivePlayers online now: 56Free
Blazing Sails

Blazing Sails

Man the cannons, patch the hull and board rival ships in quick, rowdy PvP battles on bright open seas.

87% of 8,448 Steam reviews are positivePlayers online now: 82$14.99
Journey of Greed

Journey of Greed

You and three rivals loot the lost islands, and only the one who escapes with the most coins wins.

89% of 1,176 Steam reviews are positive$6.99
Coin Treasures

Coin Treasures

Coin Treasures is a Coin Pusher/Coin Dozer on Steroids including incremental progress, realistic physics, numerous upgrades & unlocks and stunning…

75% of 161 Steam reviews are positivePlayers online now: 2Free
Puzzle Plunder

Puzzle Plunder

Puzzle Plunder is a Pirate themed match 3 game with stat building elements.

86% of 176 Steam reviews are positivePlayers online now: 1Free
Puzzle Pirates: Dark Seas

Puzzle Pirates: Dark Seas

Every activity in Puzzle Pirates is a uniquely fun puzzle: be it sailing, gunning, or hauling treasure, your own puzzling skill determines your…

73% of 533 Steam reviews are positiveFree
The Pirate: Caribbean Hunt

The Pirate: Caribbean Hunt

Sail a fleet of pirate ships across an open sea, trading and raiding your way through the Age of Piracy.

82% of 4,674 Steam reviews are positivePlayers online now: 33Free
Sea of Thieves: 2026 Edition

Sea of Thieves: 2026 Edition

Sail with your crew, raise sails, fire cannons, dig up treasure, and let the sea decide how the day goes.

88% of 323,290 Steam reviews are positive$39.99
Archipelago

Archipelago

Archipelago is a small, funny pirate strategy game: you lead a crew of up to four pirates across tropical islands, snatch golden chests from under…

72% of 127 Steam reviews are positive$5.99
Out of Reach: Treasure Royale

Out of Reach: Treasure Royale

Treasure Royale is a Battle Royale style game in which dozens of pirate crews face each other on the open sea, jungle islands and dark caves.

58% of 338 Steam reviews are positive$14.99
Puzzle Pirates

Puzzle Pirates

Work the decks with quick mini-games, sail with a crew, and trade your plunder in a player-run economy.

80% of 2,308 Steam reviews are positivePlayers online now: 403Free

Newest games like Blackbeard's Treasure

Curse of Pirates

Curse of Pirates

Ahoy, matey! How about slicing up some sea beasts and sending a couple of rivals to feed the kraken?

81% of 138 Steam reviews are positive$7.99
Last Pirates: Die Together

Last Pirates: Die Together

Rip loot from a haunted island with your crew and try to keep someone alive on the way back to the ship.

77% of 426 Steam reviews are positivePlayers online now: 19$7.99
Treasure's Mine!

Treasure's Mine!

Build defenses on randomly generated archipelagos and fend off waves of pirates!

100% of 21 Steam reviews are positive$4.99
Island Treasures

Island Treasures

Island Treasures: 2D pixel action-adventure.Play as Jack. Slash or throw daggers.Collect gold & Golden Skulls.Find keys & chests for map fragments.

88% of 8 Steam reviews are positive$1.99
The Coin Game

The Coin Game

Rack up tickets on wobbly arcade machines, cash them in for goofy prizes, and let the physics do the rest.

92% of 5,666 Steam reviews are positivePlayers online now: 10$13.39
Poor Piggy Pirate

Poor Piggy Pirate

Oink Oink, Sailor! Steer your cute piggy (and many other critters) through wild waters and watch out for the wild bunny pirates!

100% of 5 Steam reviews are positive$0.99
Queen of treasure isle

Queen of treasure isle

Poor Windy has come to search for the treasure hidden on the island.

95% of 105 Steam reviews are positive$8.99
Cat Quest III

Cat Quest III

Sail a colorful open sea as a cat captain, slash through Pi-rats and chase a lost treasure with a friend by your side.

94% of 3,159 Steam reviews are positivePlayers online now: 32$19.99
Rock the Islands

Rock the Islands

A colorful island adventure where you mine gems, sell loot, and rescue captives from goblins who then work for you.

89% of 345 Steam reviews are positivePlayers online now: 56Free
Corsair`s Madness

Corsair`s Madness

As the captain of the pirate ship Sam, you'll dive into the adventure of a mystical archipelago brimming with secrets and treasures.

88% of 17 Steam reviews are positive$3.19
Treasure Journey

Treasure Journey

A charming puzzle adventure where you'll guide a pirate across uncharted islands to uncover hidden treasures!

100% of 2 Steam reviews are positive$5.99