Games like Amalgamare

Remember how story-driven and dark Amalgamare felt at its best? These games offer a similar pull for your backlog.

Ameshidama
This is a horror adventure game where you guide a lonely girl into the outside world. The girl is stuck in a small room, alone and unable to go outside. She dreams of the outside. What is outside? Why can't she go outside? Even after learning the reason, will you still take her outside?
Story-driven, Dark, Mysterious
100% of 27 Steam reviews are positiveFree
Trick & Treat
A young witch and her pumpkin maid go trick or treating and end up in a cursed mansion. Explore its rooms, solve gentle puzzles, dance with ghosts and dodge nine dead ends on the way to true love. Short, spooky and sweet, about 90 minutes of it.
Story-driven, Mysterious, Atmospheric
96% of 2,429 Steam reviews are positiveFree
Alicemare
Alicemare is a short adventure about Allen, a boy who has lost his memory and his parents, and the home for lost children that takes him in. One rumor leads him into a dream world built from fairy tales, where five children hide five sad stories. Cute pixel art, a lovely soundtrack and just a hint of horror make it an evening well spent.
Story-driven, Dark, Mysterious
88% of 1,150 Steam reviews are positivePlayers online now: 1$2.99
Mr. Hopp's Playhouse 2
A young girl needs to find her friends, unravel a dark mystery and escape the clutches of her cursed toys.
Story-driven, Dark, Mysterious
93% of 628 Steam reviews are positivePlayers online now: 1$3.99
Mayor May Knott
A creepy-cozy 3D adventure game about solving puzzles, rebuilding a haunted ghost town, meeting weird creatures, and listening to ridiculous music!
Story-driven, Mysterious, Atmospheric
100% of 214 Steam reviews are positive$24.99
Cat in the Box
A horror adventure about a girl who brings a camera to a cult's abandoned mansion and finds the exit gone. Search for keys and clues, dodge what hunts the halls, and pick your way through five endings in a tense, atmospheric pixel-art night.
Story-driven, Dark, Mysterious
93% of 1,447 Steam reviews are positivePlayers online now: 2$6.99
Amihailu in Dreamland
A magical, dreamy adventure starring Amihailu Dugashoba and her friends! You'll wander the echoey and endless halls and spooky painting worlds to solve the mystery and escape the fantasy world. Or you would solve the mystery... if anything Amihailu said made a grain of sense!
Story-driven, Mysterious, Atmospheric
81% of 36 Steam reviews are positiveFree
At Home Alone Final
A little girl is home alone while her mom works, and a day of hide-and-seek, kittens and snacks slowly turns into something else. This pixel adventure hides a looping, twisting mystery behind its cute face, with multiple endings and a story that rewards a second look. Sweet on the surface, quietly unsettling underneath.
Story-driven, Dark, Mysterious
96% of 8,261 Steam reviews are positivePlayers online now: 2Free
Amygdala
Welcome to Amygdala, seeker of nightmares. In the presence of the Absolute Judge, you are assigned a task that only you can accomplish. Immerse yourself in this place made of emotions. Discover unique creatures called 'lords of nightmares' and uncover the beauties of horror in this unique adventure.
Story-driven, Dark, Mysterious
72% of 184 Steam reviews are positive$6.66
At Home Alone II
A recreational healing Mini-plot game explored at home. Players will play and wander around the house from the perspective of a little girl. What will she do when she is alone? What strange stories will happen in the process? and in the process of exploration, you may find some strange secrets....
Story-driven, Dark, Mysterious
86% of 220 Steam reviews are positive$1.99
Night in the Woods
Mae Borowski drops out of college and comes home to Possum Springs, a fading mining town where her friends have moved on and something stirs in the woods. A hand-drawn story about growing up, with sharp jokes, characters who feel real, and a mystery that gets darker the longer you stay.
Story-driven, Dark, Mysterious
94% of 18,193 Steam reviews are positivePlayers online now: 162$19.99
Moi Mei
The fate of his brother in danger, May is going to be a dangerous journey.
Story-driven, Dark, Mysterious
78% of 27 Steam reviews are positive$7.99

Hidden gems like Amalgamare

Mayor May Knott

A creepy-cozy 3D adventure game about solving puzzles, rebuilding a haunted ghost town, meeting weird creatures, and listening to ridiculous music!

$24.99

Out of Sight

You’re Sophie, a young blind girl who sees through her teddy bear’s eyes.

$9.99

Fear the Spotlight

A séance in an abandoned school goes wrong, Amy vanishes, and Vivian is left alone with a monster that hunts by light.

$19.99

GYLT

Guide Sally through a twisted, dreamlike town, sneaking past its monsters and piecing together what happened to her cousin.

$19.99

Amanda the Adventurer 2

Riley thought the tapes were over. Then a masked stranger mentions Aunt Kate, and the trail leads to the Kensdale Public Library, where Amanda is no…

$9.99

Amanda the Adventurer

Watch old tapes, answer a talking TV and puzzle your way to one of five endings.

$8.99

Tide Up

Tide Up is a rather dark and gloomy adventure game. Accompany the girl in a dreamlike world of wonder.

$7.99

Amelie

A psychological mystery yuri visual novel about a girl named Amelie.

$3.99

Mr. Hopp's Playhouse 2

A young girl needs to find her friends, unravel a dark mystery and escape the clutches of her cursed toys.

$3.99

At Home Alone Final

You play a young girl spending the day alone at home, where small adventures and strange visitors hide a looping mystery.

Free

Cat in the Box

Explore a cult's abandoned mansion with a camera, solve what holds it shut, and survive what walks inside.

$6.99

Midnight: Submersion - Nightmare Horror Story

Nightmare Horror Story an adventure game from the first face in a horror genre provides you to take a trip in a huge and dark city full of dummies.

$4.99

Newest games like Amalgamare

The Day of Revenge

The story takes place in a fictional world of sword and sorcery.

$1.99

Mayor May Knott

A creepy-cozy 3D adventure game about solving puzzles, rebuilding a haunted ghost town, meeting weird creatures, and listening to ridiculous music!

$24.99

Mar

Mar is a first person low quality small horror game where your only task is to escape monster by searching for specific items to escape each location.

Free

Ameshidama

This is a horror adventure game where you guide a lonely girl into the outside world.

Free

Out of Sight

You’re Sophie, a young blind girl who sees through her teddy bear’s eyes.

$9.99

Fear the Spotlight

A séance in an abandoned school goes wrong, Amy vanishes, and Vivian is left alone with a monster that hunts by light.

$19.99

Amanda the Adventurer 2

Riley thought the tapes were over. Then a masked stranger mentions Aunt Kate, and the trail leads to the Kensdale Public Library, where Amanda is no…

$9.99

Amygdala

Welcome to Amygdala, seeker of nightmares. In the presence of the Absolute Judge, you are assigned a task that only you can accomplish.

$6.66

Dreams of the Void

May Campbell moved to the island of Cassiopeia years ago to live with her grandfather. Now, she tries to survive day by day in a rotting world.

$4.99

GYLT

Guide Sally through a twisted, dreamlike town, sneaking past its monsters and piecing together what happened to her cousin.

$19.99

Amanda the Adventurer

Watch old tapes, answer a talking TV and puzzle your way to one of five endings.

$8.99

Kitty May Cry

Kitty May Cry is a 3D open world adventure-puzzle game in which you take on the role of a black kitty cat, stranded upon a little island chock-full…

$8.99