Co-op games like Polylithic

If Polylithic left you wanting something colorful and cute, you have options. You will find a few strong contenders among these co-op games. You can bring friends along for most of these.

Sapiens
Sapiens is a prehistoric colony sim where you guide a small tribe from bare hands to towns and industry. In multiplayer you team up with co-op friends to raise cities, split jobs, and trade across a huge procedurally generated world, with no PvP to spoil the plan.
Also in Survival crafting and Colony sim · Colorful, Replayable
79% of 2,080 Steam reviews are positivePlayers online now: 20$24.99
Re.poly
Re.Poly is a relaxed yet deep indie survival game in a low-poly style that blends exploration, combat, building, and adventure. Whether alone or with friends, create your own world, write your own story, and decide how you want to play.
Also in Survival crafting and Colony sim · Colorful, Cute, Replayable
91% of 116 Steam reviews are positive$19.99
Stonies
Stonies – Secure the survival of your kin! Play the gripping mix of life simulation and tycoon game now and accompany your Stonies through their prehistoric life. Prove your skill as a Stone Age leader in Stonies.
Also in Survival crafting and Colony sim · Cute
53% of 453 Steam reviews are positivePlayers online now: 5Free
Stone Rage
Stone Rage is a prehistoric, open-world survival game. Play as a Cro-Magnon or Neanderthal and shape-shift into beasts as you secure your place in a harsh landscape of dangerous animals, scarce resources, and unforgiving climates. Make friends and enemies. Build. Fight. Survive.
Also in Survival crafting
40% of 110 Steam reviews are positive$4.99
In Next Life
An online multiplayer game of crafting, survival, civilization building, and player collaboration. Start in the stone age and live, build, and invent your way to higher civilization. Live and die as well as you can, to gain the experience you need to achieve even more in your next life!
Also in Survival crafting and Colony sim · Replayable
66% of 156 Steam reviews are positivePlayers online now: 3Free
Colony Survival
A first-person colony sim in a voxel world where you recruit farmers, miners and guards, then hold the walls each night against the monster horde. Easy to run as co-op, with shared colonies, trading and long tech progress from slings to gunpowder.
Also in Survival crafting and Colony sim · Replayable
92% of 8,292 Steam reviews are positivePlayers online now: 111$24.95
Journey Of Life
You have experienced the sudden loss of your wealth, which has compelled you to abandon your previous life and begin anew. By venturing into the game world, you can construct settlements and forge alliances with other players, ensuring that you will always have exciting challenges to undertake.
Also in Survival crafting and Colony sim
55% of 598 Steam reviews are positive$14.99
Trials of Wilderness
You are alone on an island, trying desperately to survive amongst the village tribes of savages. To do this you need food, water, and shelter. Hunt animals, plant crops, tame and breed animals, make weapons, armors and potions, raid villages, defend your base, fight with big creatures...
Also in Survival crafting
70% of 131 Steam reviews are positiveFree
Native Hunter
Inspired by an existing indigenous tribe, where they live on an island called "North Sentinel Island". Native Hunter gives the player the possibility of living the experience in the body of an indigenous person completely isolated from society, just like the Sentinelese do.
Also in Survival crafting · Replayable
72% of 60 Steam reviews are positive$17.99
Nested Lands
Nested Lands is a dark medieval settlement RPG where you raise a village in plague country alone or with co-op friends. You recruit peasants, assign jobs, build and craft, then hold the walls against bandits, weather and sickness. Grim, busy and best shared.
Also in Survival crafting and Colony sim · Replayable
73% of 531 Steam reviews are positivePlayers online now: 20$14.99
Vantage: Primitive Survival Game
Vantage is a passion project created by a solo developer where your main objective is simple... to stay alive! You explore the massive world searching for food, creating primitive tools and weapons to hunt, and craft other items to make life easier. Play Online/Offline Multiplayer or Single Player.
Also in Survival crafting
55% of 67 Steam reviews are positive$14.99
Ice Age
As primitive human, in the wild Ice Age prehistoric world, Hunt and tame wild beasts such as mammoths and sabretooth, build homes, and survive.
Also in Survival crafting
55% of 51 Steam reviews are positive$9.99

Cheaper than Polylithic

Stone Rage

Stone Rage is a prehistoric, open-world survival game. Play as a Cro-Magnon or Neanderthal and shape-shift into beasts as you secure your place in a…

$4.99

Ice Age

As primitive human, in the wild Ice Age prehistoric world, Hunt and tame wild beasts such as mammoths and sabretooth, build homes, and survive.

$9.99

Romestead

Rome has fallen and the dead walk at night, so you and up to seven co-op friends rebuild it together.

$13.99

Survival: Fountain of Youth

Craft, build and sail from island to island, following old clues toward a legend while keeping your camp alive.

$9.79

Subsistence

Subsistence is a first-person open-world survival game for solo or co-op PvE, where you and co-op friends build a base through changing seasons…

$13.99

Fera: The Sundered Tribes

Fera: The Sundered Tribes is an enthralling mixture of monster hunting survival action RPG with village building and tribe management with…

$9.99

DeadPoly

DeadPoly is a blocky zombie survival shooter where survival is the only required goal.

$9.99

The Faraway Land

The Faraway Land is an open world survival simulator. Plunge into the relaxing atmosphere of a magical world filled with cute and dangerous creatures.

$9.99

Caveman Craig

A strategy/survival game set in a prehistoric world of dinosaurs and cavemen.

$4.99

Force of Nature

Force of Nature is a sandbox survival-craft game across more than 10 zones with their own plants and animals.

$7.99

SkyPrimal

From a lone castaway with bare hands to the chief of a tribe. Primal tribes share this land.

$6.99

Lodventure

Embark on a 1-4 players Co-op survival adventure in an open world wilderness in search of a myth called the Lod Stone.

$3.74

Hidden gems like Polylithic

The Last Plague: Blight

A grim medieval survival sim you can share with co-op friends: boil water, cook exact recipes, build a shelter off the grid, and hold back a…

$16.99

Nested Lands

Nested Lands is a dark medieval settlement RPG where you raise a village in plague country alone or with co-op friends.

$14.99

Romestead

Rome has fallen and the dead walk at night, so you and up to seven co-op friends rebuild it together.

$13.99

Survival: Fountain of Youth

Craft, build and sail from island to island, following old clues toward a legend while keeping your camp alive.

$9.79

Pathless Woods

A cozy open-world survival game set in a land inspired by ancient China, made for four friends to share.

$19.99

Plains of Pain

A scorched sandbox built for co-op friends to survive together: share thirst, heat and bandit trouble, raise a base into a settlement, craft hover…

$19.99

AColony

A colony building game with an emphasis on unexpected events, online co-op, and managing a unique community.

$19.99

Don't get lost

A procedurally-generated, open-world, first-person colony sim.

Free

Smalland: Survive the Wilds

Smalland shrinks you to insect size in a wild overgrown world, then hands you up to nine co-op friends to survive it with.

$34.99

Soulmask

Soulmask is an open-world survival crafting game where you and co-op friends share one ancient world, recruit barbarians, possess them through…

$29.99

INCUR Survival

A survival open-world game, where you can gather resources, Hunt, Craft tools and armor, Tame Animals, Ride Animals, Build, and defend your base…

$3.99

Sapiens

Sapiens is a prehistoric colony sim where you guide a small tribe from bare hands to towns and industry.

$24.99

Newest co-op games like Polylithic